5 ms·
Once again and as predicted, we have another 'web3 is a ponzi' article. The creators of web3, and everyone else knows it is a giant scam, just like how ICOs whe
by rvz 5y ago
Once again and as predicted, we have another 'web3 is a ponzi' article. The creators of web3, and everyone else knows it is a giant scam, just like how ICOs where in 2017. All thanks to and started by Ethereum.
Not sure why this article presents this as a great surprise or a new discovery. Sure, the majority of NFTs (Especially the JPEGs) are a pump-n-dump ponzi scam selling images to each other. When the NFT craze runs out of steam, 90% of all the image/audio/video types of NFTs will collapse. 10% of the other NFTs will survive with a valid use case.
I don't see how the whole 'web3' narrative should apply to every single cryptocurrency and project in existence, like how this article has done. Just look at this sentence and the quote:
> A person investing in crypto or a shared future on the blockchain is said to hate Earth and support the “hyperfinancialization of all human existence.”
How does that apply to every single cryptocurrency as the author of this tweet has just generalized? [0]
[0] https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1465682611171467269?s=20 https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1465682611171467269?s=20
- cehrlich 5y agoI agree that some legitimate use cases will survive, but I think the ratio is _much_ worse than 90/10.
- blitzar 5y ago> some legitimate use cases will survive More likely - some legitimate use cases will emerge, as I am yet to see anything to date that would fit into that category, but there is still room for the solution that is crypto to find itself a problem to fix.
- byhemechi 5y ago+1 on the ratio comment, i am yet to see a legitimate use for nfts, not just a something to speculate on
- rglullis 5y agoENS alone should be more than 10% of the market. Using NFTs for decentralized identity and authn is big. Unlock Protocol's is going for authz. There is a strong selection bias for those that report on crypto for clicks or those that want to create a narrative that we can not live without some big central authority controlling our lives.
- thematrixturtle 5y ago> Using NFTs for decentralized identity and authn is big. Tell me more? What problem does this solve that you can't do with centralized auth?
- rglullis 5y agoHave you ever thought about closing your Google Account and got discouraged when you realized that there are so many other services that depend on it? Worse, have you ever had your Google/Facebook/Apple/Outlook/Twitter account closed without knowing why? Centralized systems are amazing, until they aren't.
- dub 5y agoHave you ever had your credentials to a decentralized service stolen by a keylogger and realized that you will never, ever, under any circumstances regain control and there's no one you can talk to and nothing you can do about it? Decentralized systems are amazing, until they aren't (Even if you wanted to have a decentralized account recovery like saying you can have 3 friends band together and help you recover your account if you lose access, what happens when those 3 friends decide that don't like you as much as they like the idea of banding together to take over your identity and all your money?...)
- rglullis 5y agoYou know what annoys me the most about these discussions about crypto and systems in general? It's the fact that people can only argue in the extremes. Decentralization is a spectrum. (https://twitter.com/rlullis/status/1307420668372430848 https://twitter.com/rlullis/status/1307420668372430848) > Decentralized systems are amazing, until they aren't No, they are not. They are expensive, they require responsibility. The UX is complicated. Most people shouldn't use it and will be better off delegating all this to someone else. Thing is, it's not because something is good enough for most people that everyone should stick to it. > what happens when those 3 friends decide that don't like you as much as they like the idea of banding together to take over your identity and all your money? This argument is stupid. With decentralization, there is no reason for your identity to be something singular. There is even less reason for people to think that one wallet should hold "all your money".
- alexb_ 5y agoWhat exactly are the valid use cases that are not already better served with centralized systems?
- mateuszf 5y agoExample: Wikileaks being funded using Bitcoin when PayPal, Visa and other payment companies blocked transactions
- threeseed 5y agoThat was because, whether you agree with it or not, the US government deemed their behaviour to be illegal. And so the issue you have is not with Paypal, Visa etc unless you think that those payment companies should tolerate illegal parties transacting money. Because that is a very slippery slope especially given how much wealth in the world comes from the despair of the very poor and helpless.
- Zak 5y ago> That was because, whether you agree with it or not, the US government deemed their behaviour to be illegal. There are, and should be real-world limits on the ability of the US government to stop things from happening by deeming them illegal. In the case of Wikileaks, one such limitation is the relatively decentralized nature of the internet. The US government was able to pressure Amazon to refuse to host it, but was unsuccessful in pressuring OVH, so Wikileaks remains online. There is no Great Firewall of America, so it remains accessible within the US. Another limitation is that while the US government can and did pressure Paypal to refuse service to Wikileaks, there's no equivalent for preventing transfers of cryptocurrencies.
- threeseed 5y ago> There are, and should be real-world limits on the ability of the US government to stop things from happening by deeming them illegal. It already exists: the legal system. > there's no equivalent for preventing transfers of cryptocurrencies Money laundering, child trafficking, drug profiteering, terrorism etc. they all come with costs. And doing nothing to stop them is not good for anyone.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoDoesn’t Stephen Diehl CTO for a private blockchain startup? https://twitter.com/dystopiabreaker/status/1470126927818067969 https://twitter.com/dystopiabreaker/status/14701269278180679...
- nsotelo 5y agoAre there any valid use-cases? For any suggestion I've heard, it always seems that a relational database or PKI would be better.
- me_me_me 5y ago> All thanks to and started by Ethereum. I think the scam goes all the way back to electricity and Edison! Its a little bit disingenuous to blame etherium for NFT, its like blaming email for nigerian prince spam.
- vinnie-io 5y agoit is though. an NFT is just a crypto currency with a total supply of 1. and ethereum contracts allow the creation
- me_me_me 5y ago> it is though. What is this? A game of 'it is', 'it isn't'? NFT is not a crypto with total supply of 1, its not even a crypto, its at best a by-product of crypto transaction.
- doorman38 5y agoTotally bro! Edison and Tesla were SO concerned about “scamming” money out of you (over a 100 years ago). That makes total sense….lol. Mind you they were rich AF too. That’s absolutely hilarious, I’m sorry. But you’re right about NFT’s not being ETH’s fault by the way, on that I agree with you. But it still happened. By the way, why (like in all reality if being brutally honest) did we need to have NFT’s to begin with? The answer is we didn’t. People saw a “get rich quick opportunity” (even though very wrong), and went after it. That does not make it right or give it a real world use case, sorry, it really doesn’t. Yet, on the flip side, I pay my rent, most of my utility bills, and basically all purchases (Amazon, eBay, Uber/Uber Eats, Airbnb, American Airlines, and about ten others that compromise about 90% of all them) with Bitcoin (BTC). And that takes me about 5 minutes. Is that not real world? If not, please enlighten me, what is then?
- me_me_me 5y agoI am not defending NFTs, just saying that you cannot blame technology for what it was used for. Nuclear fission was the idea/tech, it was used to create A-bombs, and clean nuclear energy. Nuclear fission like smart contract is an idea, how its used it up to people.
- spinchange 5y agoWhat else is there to the narrative? This stuff is predominately solutions in search of problems and they are not innovative except for trying to financialize and/or securitize every conceivable digital artifact imaginable. It sucks comprehensively like at the ideological origin points.
- danaris 5y ago> Not sure why this article presents this as a great surprise or a new discovery. Because even if the circles you move in are all very well aware that NFTs are a massive scam, very obviously many people haven't yet realized that—after all, it's still working.