3 ms·
I don't think this is a conservative opinion piece -- or at least, it's not well aligned to the Republican tribe. While it does mention some examples of cancel
by klyrs 5y ago
I don't think this is a conservative opinion piece -- or at least, it's not well aligned to the Republican tribe. While it does mention some examples of cancellation on the left, it also devotes significant focus to legislation by Republicans attacking the freedom of speech in academia.
But, sadly, it appears that most of the commenters here are responding to what they expect from the title.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 5y agoIt is very obviously conservative in language and origin; you only have to read French's bio or about where The Dispatch's come sfrom. Their tag line is, "Fact-based reporting and commentary on politics, policy and culture -- informed by conservative principles". 5 years ago this would have no question passed for a conservative piece. What has shifted here is the rapid Republican/Trumpist slide toward authoritarianism. So I read this as a conservative who is shocked by the monster he helped unleash. I also don't think it's particularly well thought through, in that it tries to both-sides the problem with a false equivalency between "cancel culture" (that is, people using their free speech and free association) and right-wing attempts to use the power of the state to win a culture war (which clearly violates free speech). And the fundamental premise in the title is nonsensical. It's like saying, "Having bouncers can't make a bar popular." Yes, duh, and nobody thinks otherwise.
- ianai 5y agoBut aren’t bouncers a sign of a very popular bar? I don’t think that makes the point they’re targeting as an analogy. Good comment though.
- wpietri 5y agoBouncers aren't there to create a healthy bar. They're there to set a minimum standard for behavior. E.g.: https://twitter.com/iamragesparkle/status/1280891537451343873?lang=en https://twitter.com/iamragesparkle/status/128089153745134387...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- klyrs 5y ago> So I read this as a conservative who is shocked by the monster he helped unleash. That's an interesting read on the situation. If conservatives are rethinking their devotion to a would-be dictator, would you silence their ruminations?
- hotpotamus 5y agoThis is not a re-thinking. French and the founders of The Dispatch are one of a small group who were and remain "Never Trump" conservatives. I get the sense they are among the few who actually believed in the principled conservatism that Republicans liked to talk about until it became unpopular among their base. I may not agree with French, but I 100% believe that he is being intellectually honest from his point of view and will continue to share his views that way. See also The Bulwark for a similar group who I think actually seem to be moving leftward a bit in ideology (from center-right to center perhaps; they'd bristle at being placed anywhere on the left) and David Frum. They are the conservatives I find most interesting to listen to because they chose to be honest even when it cost them money/viewers/influence. But there are not that many in this camp.
- wpietri 5y agoI partly agree. But I especially agree it isn't a re-thinking, and that's one of the beefs I have with French. I have not seen him grapple with either his role in the problem or whether repeating his previous behaviors will lead to a solution. Which is why I think both-sidesing the problem, as he does here, is at best unhelpful.
- wpietri 5y agoWhere did you get the idea I think French should be silenced?