3 ms·
> Being first to market does grant a significant advantage. This was the first comment I saw on the article and I immediately began to cringe. This is so dead
by mbesto 15y ago
> Being first to market does grant a significant advantage.
This was the first comment I saw on the article and I immediately began to cringe. This is so dead WRONG! For the life of me I can't find the reference but I believe their is a book that talks solely how being first in a market is a massive myth.
- kenjackson 15y agoIt can be a big advantage. In a commodity market, which search has become, it's huge. And the other type of market is one with huge network effects. Beating Facebook will be hard regardless of your feature set.
- taeric 15y agoYou realize that Facebook was hardly first into this market, right? Same with Google.
- kenjackson 15y agoFacebook was the first I know in this market. Others competed in similar markets, from SixDegrees to BlackVoices, but sufficiently different in that they weren't attempting as broad of an appeal. Google was the first to the "search only" market. Well after AltaVista abandoned it. When Google came on the scene search engines were a feature of portals. They made the market of the search-engine only destination.
- mbesto 15y ago> Facebook was the first I know in this market. And herein lies the fallacy and the confirmation bias that exists about the success of companies. Just because you know it to be first doesn't mean it was the first to market. > Well after AltaVista abandoned it. So you're saying AltaVista was first? (technically it wasn't) scratches head
- kenjackson 15y agoI think you don't understand what "first" means in this context. It doesn't mean literally first. Here, read this description of first-mover advantage from Wikipedia: "In marketing, first-mover advantage or FMA is the advantage gained by the initial ("first-moving") significant occupant of a market segment." Notice the term "significant occupant". Second, notice the term "market segment". Just because you know it to be first doesn't mean it was the first to market. The fact that you know it to be first (assuming you know the market somewhat), implies that it was quite likely first-mover. In that if someone else was previously a significant occupant, you would have known of them. My friend who did New Haven Clique in 1994 and got 20 Yale friends to join wasn't first-mover. So you're saying AltaVista was first? (technically it wasn't) scratches head In the search space I think it probably was AV (and of course they abandoned to go portal -- which brings up the discontinuity argument that plagues first-mover discussions). The only other one I could think of was OT, but they were more of an engine and less of a search page destination. Almost everyone else was portals (although Yahoo/InfoSeek portals from the past would only barely resemble what we call portals today).
- trevelyan 15y agoNot intended to come across as aggressive, but have you started a business? How about one that competes with entrenched players in an existing space? Or one that appears on page seven or eight in Google for relevant search queries when your competitors are on page one? There is a reason most YC companies are trying to disrupt markets rather than compete head-on-head with existing business models. Because while it isn't impossible to break into markets dominated by competitors, it is much harder and you are at a severe disadvantage. How do you reach consumers? How do you build brand awareness? How do you advertise profitably? And why should the NYT or RWW or anyone write about your business when there is already a bigger story out there? There are ways around these problems, but they all involve tradeoffs that work against small startups and that take time and money to overcome. Blogging heavily to try to overcome SEO problems will take at least 12 months in the best case to see any results and gets less effective every year, while requiring quite a bit of work up-front that does not drive revenue. Viral loops can take time to function effectively in the real world. And meanwhile you have to be building something that will drive revenue eventually in addition to addressing user concerns, iterating and improving your product. Your best bet is often just to produce something really good and aim for word-of-mouth. But even in this case, your speed of growth will be much slower than initial entrants ceteris paribus, and you'll often need to compete by giving more stuff away for free. If Google didn't have VC funding they wouldn't have been able to spurn the sponsored placements that their competitors used and would have ended up with an internal marketing department. Would their product have seemed so much different/better then? So ask yourself -- can you give away your product for free for four or five years while you find a better way to make money (AdSense)? And do you really have an advantage in this search compared to your profitable competitors who are also looking to innovate and improve their products, and who also have non-trivial budgets to back their development efforts?
- spc476 15y agoMicrosoft made a killing by being second to market, except maybe for BASIC when they started. Operating systems, second (or third even). Applications? Second. Graphical interfaces? Second (and I remember when Microsoft was the David to Apple's Goliath in the "Look-and-Feel Lawsuits" of the mid-80s). There's not much Microsoft was first at.