4 ms·
> A good chunk of the engineers at Boeing are also pilots I don't know how you square that with the MCAS disaster. Everything relating to it ( design, piss poo
by sofixa 5y ago
> A good chunk of the engineers at Boeing are also pilots
I don't know how you square that with the MCAS disaster. Everything relating to it ( design, piss poor implementation that somehow passes tests and certification, hiding it from the FAA, airlines and pilots) at best indicates that the people involved have maybe seen an airplane, once, from afar.
IIRC the Ethiopian pilots followed the Boeing airworthiness directive to the letter and the plane still crashed. Boeing accepted responsibility for the crashes. Sadly there won't be any criminal prosecution and it's highly unlikely there will be significant changes at Boeing and the culture that led to 300+ dead will probably lead to other issues ( like the poor quality on the 787s manufactured in South Carolina). How many people have to die for serious changes to be made?
I hope that future Boeing models will require full certification from the EASA and other aviation authorities, the FAA has zero legitimacy.
- WalterBright 5y ago> I don't know how you square that with the MCAS disaster. There was nothing wrong with the MCAS concept. There was a lot wrong with its implementation, and I cannot explain why that happened. I've never seen any credible story of how it came about. > the Ethiopian pilots followed the Boeing airworthiness directive to the letter No, they did not. The EAD says: 1. restore normal trim with the electric trim switches 2. turn off the stab trim system The EA pilots: 1. turned off the stab trim system with the nose disastrously trimmed down > Sadly there won't be any criminal prosecution Be careful with criminal prosecutions. I understand the desire for revenge, but criminal liability will cause everyone involved to be silent about issues, cover them up, be uncooperative, and not fix them. (Because to fix them means to admit criminal liability.) To make systems safe requires a "no fault" culture. > How many people have to die for serious changes to be made? That implies that airplanes have never had crashes before due to errors all around. There have been lots of them, and with each one, designs, processes, and training get better.
- froh 5y ago> "no fault" "No blame" No fault is what we want to achieve. Also we need to maintain liability of the managers deciding to not do certain measures, for cost reasons. It's perfectly fine to invent MCAS, to maintain 737 "look and feel" to the pilot. It's not okay to not introduce it properly. It's not okay to only think about MCAS failure modes, symptoms and remedies after the fact. It's not okay to make the business decision (!) To not thoroughly train for potential failure. There has to be liability at the decision making level.
- rramadass 5y agoThis is exactly right. I am not sure why Walter is trying to excuse Boeing of the consequences of their actions. They made a series of very wrong decisions in the name of "profit" which cumulatively led to the disaster. They need to be held fully accountable.
- ummonk 5y agoNo it doesn't say that. This is what it says: "Disengage autopilot and control airplane pitch attitude with control column and main electric trim as required. If relaxing the control column causes the trim to move, set stabilizer trim switches to CUTOUT. If runaway continues, hold the stabilizer trim wheel against rotation and trim the airplane manually."
- WalterBright 5y agoRead all of it.
- sofixa 5y ago> Be careful with criminal prosecutions. I understand the desire for revenge, but criminal liability will cause everyone involved to be silent about issues, cover them up, be uncooperative, and not fix them How is that in any way different than what happened with Boeing here and the McDonnell Douglas cargo door fiasco? The company refused to acknowledge and fix the problem until after multiple incidents happened, there was no criminal prosecution and nothing changed. > That implies that airplanes have never had crashes before due to errors all around. There have been lots of them, and with each one, designs, processes, and training get better. There have been many honest mistakes or just not knowing any better, miscommunications, etc. But what Boeing did now cannot be excused with an honest mistake. It's impossible that the people involved didn't understand the potential repercussions of no redundancy and hiding the presence of MCAS from regulators (which they were supposed to given the criticality of the system) and pilots. There's no way around this. What can be improved here? Add a "don't negligently implement stupid systems and hide their existence from everyone for a few bucks/months" sign to mandatory corporate training?
- WalterBright 5y ago> It's impossible that the people involved didn't understand the potential repercussions of no redundancy I'd like to know the answer to that question, too. "Impossible" is a strong word, however. Some speculation here: https://www.industryweek.com/supply-chain/article/22027840/boeings-737-max-software-outsourced-to-9anhour-engineers https://www.industryweek.com/supply-chain/article/22027840/b... Personally, I've found very, very few engineers outside of the aviation industry that understand the principles of dual-path design.
- salawat 5y agoDual-path is analogous to Rickover's Sub-safe correct? No single points of failure, and graceful degradation to the point of failsafe right?
- Swenrekcah 5y ago>Be careful with criminal prosecutions. I understand the desire for revenge, but criminal liability will cause everyone involved to be silent about issues, cover them up, be uncooperative, and not fix them. (Because to fix them means to admit criminal liability.) To make systems safe requires a "no fault" culture. It's not about revenge but deterrance. Top level executives never face any consequences of their actions, except they might receive only a container-load of money instead of a boat-load. So why shouldn't they take risks with society and other peoples lives, they know they'll be well of if it goes good or bad. Also, would you apply the same logic to someone who conspired to burgle your home or assault your kids?