40 ms·
It seems like a TED talk might serve pretty well as a teaser for reading a book or scientific article about a subject? The problem isn't that teasers are bad, b
by skybrian 5y ago
It seems like a TED talk might serve pretty well as a teaser for reading a book or scientific article about a subject? The problem isn't that teasers are bad, but that there's no next step, no recommended reading. The teaser is all you get and you're not expected to want more. This is anti-curious.
Often memes are kind of similar in that they're basically headlines without a link to an article.
- mdp2021 5y ago> expected to want more ?! You are naturally supposed to do your homework. Normally, e.g. "desertification", finding a bibliography is not considered the issue. And when the talk is about an upcoming technology, e.g. "creating soil out of discarded garments", well yes explicit bibliography would be nice to have, but the matter is more complicated (and large parts of the matter could be in pre-bibliography state).
- ghaff 5y agoMy somewhat polarizing opinion is that, aside from tutorials/workshops, most conference talk are better around 30 minute length. I generally don't find it's a great format for really diving into a topic and 30 minutes is enough to introduce a topic and perhaps inspire me to dig deeper. Perhaps it's my modern attention span but I find a lot of things that we've traditionally slotted into hour-length period, are better handled with 30 minute ones.
- skybrian 5y agoI still think they could have been improved by thinking about what the call to action is supposed to be, other than just being inspired. It's like, okay, you got people's attention. What are you going to do with it?