3 ms·
> We used to hate Microsoft for much less than this. I wonder how Apple can still have so many fans, even on this forum. If you build a lifestyle product, peop
by smoldesu 5y ago
> We used to hate Microsoft for much less than this. I wonder how Apple can still have so many fans, even on this forum.
If you build a lifestyle product, people can and will struggle to separate their own identity from the products they own. People take an insult on Apple like it's an insult on them, which is not a basis for healthy discourse in the slightest. We end up with apologist takes like "I actually like having 30% of my revenue forfeited to Apple because [they deserve it | I would have given it to them anyways | it's not that much | (YOUR EXCUSE HERE)]" that don't really do anything to diffuse the situation.
Unfortunately, this dysfunction is not exclusive to technology, it's a problem with capitalism as a whole. The same "thought guards" exist with other lifestyle brands like Disney, Gucci, Ferrari, and anyone else who sells the idea of elitism to people who lack self-respect.
- scarface74 5y agoSo 60% of the US population have iPhones because it’s a “lifestyle product”?
- smoldesu 5y agoSure. The "blue bubble" effect is strongest in the United States, and Apple's most iconic catchphrase under Steve Jobs was "it just works". If that's not the hallmark of a technology product being adapted to a lifestyle product, I'm really not sure what is.
- scarface74 5y agoSo you believe that 60% of Americans on average spend twice as much on iPhone, just for the “blue bubble”? There couldn’t possibly be any other reason? So technology products shouldn’t “just work”?
- smoldesu 5y agoThe "blue bubble" isn't just about iMessage, it's a colloquialism for how Apple's social marketing works. They have proprietary, closed protocols like Airdrop and Facetime that intentionally create friction between people on iOS and Android. It's a phrase for their marketing gimmicks that make vulnerable shoppers buy the products their friends have because they don't want to be left out. It's about the fashion statement and social pressure that goes into buying and owning a phone; Apple markets themselves as the solution to that. Much in the same way that celebrities spend inordinate amounts of money on useless and gaudy accessories, the iPhone is a token of mediocre wealth and being socially "in".
- scarface74 5y agoAnd 60% of the US population fall for this marketing? Google makes 80% of their revenue from ad sales and they can’t convince more than 40% of people to buy their supposedly superior OS? Are the US so full of dummies compared to the rest of the world that we are succumbing to Apple’s nefarious marketing? People have been saying that the only reason people buy Apple products since the iPod was introduced in 2001. The rest of the industry has had 20 years to catch up with Apple if it were that easy, they couldn’t? Also Google has how many active and failed messenger apps in the last decade?
- smoldesu 5y ago> And 60% of the US population fall for this marketing? Sure. They spend more money on it than any other company does. > Google makes 80% of their revenue from ad sales and they can’t convince more than 40% of people to buy their supposedly superior OS? First off, this is a false dichotomy. The 80% you're referencing is not what they spend on actual marketing of any of their products. Secondly, I don't believe I ever called Android superior, or even insinuated that superiority was a component here. The average first-worlder doesn't give a shit about what the "superior product" is, this rings true for every market: cars, computers, TVs, and cell phones. Everything is disposable in the end, as long as they get their money's worth they're happy. Such is life under capitalism. > The rest of the industry has had 20 years to catch up with Apple if it were that easy, they couldn’t? The rest of the industry has no interest in building walled gardens and exclusive experiences. Apple is unique in that they have a massive software ecosystem of protocols and applications that they have made impossible to use on third-party devices. If any other company tried this without a majority share of the hardware market, it would be a suicide mission. > Also Google has how many active and failed messenger apps in the last decade? I don't really see how this is pertinent. If Apple really wanted to change the world of messenger apps, they could put iMessage on other platforms (hell, they could charge a fee for it if they want extra capitalism cookie points). They didn't. The argument here is that Apple has no right to abuse their position in the market to extort developers for an arbitrary amount of money without competitors in that space. Apple is the largest company in the world; their antitrust scrutiny deserves to be through the roof, and actions like this are going to ultimately bury them when regulators come knocking. You're entitled to use whatever you want, but this isn't about individual technology politics (as much as Apple would like to frame it that way). This is about a large-scale failure of regulation, and the complete lack of consequence for refusing to build technology that empowers everyone.
- brimble 5y agoYeah, weird. I thought I was an (softish) Android fan who got converted to Apple by working at a place developing on both platforms, and being exposed daily to just how much wildly better an experience my phones and tablets could be. Guess I was wrong.
- smoldesu 5y agoYou're obviously entitled to your own opinions, but your experience as a software developer doesn't reflect the experiences or thought process of the average American at all.
- scarface74 5y agoHe is saying he had a much better experience on iPhone. The average American is buying iPhones 60% to 40%.
- brimble 5y agoIt was both factors. Both user-stuff and developer-stuff were far more pleasant on i-devices. And because of testing needs, I got to use a huge range of devices from both ecosystems. I don't develop in my spare time on my i-devices, so gain none of the benefits of the nicer development experience directly. I use them for tons of stuff, but I don't write personal software for them (never had a need to). [EDIT] To head off any "but I think Android development is nicer"—most of the bad things about it don't kick in until you're working at (even smallish) scale. Much of it's due to the huge range of versions, customizations (Samsung's alternative web view implementation, say), and device capabilities in the wild. It's probably somewhat easier to develop for than iOS if you're targeting just your own device or small set of devices, are free to make the UI whatever you like rather than having to style it to be "on brand", et c.
- brimble 5y agoIf all the folks who think Apple is all flash & marketing with no substance would get together and make products that are actually competitive with Apple's on substance, that'd be awesome and they might well get my business.