4 ms·
Blockchain is really just an accounting system. So ignore blockchain; take it out of the picture, and what do you have left with crypto? People inventing/prin
by jqpabc123 5y ago
Blockchain is really just an accounting system.
So ignore blockchain; take it out of the picture, and what do you have left with crypto?
People inventing/printing an endless supply of money for their own benefit. In what way is this *not* a scam?
But, but, but central banks do the same? Yes, they do --- but with a very different purpose and understanding. They try to maximize the positive effects on the entire, overall economy --- realizing this is the best way to maximize their own. If they fail in this, they can be replaced. Checks and balances.
"Digital" currency is a good idea that can and will eventually happen. But "crypto" currency is really just a system of misguided and misplaced trust --- you trust that unregulated "exchanges" are fair and honest and reasonable and acting in the public interest without any checks and balances.
And if they are not, you have no recourse.
- 3pt14159 5y agoI used to think the good parts of crypto could be salvaged. I now don't. The people joining at this point are either naive or corrupt. I don't think people like Vitalik would join today because the entire scene has changed. There are no limit to the number of these coins. If the Bitcoin maximalists had won out, maybe there would be a different future where the world could standardize on a single protocol, but they didn't win out. So whether it's new coins, new NFTs, new this or that. It doesn't matter. It's a pump and dump. And once the marks get wise to one type of pump and dump, you change it around a bit and pump and dump something else. Real problems are not being solved by crypto.
- shafyy 5y agoI'm curious if people like Vitalik feel trapped, or worse yet, that they have created a monster? If they don't feel bad, I wonder how they justify the cognitive dissonance. The right thing for Vitalik would be to recognize that this is not going to turn into what he imagined it to be, and to publicly speak out against it. Instead, he's trying to justify everything and secretly hopes that he somehow can still turn it around. "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds."
- pjc50 5y agoI wonder how far the billion dollars goes towards making him feel better. People have justified far worse for far less. https://www.forbes.com/sites/ninabambysheva/2021/11/03/ethereum-co-founder-vitalik-buterins-net-worth-hits-146-billion-as-ether-is-trading-at-all-time-high/?sh=355b1bc22250 https://www.forbes.com/sites/ninabambysheva/2021/11/03/ether...
- rapnie 5y ago> I'm curious if people like Vitalik feel trapped, or worse yet, that they have created a monster? > If they don't feel bad, I wonder how they justify the cognitive dissonance. "Ethereum Co-Founder Vitalik Buterin’s Net Worth Hits $1.46 Billion As Ether Reaches New All-Time High" [0] Trapped, not likely. Monster, maybe. Dissonance management not hard. I think. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/ninabambysheva/2021/11/03/ethereum-co-founder-vitalik-buterins-net-worth-hits-146-billion-as-ether-is-trading-at-all-time-high/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/ninabambysheva/2021/11/03/ether...
- 3pt14159 5y agoWell, I think it's a combination of things. First, you kinda have to be an optimist to create something like Etherium in the first place. I met the founders out in Toronto before the coin was even off the ground and while there were some sketchy drug dealers at their meetups, the crowd seemed mostly kind-techno-optimist. So the creator of the coin is more likely to see continued upsides once the coin is off the ground and a bit of cognitive dissonance comes in and he donates some of the gains to good causes here and there and gets praised by people like pg so it creates a kinda shield against what would have been obvious to him if he were introduced to the scene as it exists now. Tech initiatives are almost never led by someone that's simultaneously honest and a clear eye'd realist.
- cryptica 5y agoExactly. It's the most secure and reliable accounting system imaginable. Anyone who believes that this degree of reliability and security is not required is naive and doesn't understand human nature and doesn't understand how capitalism shapes human nature. This kind of accounting system is absolutely essential. History shows over and over that the means of power can be corrupted will be corrupted. If you haven't figured this out by now, you haven't been paying attention... You don't even need to look at history to see this. Just open your eyes to what's happening right now.
- simonh 5y agoI match your accusation of misunderstanding human nature, and raise it an accusation of profound naivety. If blockchains actually start being used for economically or socially productive or valuable functions then they will be regulated. Suppose you sell something and the transaction is logged on a blockchain, that's immutable right? It's right there in the ledger, nothing anyone can do about it. It's immune from governmental interference right? Say a court invalidates the transaction, maybe they think you lied to the counter-party, nothing they can do, right? The blockchain doesn't lie. Except they can prosecute you, fine you, imprison you, confiscate your property, pursue you to the ends of the earth and even kill you. If the transaction was an NFT, they can just directly modify the resource the NFT refers to. If it's bitcoin, they can fine you equivalent value in real world money and assets, or if they can be bothered to care about the bitcoin at all they can legally coerce you into transferring the bitcoin back. It's like the scene in Game of Thrones where Little Finger tells Cersei that knowledge is power and only barely survives at her pleasure because presumably she was in a good mood. No. Power is power.
- cryptica 5y agoBut the thing is that any movement of tokens on the blockchain is public for all to see. It removes a government's ability to do things in secret. With centralized systems, shady stuff is happening all over the place. Systems get hacked all the time, funds are stolen by ex-employees without anybody noticing. It's naive to not see how corrupted and hacked the majority of modern centralized systems have become... Big companies are constantly paying off hackers to avoid DDoS attacks. All this stuff is happening silently and constantly behind the scenes. Adding a layer of transparency to money transfers can go a long way.
- sshine 5y ago> Blockchain is really just an accounting system. Yeah, it's really just a globally accessible, append-only, Turing-complete accounting system controlled by no single authority. Nothing to see here, move along.
- jqpabc123 5y agoHow did the world ever survive/operate without it?
- piva00 5y agoI'm very much not into cryptocurrencies and I constantly bash them and their communities but... The same argument could be used for the internet, or cars, or phones, or any other technology. The world survived but it definitely wasn't the same before.
- jqpabc123 5y agoSee my other comment above. Blockchain and crypto are interdependent and as such, are not really analogous to the technologies you mentioned. In other words, take away the crypto and blockchain is largely a solution looking for a problem. Don't take my word for it, just ask Microsoft and IBM. https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-is-shutting-down-its-azure-blockchain-service/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-is-shutting-down-its... https://www.coindesk.com/business/2021/02/01/ibm-blockchain-is-a-shell-of-its-former-self-after-revenue-misses-job-cuts-sources/ https://www.coindesk.com/business/2021/02/01/ibm-blockchain-...
- acdha 5y agoThe internet is a globally-accessible system controlled by no single authority, too, with an awful lot of Turing-complete systems using it. The smarter question to ask is what problems require a global append-only database with code execution capabilities, and how much value there is in that approach relative to the much cheaper alternatives. Using a blockchain locks in significant costs relative to everything else so there has to be a really compelling answer to that question to be worth the extra cost and risk.
- TacticalCoder 5y ago> People inventing/printing an endless supply of money for their own benefit. This is odd because Bitcoin, despite is ecological problem, was created to precisely not have an unlimited supply. There are only ever going to be 21 millions Bitcoin and the free market was supposed to decide was one Bitcoin was worth (offer and demand: nobody was coerced into buying any). I don't like Bitcoin's carbon footprint but I can see how Bitcoin maximalists may be disgusted by all the shitcoins and by NFTs. I don't think "Satoshi Nakamoto" (whatever that means), if he/they is/are still alive, planned on creating an unlimited supply of money just for the sake of getting rich. To me Bitcoin seemed more like some kind of an anarchist cyberpunk statement than a ponzi/scam.
- jqpabc123 5y ago... was created to precisely not have an unlimited supply. Bitcoin is not the only crypto. The supply of bitcoin clones and cryptocurrencies in general is unlimited. ... planned on creating an unlimited supply of money just for the sake of getting rich. What was *planned* doesn't change the reality that exists in the crypto marketplace. And the creator is no longer in control.
- landemva 5y ago" printing an endless supply of money for their own benefit. " Good description of 'Federal Reserve' which prints money to bail out the banks it allegedly regulates. There are many open finance projects, DeFi, on Ethereum which allow me to opt out of the bankster's rigged system of debt-is-now-money.
- jqpabc123 5y agoGood description of 'Federal Reserve' which prints money to bail out the banks it allegedly regulates. Read the rest of my post. The Federal Reserve Board does not get rich from this. Any benefit to them is indirect and follows the trajectory of the overall economy. ... opt out of the bankster's rigged system of debt-is-now-money But only if you opt into the rigged system of electrons-are-now-money --- which also uses the idea of debt-is-now-money. For example, see Tether.
- landemva 5y agoThose who run the banks, who own and are regulated by the Fed, get rich. September 2019 repo problems, like Deutsche Bank and others, demonstrates how the Fed bails out even foreigners. Crypto is a vibrant growing space and like any growing space there will be problems along the way. I have no interest in Tether, though some find it useful and they can use their free will to choose it as a place to park funds. I think people would be better served with DAI or USDP when parking funds, but that is just me.
- jqpabc123 5y agoI have no interest in Tether ... Pitiful excuse. Tether should interest you in the same way (and for the same reason) the Federal Reserve does. It is involved in more than half of all crypto trades and provides much of what passes for stability in the crypto marketplace. And Tether is based on debt-is-now-money --- only worse because the debit is unsecured IOUs at best and at worst may be totally non-existent. The fact that no one really knows if Tether is backed at all, yet it easily maintains it's 1 USD peg points to possible/likely widespread collusion and fraud.