3 ms·
Circle lines seem to be making a comeback (or finally be getting popular?) e.g. Moscow’s mcl and bcl, paris’ line 15) and it’s really heartening to see. Circle
by masklinn 5y ago
Circle lines seem to be making a comeback (or finally be getting popular?) e.g. Moscow’s mcl and bcl, paris’ line 15) and it’s really heartening to see. Circle lines tend to have pretty low distance/trip ratios but high value and great occupancy.
- lmm 5y agoCircle lines are unpopular nowadays because of poor resilience, just as lines with many branches are falling out of fashion (particularly as integrated ticketing reduces the advantages they once had) - indeed it's not so long ago that London deliberately "unwound" its circle line. Although the Yamanote line is a circle, it's very much an off-centre one that swings out through the suburbs on one side and not the other. And it's worth noting that Japan is pretty far behind in terms of integrated ticketing for occasional journeys (although commuter passes are integrated between different companies).
- mlindner 5y ago> And it's worth noting that Japan is pretty far behind in terms of integrated ticketing for occasional journeys (although commuter passes are integrated between different companies). Firstly, Japan actually has very good integrated ticketing, namely you don't buy tickets at all. You wave your phone/card over the stall on entry and wave it again at whatever station you exit from, and the system calculates the fare at exit. (And it's discounted from the price of actually buying tickets.) Japanese train station gates allow more people to move in and out of the station than any other model of station I have seen in any country. Secondly, the over-focus on integrated ticketing misses that the important thing is integrated payment. It wasn't the case until some number of years ago, but nowadays everything but the most rural of rural lines has a single shared national system for IC card payment that is easy to use. The IC cards can even be used at most grocery stores and restaurants. They even work for foreigners and are a great alternative to cash to avoid having to calculate payments.
- lmm 5y ago> Firstly, Japan actually has very good integrated ticketing, namely you don't buy tickets at all. You wave your phone/card over the stall on entry and wave it again at whatever station you exit from, and the system calculates the fare at exit. You missed having to go through interchange gates or, more commonly, exit and re-enter when you're changing lines. The fact that ticket payment is easy mitigates the damage somewhat, but the fact remains that tickets aren't integrated and this has genuine costs; people often end up travelling a longer way around so that they can stay within a single operator's network, because the fare structure incentivises them to do that.
- masklinn 5y agoIt’s also a common tourist trap: first time around in Tokyo, you don’t realise how the networks work and that ticketing is not integrated (but payment is), and you end up paying way more in fares than you might have expected.
- mlindner 5y agoI don't know if I'm "trapped" but switching between lines was trivial and the price differences being so marginal it didn't even matter. I don't care that I'm spending 30 yen (roughly $0.30) extra for a more direct route.
- lmm 5y agoIt's often far from marginal. E.g. Shinanomachi to Shin-Okubo: one change on the same company's trains, JPY160. Shinanomachi to Nishi-Shinjuku: similar distance, one change again, but you're changing to a different company's train so it's JPY310, about twice as much.
- masklinn 5y ago> I don't know if I'm "trapped" but switching between lines was trivial That’s the trap, it’s extremely easy to change networks. > the price differences being so marginal it didn't even matter. I don't care that I'm spending 30 yen (roughly $0.30) extra for a more direct route. That was not my experience at all. The price difference was routinely 100% or more, especially for cross-city trips where the “direct” route would have multiple network swaps, whereas a slightly less direct route (adding maybe 1/10th the trip length or less) would have 0~1 network changes. In fact, just looking at the fare structures you can’t be correct: they start at 170~180Y, and reach double the initial fare at something like 40km. I would expect JR to be similar. The entry fare is an outsized component of the total, and will be the vast majority of it unless you travel very long distances. Even more so if you network switch as the “distance counter” resets on every network change. So if you make a single trip with one network change you’ll be paying 350Y minimum, versus under 200 if you remain in-network and the distance traveled is below 10km or so.
- sanxiyn 5y agoIt is a very important observation that Yamanote line is off-centre, because it is important to its success. It also matters that Tokyo is at waterfront. This is why I am pretty skeptical about Moscow and Paris' circle lines. Details here: https://pedestrianobservations.com/2017/05/13/the-yamanote-line-a-ring-or-a-radial/ https://pedestrianobservations.com/2017/05/13/the-yamanote-l...
- masklinn 5y agoMoscow’s BCL does not come out of a technocratic dream, it’s a direct outcome of MCL’s success.
- thriftwy 5y agoMoscow's Central Circle was neglected for many decades based on the same scepticism, but it turned out great - a lot of passenger traffic on what used to be a freight circle line running through the industrialized "gray belt".
- franciscop 5y agoOh something I totally missed to explain is that Tokyo is not built like most European/American cities, or even most Japanese cities; it's a city of cities so to speak, so the circle is not around a "life center" (it's somewhat around the imperial family castle, but there's no normal people living there). The circle line stops on the important "cities" that conform Tokyo, which are built in somewhat of a circle itself! The big buildings and everything is on the Yamanote line then. And it's fairly big, not what you'd have as a circle line in most EU cities, it takes a bit over 1h to go around in train. A bit like London, but more extreme.
- quantumwannabe 5y agoThat is how the newer American cities are laid out as well. Look at a map of Los Angeles or Dallas-Fort Worth or any other sprawling American city and you'll find the exact same layout as Tokyo: many small cities that grew into one giant city, with many of them having their own "downtowns"/"CBDs".