2 ms·
The internet is a globally-accessible system controlled by no single authority, too, with an awful lot of Turing-complete systems using it. The smarter question
by acdha 5y ago
The internet is a globally-accessible system controlled by no single authority, too, with an awful lot of Turing-complete systems using it. The smarter question to ask is what problems require a global append-only database with code execution capabilities, and how much value there is in that approach relative to the much cheaper alternatives. Using a blockchain locks in significant costs relative to everything else so there has to be a really compelling answer to that question to be worth the extra cost and risk.
- jqpabc123 5y agoBlockchain only works if you can print/mint the money needed to pay for the operation. Otherwise, there are faster/cheaper/simpler alternatives.
- acdha 5y agoAlso ask whether the entire system can live on the blockchain. If it needs trusted third-parties to provide data, broker deals, etc. all of the overhead isn’t giving you much.
- sshine 5y ago> The smarter question to ask is what problems require a global append-only database with code execution capabilities Global financial systems? > how much value there is in that Value is subjective. > there has to be a really compelling answer to that question to be worth the extra cost and risk. Somehow I sense that you're not compelled. That's okay.
- acdha 5y ago> > The smarter question to ask is what problems require a global append-only database with code execution capabilities > Global financial systems? Clearly not since those have functioned for centuries without one. You can argue it could be more efficient than the status quo but it can’t possibly be a requirement to use more compute capacity than the entire world had only a few years earlier. > Somehow I sense that you're not compelled. That's okay. Well, I do tend to require something in the way of evidence.