4 ms·
I don't think leaving huge holes in someone's education, because a parent (or one of these co-ops) can't teach it properly, is a good trade-off for shielding hi
by ryandrake 5y ago
I don't think leaving huge holes in someone's education, because a parent (or one of these co-ops) can't teach it properly, is a good trade-off for shielding him/her from perceived indoctrination. Notice I specifically said perceived because it's mostly exaggerated or outright untrue. If merely teaching kids that the Civil War happened, and that it was actually about slavery is now indoctrination, then anything can be considered indoctrination. There are a lot of parents out there that oppose teaching facts they personally disagree with, and these people are the ones who least should be homeschooling.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>I don't think leaving huge holes in someone's education, because a parent (or one of these co-ops) can't teach it properly, is a good trade-off for shielding him/her from perceived indoctrination. I generally agree that forgoing basic education is not a solution. Most parents I know readily admit that they don't have the bandwidth for homeschooling and choose private schools as a solution. I'm not to interested in tilting at individual facts, so hopefully we can skip that part, and agree that different world views are instilled in children as part of their education (by whatever means). I often hear it parroted that certain people are oppressors by virtue of their birth and guilty and responsible for generations of injustice. I do not want my children to internalize this message. With that context, perhaps we can agree that all parents are opposed to teaching children ideologies they don't personally agree with. I would further suggest that many parents currently pulling their children from schools are doing so based on the message above.
- fineIllregister 5y ago>I often hear... I often hear the same strawman from right-wing sources. Usually the actual content is benign, like GP mentioned (topics like the US Civil War was fought over slavery). I've never heard any teacher or curriculum say the things being alleged or seen any evidence that they were said, which returns to the bulk of GP's comment: people are having degraded education over falsely perceived indoctrination.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI didn't say I heard that specific phrase from teachers, but I hear it from other people in real life all the time. Do you deny that people hold this belief? Do you believe it yourself? P. S. Why do people keep bringing up the civil war? Did I miss something?
- YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo 5y agoYay, make it personal despite getting delivered objective facts without providing any facts to bolster your own believes. yikes.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoOK, so do you think that you can never ask a person what position they hold when discussing that very topic? If they believe that racial guilt exists or is deserved is relevant to the conversation of if it is or should be taught in schools.
- YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo 5y agoThe nice thing is that it doesn't matter what I believe is deserved or not the thing is that there was wrong doing and that the wrong doing should be teached in school. Imagine Germany not teaching their children about the second world war. LOL
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think we are talking about entirely different topics/ talking past eachother. I too agree that school should include the darker parts of history and lessons learned from them. I don't think that you and I can have a discussion unless we agree on the subject we are even talking about.