3 ms·
> I think that a lot of people are anti-NFT because they hate them and all these explanations for the exact reason why they suck shift once you start talking t
by rsynnott 5y ago
> I think that a lot of people are anti-NFT because they hate them and all these explanations for the exact reason why they suck shift once you start talking to these NFT haters and engaging them.
As one of the terrible nocoin haters, possibly I can explain what's going on here.
People dislike NFTs for _multiple reasons_:
- They're typically hideously wasteful of energy.
- They are typically scams
- Even if not explicitly scams, they represent a pointless and inefficient financialisation of bloody everything that no-one except crypto enthusiasts seems to be at all interested in
- The art is weirdly universally alarmingly bad
- As applied to games, they incentivise bad (pay to win) design dynamics
I could go on. It is not inconsistent to dislike something for multiple reasons.
- bhouston 5y ago> They're typically hideously wasteful of energy. What do you think of Immutable X, which has pledged to make all transactions on its blockchain carbon neutral? https://www.immutable.com https://www.immutable.com > They are typically scams There is definitely a lot of scams. First most of the ICOs a few years back were scams, and then a lot/most? of DeFi schemes are scams. But I am not scared off of an area just because there are scammers in the vicinity. I think there is a lot of opportunity for what I would term gentrification of what are otherwise lawless areas. > Even if not explicitly scams, they represent a pointless and inefficient financialisation of bloody everything that no-one except crypto enthusiasts seems to be at all interested in I think that it will become less "inefficient" over time. I think that what can be sold will be sold if there is a market. There will be a series of fads, just like in real-life. I think this sorts itself out. If you want to believe Beanie Babies are a good thing to sell and speculate on, go for it. I won't stop you. But I probably won't speculate on those. > The art is weirdly universally alarmingly bad A lot of NFT art is derivative. But there are tens of thousands of artists who have made NFTs, and many are talented. I think you are cherry picking the copycats and the grifters work. > As applied to games, they incentivise bad (pay to win) design dynamics Games for me already went deep into the "pay to win" territory once they landed on mobile. That made a lot of companies quite rich. Thus you may disagree with the dynamics, but they are the main way that mobile games make money.
- politician 5y agoThe energy argument is a bad argument because it's an obvious ploy by the terrible nocoin haters to latch on to broader environmental politics by a superficial analogy equating PoW to Fossil Fuel Power Plants and CO2. The reality is that there is plenty of zero-carbon energy to power our global economy -- it's called the Sun, and it's been working pretty well for a long time now. If we accept the ploy, then everything that isn't strictly necessary needs to go: Netflix, Google, computers in general, cars, trains; and we all need to return to living in harmony with nature and subsistence farming. Instead of being fooled by feels good thinking, let's work on the real problem: decarbonizing the electrical grid.
- piva00 5y ago> If we accept the ploy, then everything that isn't strictly necessary needs to go: Netflix, Google, computers in general, cars, trains; and we all need to return to living in harmony with nature and subsistence farming. All these things have a value returned to society in some shape or form, even if just as entertainment. Being more mindful about our resources' usage is not a ploy, it's simply the mindset we need to have if we plan on having a comfortable future, it's pretty basic thinking: we need to be more efficient and mindful of where we spend our limited resources because the wake up call has come. This complete reductionist take on the environmental effects of PoW is absurd... Much more absurd than the argument that energy is better spent somewhere else than mining coins. Yeah, we have plenty of energy, do something more useful with it then, not consume a whole medium-sized country of energy to support an immutable ledger.
- politician 5y agoThis position is inconsistent. > All these things have a value returned to society in some shape or form, even if just as entertainment. If other people find crypto mining fun, valuable, or meaningful, then how are you able to claim they are wrong when you're relying on 'entertainment' to justify Netflix, etc? > Being more mindful about our resources' usage is not a ploy, it's simply the mindset we need to have if we plan on having a comfortable future, it's pretty basic thinking: we need to be more efficient and mindful of where we spend our limited resources because the wake up call has come. I agree with this sentiment in general. I think you could be more precise in your condemnation of cryptocurrency while justifying Netflix.
- rvz 5y ago> I could go on. It is not inconsistent to dislike something for multiple reasons. Of course it isn't. I don't like NFTs but it's dangerous to assume all NFTs fit in the above reasons. You can still have the following: > - They're typically hideously wasteful of energy. NFTs that are economically friendly: NFTs on Solana, Algorand, Avalanche, etc. > - Even if not explicitly scams, they represent a pointless and inefficient financialisation of bloody everything that no-one except crypto enthusiasts seems to be at all interested in NFTs that are useful: Blockchain Domain Names for identities. ENS [0], Solana Name Service, etc. We still pay for blockchain domains in order to renew them, just like we do for domains on ICANN expect that for the latter, the registrar can seize your domain and hike the prices up [1], for any reason where as the former is owned by you on the blockchain and no one can take it away. So which one is the true scam? All the other reasons such as NFT jpegs, NFT games, etc are all valid criticisms and demonstrate limited or no usefulness. But not all NFTs are like that. ENS (which is a blockchain domains service) is a great example of utility in NFTs. [0] https://ens.domains/ https://ens.domains/ [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29403773 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29403773