5 ms·
Crash starts from the 3:26 mark: [0]. Had they not intervened, the damage would have been much worse. Further in the video, it has repeatedly become confused in
by rvz 5y ago
Crash starts from the 3:26 mark: [0]. Had they not intervened, the damage would have been much worse. Further in the video, it has repeatedly become confused in trying to drive through the pylons - again the driver intervenes.
This is just one of the many reasons why FSD is not only putting drivers at risk, but it is really turning its customers into real-life crash dummies.
A more accurate re-brand of this product should be something more like 'Fools Self Driving' than 'Full Self Driving', given the false advertising and lack of safety features for these drivers using the product.
[0] https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU?t=206 https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU?t=206
- xeromal 5y agoThanks for the timestamp!
- pcurve 5y agoIt's interesting how those green pylons were completely invisible to the car's sensor. If you look at dashboard LCD 4:30, the car seems too slow to register them as objects or misses it completely. 4:42 it makes a right onto tram track. And again at 6:24 Jesus.
- bradfa 5y agoAs a human, I had a hard time seeing the green pylons when watching the video. Local to me pylons are always bright orange and easy to see. My brain is not looking for dark colored narrow barriers so it doesn’t surprise me that FSD doesn’t see them either. I imagine I’d have a hard time driving those roads in bad weather or at night and maybe even under the lighting during the video.
- colanderman 5y agoThe car doesn't even see an orange pylon, with bright reflective tape, at 7:24. Or for that matter, the lane markings -- after the driver pulls the car back into the lane, in continues to try driving through the parking spaces and shoulder. This car can't even see orange pylons and lane markings. That's not even passable for a student driver on a closed course.
- stubish 5y agoAnd a great example why self driving needs more sensors than just vision. Otherwise it will keep making many of the same errors humans will. Someone is going to wipe the floor with Tesla simply by having a system that avoids collisions, rather than avoids collisions with things that can be seen.
- lttlrck 5y agoIt didn't see the orange one later in the video either.
- Volundr 5y ago> As a human, I had a hard time seeing the green pylons when watching the video. I'm not doubting you, but I find that surprising. Admittedly the dark green blends into the background a bit, but the retroreflectors catching the sunlight stood out for me even in the video, which would have muted the effect somewhat. > I imagine I’d have a hard time driving those roads in bad weather or at night and maybe even under the lighting during the video. In bad weather or at night you should have you headlights on and those retroreflectors will make them shine brightly. They'll actually probably be easier to spot. In the event the weather is bad enough the retroreflectors can't bounce your headlights back at you, it's going to be bad enough your not seeing the paint either.
- AlexandrB 5y agoI think there's a huge difference between spotting them in a 2d video and spotting them live. Your brain is very good at picking out details like motion and parallax in a live environment.
- klyrs 5y agoThe bollards are plainly visible in broad daylight, and wrapped with reflective tape. If you cannot see them, please stay off the road.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoTesla has been full of it on FSD for a while now, at least the current beta is rolled out to a much more restricted set of people, although they still sell the general one to the general public... But WHY is a (I'm assuming) concrete post that short and painted DARK GREEN? Green seems like a horrible choice for a post in night driving. That's not every particularly well designed for human driving. San Jose? Why isn't this post yellow? Yellow seems to be the typical concrete post color. Surface/local street FSD driving is 10-20 years away and will require a lot of convergence, construction standards, regulatory testing, common databases of "danger locations", etc. It's so much harder. So many "target types" so much variation, so many different local standards. In particular I don't agree with Tesla's lack of a database or route-specific training or the like. Lidar I think is actually less of an issue than that approach. But a good divided highway automation should be doable. That has a lot more standardization, and higher amounts of traffic would lead to better statistical models and datasets for proving out algorithms. These are the problems in highway driving: traffic jams (can be prewarned)/ stopped cars (a current tesla issue), deer/animals wandering onto the road, construction (can be signaled in a standard way and prewarned). Debris/potholes?
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>Green seems like a horrible choice for a post in night driving. Those pylons have reflective strips on them for the night.
- lttlrck 5y agoIt doesn't see the orange post later in the video either...
- vanilla_nut 5y ago> it is really turning its customers into real-life crash dummies. Not just the customers, anybody else unfortunate enough to share the road with them. As a frequent pedestrian/bicyclist in my city, Teslas scare the shit out of me. Even worse, when Tesla drivers cause accidents, the response is typically complete shock and disbelief that FSD failed them. And an utter lack of responsibility for the damage and/or injury they caused. Because obviously they weren't driving, it was the car!
- HarryHirsch 5y agoSanhedrin 91b applies: https://www.sefaria.org/Sanhedrin.91b?lang=bi https://www.sefaria.org/Sanhedrin.91b?lang=bi Both Elon Musk and the driver are equally at fault and need both go to jail, they enable each other to make the public roadways unsafe.
- epgui 5y agoWhy do you feel like you have to bring Judaism / religion into this conversation?
- HarryHirsch 5y agoThe Talmud explains Jewish legal concepts, how they were used and applied in practice. It's not an attempt to drag religion in, rather to point out that 1500 years ago the Jewish Sages recognized that folks who enable each other are both guilty and need to be judged together. The plausible denability and diffusion of responsibility that you see so often nowadays is pernicious to society.
- olliej 5y agoHuh, I don’t recall seeing the bit in the law about religion being involved in the US legal system. Seriously injecting religion by posting irrelevant scripture in a discussion of legal liability is purely proselytizing and an attempt to convert people.
- Animats 5y agoHitting a bollard is inexcusable. Even for a vision-only system. They're really lucky that it wasn't a solid bollard. New York City is replacing plastic bike lane bollards with steel ones because cars and trucks weren't taking the plastic ones seriously.[1] There's another place where it tries to turn onto the light rail trackway and then ends up in the bus lane, but that area of First Street in San Jose is confusing. Tesla used to make a lot of PR about how they were training their AI collecting data from vehicles in the field, although nobody seems to have tapped in and found out what they're collecting. You'd think that if they did that, they'd log all the places where there was trouble or the human overrode the system. Then transmit cautions to cars getting close to trouble spots, so the fleet as a whole never made the same mistake twice. Apparently not. [1] https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2021/12/21/incoming-dot-commissioner-rodriguez-promises-to-upgrade-half-of-the-citys-plastic-protected-bike-lanes/ https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2021/12/21/incoming-dot-commissi...
- AlexandrB 5y agoInterestingly at the beginning of the video the route planning seems to work overtime to avoid making a specific turn. See about 25s in: https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU?t=25 https://youtu.be/sbSDsbDQjSU?t=25 That's kind of like what you're describing, but more dumb where the car tries to avoid the trouble spot entirely.
- kmonsen 5y agoThe driver is really alert and intervenes super quickly. I don't think we can expect regular drivers to intervene this quickly.