3 ms·
US consumer banking is archaic and can't be fixed with just another bank. The whole process is broken and it requires an industry change. I applaud BankSimple
by sschueller 15y ago
US consumer banking is archaic and can't be fixed with just another bank. The whole process is broken and it requires an industry change.
I applaud BankSimple for what they are doing but in the big picture it doesn't solve the major problems.
My biggest gripes with the banks:
- Can't wire money to someone else without going into the bank and paying ridiculous fees (Last time I checked, $25 for domestic, $45 for international). INGDirect attempts to make this better but the receiver still needs to have an email address and go through a procedure to receive the money. It's also slow, average is 2-3 days.
- It's easier and cheaper for me to use checks. It costs me nothing to deposit it but I have to pay a fee to receive a wire transfer. Wires have a lot fever errors than checks and a wire of over $5k doesn't have to be put on hold because the bank has to verify a check. The banks punish you for using wires instead of checks.
- When you go online and use bill pay the bank will pay a 3rd party to print and mail a check!! How is this electronic payment. (This does not apply to large firms like the phone company which will receive the payment electronically but small business can't utilize this!)
- Why no IBAN? Swift requires intermediary banks which charge a fee on your international wire.
- No chips on debpit/credit cards. In Europe most banks issue cards with chips on them. This would eliminate the risk of getting skimmed if only the US would also start using chips instead of the magnetic stripe.
I just don't understand why the banks do this. Someone enlighten me.
- jessriedel 15y ago> When you go online and use bill pay the bank will pay a 3rd party to print and mail a check!! How is this electronic payment. Is this true? That boggles my mind.
- jh3 15y agoYes it is. AFAIK Wells Fargo/Wachovia still does it.
- bdonlan 15y agoIt depends on the payee. Many payees do support electronic payment; banks will print a check for those that don't. Encouraging people to use bill pay for everything allows them to collect fees from the payee for those who collect electronically, and/or save their own processing costs. If they didn't support _all_ payees, however, people would be more reluctant to use the bill pay system. So it's a marketing decision, to support payees that aren't capable of receiving electronic payments yet.
- sschueller 15y agoThe whole issue is that payees have to pay to receive electronic payment but can receive check payments for free. That makes no sense to me. It should be the other way around. Even if a small business wanted to receive payments electronically the fees are too high for small volumes.
- bdonlan 15y agoIt might make sense in some cases; it takes less labor to accept electronic payments than paper-check payments. If the fees cost less than paper-check processing labor, it makes sense to pay the fees. I agree that it might not make sense for smaller businesses though - but that's why there's the check fallback.
- PotatoEngineer 15y agoI have USAA, and yes, this is exactly what they do (for some payees; others are actually electronic). My bank statement treats it as a check, and they have scans of the checks written this way. It's a bit of a surprise, because I'm writing checks that are numbered 200 or so, and the bank's Bill Pay uses checks numbered 900000 and up. I don't care (much), because the bill is still paid, right? (Granted, it takes longer when they mail the check than when they do the electronic thing.)
- outworlder 15y agoA major bank issuing magnetic stripe only cards would be out of business in less than a month in Brazil. Heck, not even the ATM machines are safe and get blown up quite regularly, even with the systems in place that stain the bills. Perhaps the fix would be to import a few... "bad guys"?
- Raphael 15y agoIn the video, he paid money to another guy (also at BankSimple). Wonder how fast that goes through.
- xinsight 15y agoAgreed. It's frustrating that I can pay money to larger companies online (phone, cable, internet, etc.) but I can't send money to another person. Clearly it's technically possible, but the banks don't want to enable this for normal people, so North American's are stuck mailing IOUs (cheques) around.
- al3x 15y ago(I'm a co-founder of BankSimple.) A lot of the banks mark up their wire transfer fees. We won't. Domestic US transfers with us (ACH) will be free. International transfers (SWIFT) cost us ~$15, and we'll pass that on to our customers with no mark-up. We're trying to make electronic payments easier than checks with some UI innovations that today's demo didn't fully address. We want people to move money electronically, not with paper checks. Bill pay in the US is a mess. We're going to try to have a great bill presentment system to help address this. A lot of the banking world in the US is baffling to us, too. that's why we're doing what we're doing. We won't be able to fix everything overnight, and there's lots that's out of our control at the moment. But over time, we'll chip away at the problems and try to make banking better.
- joelhaus 15y agoOne reason BankSimple will win is (hopefully) because you will not pay too much attention to articles like this: http://www.americanbanker.com/issues/176_184/google-wallet-mobile-payments-isis-lightspeed-1042421-1.html?zkPrintable=1&nopagination=1 http://www.americanbanker.com/issues/176_184/google-wallet-m... Certainly, there are many ready for this world you speak of and we wish you great success!
- sschueller 15y agoThanks for the reply, I hope you guys can fix some of these ridiculous processes. A huge issue for US citizens living abroad is that most US banks require a US home address (might be a patriot act thing). Since all US citizens are required to file and pay taxes even if they don't live or make money in the US (only country in the world that still does this) sending a check to the IRS is not that simple without a US bank account. Will you require US residency or will a US passport suffice?