3 ms·
> For urban liberals, that means confronting some uncomfortable choices. A public space (and transit is public) is supposed to be open to all, but if we want pu
by mschuster91 5y ago
> For urban liberals, that means confronting some uncomfortable choices. A public space (and transit is public) is supposed to be open to all, but if we want public spaces to be livable, that probably means smells and behaviors are more tightly regulated in public, either through direct enforcement by transit police (unlikely) or more social pressure (also unlikely).
All you list here is repressive regulation, with all the problems that come with it - e.g. both unintended (correlation between homelessness distribution and ethnicity) and intended (discriminatory behavior by police) racism.
The worst problem in public from a safety point of view are homeless and mentally unstable people, and then "wild urination" and litter. To use police against the first two is just plain inhumane even if it's the sad "standard" - the solution to these problems are affordable housing and accessible mental health care. Using repression only shifts the problem to somewhere else, it does not solve the problem.
As for wild urination and litter, the issue here is that public toilets and trash bins are scarce. In Munich for example, trains used to have litter bins at every seat, buses and trams had tiny litter bins bins for tickets and small litter and a lot of subway stations had public, free-to-use toilets - both were cut due to cost-cutting, and then the problems arose.
- ryukafalz 5y ago> As for wild urination and litter, the issue here is that public toilets and trash bins are scarce. Yes! I don't get why more people (and elected officials) don't realize this. The city I live in (Philadelphia) has approximately zero public toilets. Many of our train stations also constantly smell of urine. These two things seem related?
- mschuster91 5y ago> Yes! I don't get why more people (and elected officials) don't realize this. They realize, but they don't care. Their equation is: Why put in public taxpayer money (and thus, risk their own "political capital") for a service that's: - mostly going to be used by homeless (and a few people with medical issues like IBS) - going to be constantly vandalized (graffiti), mistreated (discarding tampons and condoms in toilets is a "classic"), abused ("glory holes", drug consumption, ...) or in questionable hygienic conditions (e.g. people flinging poo to the walls and ceilings), requiring a significant maintenance budget - mostly going to improve the quality of a service (public transit) that mostly poor and other down-on-their-luck people are using when the ones that vote for the politicians don't profit? Not to mention that many small city/town budgets are already severely under strain. Middle-class and rich people and companies don't need public transport, they have cars, and they don't need public toilets as they have toilets at home, at their employment place and if need be can afford to buy a snack at a restaurant to use their toilet. That perverse incentive is why it needs regulation of minimum standards for urban areas at a state or better federal level.
- ryukafalz 5y ago> Middle-class and rich people and companies don't need public transport, they have cars This I think misses the geometric constraint here: in particularly dense city centers, there isn't really room for cars. I'm fairly well-off and have a car in the city, but I wouldn't bother trying to drive it around here, because it's honestly less convenient than taking public transport. You can drive to your destination fairly quickly, but you then have to find a place to park the car and walk from there to where you're going. In Center City especially, that can take nearly as long as the drive there in the first place. No thanks. My car mostly only gets used when I want to leave the city.
- ryan_lane 5y ago> mostly going to be used by homeless (and a few people with medical issues like IBS) This is a weird trope, and also just generally cruel. First: when public restrooms are generally available, they tend to be well used (I use them frequently in Tokyo, for instance). Second: even if they are mostly used by the homeless, that's good for them and us, because it means they have a humane place to use the bathroom, and it means we see less feces on the street and fewer places smell like piss.
- mschuster91 5y agoI'm not describing my own viewpoint here, but the thought train of average centrist to right-wing politician. They don't care in a positive way about poor, ill or otherwise disadvantaged people unless they can use their plight to gather votes (which is a rare occasion in itself).
- ryan93 5y agoso if every race experienced homelessness at the same rate you would be okay with "repressive regulation"?
- mschuster91 5y agoNever did I say that and I never will. Repressive regulation is almost never the answer, it's the last resort because it carries so many problems with it - not just racism, classism and other discrimination, but plainly the fact that repression does not solve the underlying cause of the problem you want to repress.
- ryan93 5y agoYou did say it implicitly. Dont understand your point about the underlying cause. If a homeless person is peeing on a subway and you keep them off subways. the problem IS solved.
- mschuster91 5y agoThen the homeless person will pee somewhere else in unsanitary condition. As said: all that is doing is shift the problem around, when the real problem is that the homeless person does not have access to a facility to relieve himself - which ffs is considered to be one of the basic human rights! [1]: https://sanitationfirst.org/blog/the-right-to-a-toilet/ https://sanitationfirst.org/blog/the-right-to-a-toilet/
- ryan93 5y ago
- mschuster91 5y agoJFC "these people" are American citizens, and to a disturbingly large part former veterans that risked their life in one of the various wars the US fought and got (c)PTSD as a result.