7 ms·
Eric Schmidt Testifies Before Congress
- llambda 15y agoAlso available here: http://sunlightfoundation.com/live/ http://sunlightfoundation.com/live/
- pycassa 15y agoat D9: According to eric at D9, these are the top consumer companies 1-4-the gang of four(appl,google,amazon,facebook) 5-6(paypal,twitter) Schmidt said he believes Microsoft is “not driving the consumer revolution.” He doesn’t count Microsoft’s Xbox business because it’s “not a platform at the computational level.” today before congress: Microsoft's Bing has continued to gain in popularity, perhaps because it comes pre-installed as the search default on over 70 percent of new computers sold. Microsoft's Bing is the exclusive search provider for Yahoo! and Facebook. Microsoft recently signed a deal for Bing to power English language search on the fast-rising Chinese search engine Baidu, which Baidu has acknowledged will help it become more competitive in markets outside of China. In addition to Internet Explorer, Microsoft has integrated Bing into its popular gaming console, the Xbox 360, which it is in talks with cable companies to convert into the set-top box of the future. Microsoft?s Bing launched in June 2009 and has grown so rapidly that some commentators have speculated that it could overtake Google as early as 2012. Read more: http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-20109615-93/schmidts-written-testimony-before-congress/#ixzz1YcCQbU6L http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-20109615-93/schmidts-writte...
- MikeCapone 15y agoIndeed, but one is comparing the consumer tech market as a whole and the other is just in the search market, so this isn't apples to apples (so to speak), no?
- pycassa 15y agowhen bing alone can challenge google's core business, isn't putting the whole microsoft after twitter and paypal as a consumer tech company silly?
- kenjackson 15y agoReally? Microsoft does: Bing -- second largest search engine XBox -- one of the largest gaming platforms, including Indie games. Windows -- most popular consumer OS Halo -- one of the most popular game franchises ever Kinect -- hottest selling consumer electronics gadget ever Windows Live Messenger -- most popular IM platform in the world Hotmail -- one of the largest email sites in the world IE -- one of the most popular web browsers in the world Metro -- one of the most interesting consumer UIs currently available And all this puts them behind -- Twitter? Really?
- kamaal 15y agoI guess that's the whole problem, Microsoft wants to be everything to everybody. Now just compare the same with Apple. They don't have 1/10th the product line as Microsoft and are still more successful. Focus is important here, when you do so many things and none of them properly you are ultimately in a situation where all your products are weak quality wise. There are always better alternatives in the market and people will feel compelled to switch to them. Imagine this happening with most of your products. Ultimately the whole ecosystem gets weaker. Even though your numbers may be looking good due to volume, that doesn't tell the whole story. Slowly your competitors one by one will drive you out of the market.
- kenjackson 15y agoNow just compare the same with Apple. They don't have 1/10th the product line as Microsoft and are still more successful. The Apple comparison is a red herring. Apple is unique, not only to the computer industry, but virtually all industries. No other company has risen so quickly, from so low, on a few products. To put it another way, if you take Apple out of the equation, MS appears favorable to just about every other company in the industry. From SAP, to HP, to Google, to Facebook, to Twitter, to EA, to DropBox, to Oracle.
- jaryd 15y agoWe need more technically savvy congresspeople.
- DrHankPym 15y agoMaybe we should start electing websites as our representatives.
- endlessvoid94 15y agoThe lack of eloquence and understanding by those congresspeople is very, very disappointing. Mr. Schmidt answered those questions in an excellent manner. The racetrack analogy was particularly unnerving.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- boredguy8 15y agoI disagree that he did a good job answering questions. For instance, I have no idea what it means to "game the system" from his description, nor do I understand the consequences if someone were to game it. How about instead, "If we told everyone our algorithm, when someone searches for this event, it wouldn't be an issue of whether or not your questions or my answers hold the first position, but whether or not the first 100 results are for Viagra or Cialis."
- jaryd 15y ago+1 Did anyone else notice that Al Franken was almost entirely incomprehensible? I'm happy that Schmidt has the presence and patience to pleasantly attempt to correct these scary misinterpretations.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- zyb09 15y agoHoly shit, they're are hammering down on Eric Schmidt accusing Google of tampering with search results and what not for pretty dumb reasons imho. Seems really unfair to me.
- Helianthus 15y agoThey expect him to be able to say "We know that we are not tampering with search results because of x, y, and z"--a strong statement--instead of "Search is a magic box that is imperfect. Shrug?" which is kinda what he said.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rev087 15y agoSenator: "Ok Mr. Schmidth, tell me what I`m thinking."
- xtacy 15y agoIs there a recording available?
- jojopotato 15y agohttp://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/301681-1 http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/301681-1
- yonran 15y agoIt's also available from senate.gov: http://judiciary.senate.gov/hearings/hearing.cfm?id=3d9031b47812de2592c3baeba64d93cb http://judiciary.senate.gov/hearings/hearing.cfm?id=3d9031b4...
- kposehn 15y agoJeff Katz (NexTag) is slamming Google right now for copying his business.
- kposehn 15y agoYelp is up now.
- jc4p 15y agoI can't wait until he starts talking about why Google is bad, I wonder if any one knows about Yelp's "pay us for advertising or you'll have your good reviews deleted" policy.
- electrichead 15y agoThis was my first thought as well. I completely disagree with him that Yelp would not have been able to start up right now. Google would have helped drive traffic to yelp now just as it did then. Edit: I think I remember it being "join Yelp so you can delete the bad reviews".
- jc4p 15y agoI really thought he was going to talk about how he couldn't create Yelp now because of Google buying Zagat but it seemed like his entire point was "Google is evil." I'm glad the person currently speaking who actually understands technology (seemingly) and worked on antitrust law suits knows what she's saying.
- kposehn 15y agoYelp's own actions notwithstanding, it is quite true that Google has pulled some questionable moves and is clearly attempting to drive traffic to their own products. Not that I like Yelp however ლ(ಠ益ಠლ)
- jrockway 15y ago
- yanw 15y agoThese senators seemed ignorant about pretty much everything involved. And as for Mr. Schmidt he should have started by saying that Google is free, it's free for users and for those wanting to be indexed by them so they don't owe any self proclaim competitors anything.
- chsonnu 15y agoWhat's new? It reminds me of the dog and pony shows with Enron and Goldman. These guys aren't skilled at anything other than pandering to the elderly.
- npollock 15y agoThey actually just did. They argued that Google is free, and there's nothing to prevent users from using a different search engine. The argument seems to be that a large market share does not constitute monopoly power. In order for monopoly power to exist, there have to be barriers preventing users from switching search providers.
- drgath 15y ago> In order for monopoly power to exist, there have to be barriers preventing users from switching search providers. That is incorrect. A "monopoly" is simply having a large enough control over the market that you dictate how others access that market. Monopolies are not illegal. Google does have a monopoly on search, Schmidt admitted that much today by saying they are "in the area" of having one. Abusing your monopoly power is however illegal, and that's what Google is being investigated for.
- zmmmmm 15y ago> Abusing your monopoly power is however illega However the principle that underwrites all of it is harm to the consumer. If you can't prove harm then it is hard to justify action. If consumers are choosing the monopoly provider willingly with zero compulsion by factors other than that it serves them well then you have a good argument that the monopoly is not harming the consumer. The best argument would be that the purchasers of advertising are harmed because Google's ad prices are bolstered by their monopoly on search. However even there, Google uses a quite transparent and open bidding system for ads. They have no direct control over what people pay, they don't set their own prices - Google only shows ads at the prices people voluntarily bid. This doesn't put them in the clear but it makes it pretty hard to prove they are gouging or any of the other obvious signs of a monopoly abusing their power.
- kposehn 15y agoSimply put, IMHO what needs to happen is Google needs to be pushed to stop blatantly favoring it's own properties vs. others. At the same time, it cannot become so regulated as to become a utility.
- kposehn 15y agoMs. Creighton is claiming that competition needs to flourish - one important aspect is that competition in an ecosystem you control falls under this statement.
- misterkeeter 15y agoSeems to me that one way you can tell Google has competition is the facebook.com/cspan tag at the bottom of the screen.
- kenjackson 15y agoHuh? Google doesn't really compete in hosted company pages -- at least not until yesterday.
- zmmmmm 15y agoYes, I find it odd that Google gets so much attention while Facebook never rates a mention. I find Facebook way more creepy and actually much harder to switch away from - I can use bing any day of the week and the results are comparable. I can use G+ today and the results are useless. To my mind there has to be some recognition of whether a "monopoly" is due to exploitation of natural barriers to entry or not, and Google seems one of the least problematic in this regard.
- hastalabasura 15y agoSusan Creighton knows her shit.
- kposehn 15y agoShe is smart, but she did skate around the question of scraping. They asked whether Google had scraped content, but instead she attempted to change the question to whether or not it is scraping when they show the excerpt about the site in results - not whether they had scraped Yelp reviews.
- lukeschlather 15y agoI think that's the crux of it though. Of course Google does scraping. They'll even give you a full cache of a page if you ask for it.
- kposehn 15y agoA cache is a bit different though I think - that is a reference. The Yelp case was them using content in their own competing product and then not representing the source clearly. I deal with this as an affiliate all the time. I don't mind Google cacheing my web pages to increase our search ranking and help drive traffic to our site. However, if Google made a competing site about the same products and then took our reviews to use in that site without our permission, then I would have a major problem. I'm not in favor of regulating Google, but I am in favor of some discipline and guidelines being laid down. The government clearly cannot decide how this should work, but I think Google is responsible enough to know that things need to be adjusted and just how much is needed.
- hastalabasura 15y agoNot representing it clearly? When the places pages included Yelp reviews it would put the top review with a link to "View more reviews on Yelp" and very clearly had a Yelp logo next to it. Same with TripAdvisor reviews. Now the places page is only showing Google reviews with "Reviews from around the web"
- aamar 15y agoThe central question seems to be the following, articulated most precisely by Mike Lee (R-UT): even if the organic search results are entirely unbiased, Google also programmatically (via "Google Universal Search", the system that organizes the overall search page) inserts specific links to other Google pages--such as Places, Maps, Shopping, or News--in very prominent positions. There are competitors for all of those sites (Yelp, Nextag), but Google systematically (it seems) prefers their own version. This behavior is relevant to an antitrust principle that a firm with a monopoly in one area/market should not be allowed to use that monopoly to get inordinate market share in other markets. The senators do not appear to have concluded that Google is doing anything illegal, though several have used the words to the effect of "I'm concerned with what is happening here." My take: I agree with other commenters here that the senators have at several points seemed to have gaps in their understanding of Google vs. the average HN commenter, though I didn't hear any overtly wrong claims with respect to the central question. Maybe this analysis is better done by the FTC (there is an investigation in progress there), but it does not seem ridiculous that Congress, which is somewhat more transparent, is asking these particular questions, which do not seem incoherent or pointless.
- yanw 15y agoGoogle is free for users and free to anyone wanting to get in their index, so they do not owe any self proclaimed competitor anything and that is the crux of it, the law is on their side, you cannot monopolize "free" and all this politicians' propaganda is waste of time and tax payer dollars..
- Zakuzaa 15y agoYou clearly have very little understanding of how antitrust laws work.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- coderdude 15y agoHe shares the point of view of the person defending Google (she's a former anti-trust investigator?). If you can freely and instantly switch from Google to Bing then you cannot claim they have a monopoly. If you don't like Google's results there is nothing locking the consumer into Google except their own choice.
- brackin 15y agoFor once Google are being honest and the others are being slimey. In one image they covered the sponsored ads in a box which hid the fact there is a clear differentiation between Sponsored and algorithmic results, they also say "Ads".
- redthrowaway 15y ago>For once Google are being honest and the others are being slimey. For once? I hardly get the impression that Google is slimy and duplicitous, and their competition not so.
- rmrm 15y agoI think Google would be well served if Schmidt had a little more Steve Jobs in him. Not a lot, as I think Jobs might get so frustrated he'd melt down, but a little. Eric makes everything sound somehow slightly sinister, even when it isn't. When asked about something like maps and places the correct answer is: We realized that is what people wanted in response to their queries. We looked around, and the other map products sucked. Also, we couldn't use them in the way we wanted to serve the users, even if we had wanted to. So we spent a ton of money developing our own -- and it absolutely clobbered the competition. It was magical, far better than anything that existed before it. Way more information, way easier and faster to use. And the users have responded overwhelmingly positively to it. If you're asking if we favor our own maps properties, damn right we do. Because it is better. Were the people that made other maps products happy about it? Of course not. We didn't build it for them. We built if for our users. As a part of any online maps product, users want to use it to find information tied to the locations and businesses they are looking at. We call this places. We realized we needed to build something so that we could serve up this information in a highly integrated way, because we believed users wanted a unified experience. So we spent a ton of money, and we built out our maps product with Place information. Business hours, phone numbers, pictures, and reviews. We tried to partner on reviews. It didn't work out. So we built our own review system. And it is brilliant, consumers love it. Maps and Places absolutely blow away anything else that exists in terms of ease of use and functionality and richness of information. It is one of our greatest feats. Again, consumers love it. Were existing business directories and review sites happy about it? Of course not. We didn't build it for them, we built if for our users. Maps, and Places, and Product Search -- they are all part of search. They are all part of finding information, and answers. And that is what we do, and we'll continue to push forward on that front. Because that is what consumers want.
- acidblue 15y agoI wonder how Apple feels about Congress, and others, referring to Google's and Yelp's services as "Apps", hah!
- yanw 15y agoFor fuck's sake senator Blumenthal just asked if Google "Has ever scraped content?" !!
- abailin 15y agoOf course not, it's all user submitted.
- Helianthus 15y agoThat had a very specific meaning in context. He was asking if Google used Yelp's content to build its Places content, in which case Google would be using its capacity as a Search company in order to grant its Places division a competitive (anti-competitive?) advantage against Yelp. If simultaneously it can be shown that Search was favoring bringing attention to Places over Yelp, there might be an anti-trust case. There's a lot of posts on here about how uninformed the politicians seem to be. We seem to forget that _we're_ the ones who are uninformed of the vast technicality that is anti-trust law and the oceans of oratorical precision required in order to establish a legal case.
- yanw 15y agoHe asked both question, that was a separate one in general meaning. As for Google showing snippets of Yelp or anyone else that is still lawful, the whole search business is built of snippets and fair use.
- Helianthus 15y agoagain, you're using 'snippets' out of context and taking the letter of the politician's word at the expense of his intent.
- rshm 15y agoSenator, you have so many hypothetical !
- GeneTraylor 15y agoThey keep pounding the same misconceptions again and again in endless repetition, and I can't help but wonder, who hired these guns? (that's not to say that some of their arguments don't hold water, but they are going to incredible lengths to cast Google as a monopoly, why?) The cynic in me doubts that the cause is a lack of understanding.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- melling 15y agoI'm going to get burned for this comment but ... Microsoft has had a desktop monopoly for 20 years. They have 90% desktop market share and people don't complain about that. They destroyed their competition yet people complain because Google has 65% market share on a product that people can leave overnight. I'm not sure why people get bent out of shape over Google.
- clarkevans 15y agoPeople did complain and Microsoft did have anti-trust case brought about them and a set of behavioral limitations imposed.
- tzs 15y ago> Microsoft has had a desktop monopoly for 20 years. They have 90% desktop market share and people don't complain about that You don't count being fined billions of dollars over that monopoly, being forced by governments to make changes to Windows to help competitors, and being sued by several state governments and others as people complaining!?
- aeturnum 15y agoPeople have complained about Microsoft's monopoly at great length. They had an anti-trust case successfully brought against them in the US and similar cases overseas. It's an issue that people are very much aware of. That aside, the department of justice could (if they hadn't already won against Microsoft) bring two suits simultaneously. The need to investigate one company doesn't stop you from investigating the other.
- yanw 15y agoIt's all political, all grandstandings, and an overall a welfare operation for antitrust lawyers. There is not issue here to start with.
- AgentConundrum 15y agoSo.. who is the asshole, sitting behind (visible to the left of) the ex-FTC commissioner, that's constantly laughing, shaking his head, and rolling his eyes at what she's saying? He is extremely irritating.
- mrtron 15y agoHe keeps staring at the camera, I almost wonder who is paying him to be there making those actions. I would bet a 6 pack of beer he is a paid lobbyist.
- miql 15y agoI noticed that, too. Not only did I find that annoying, I think it was disrespectful.
- nkassis 15y agoI wouldn't be surprised either. I'd like to know how do spectator get access to the room? Can anyone show up to a hearing like this? Placing someone would be hard, involving knowing where the cams are and how to position yourself and getting there first.
- oldstrangers 15y agoThe antitrust regulator just asked about sending in a third party to review google's search algorithm. Haha. Hahahahaa. Not a chance.
- 0x12 15y agoAnd why not? Google could put up a lot of resistance but if the government wants something bad enough they generally get it. The other option is not to do business in that particular country, and for google that option is not on the table.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- zmmmmm 15y agoNot sure if it was the GP's point, but it seems incredibly naive to think that the search algorithm itself is such that someone can just go in and "look" at it and gain any meaningful understanding. Even assuming Google is guilty of outright manipulation there's never going to be a smoking gun of "if(website == google) rank = rank +1, it is going to be an abstract machine learning algorithm with hundreds of inputs and dozens of outputs, all themselves the results of complex statistical properties gleaned from the web. There would be zero insight available to any mere mortal who might gain access to the code driving it.
- LukeHoersten 15y agoWatch the recording here: http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/OversightofG http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/OversightofG
- martingordon 15y agoLast I checked it wasn't possible to switch the default search engine on Android phones (whether it was set to Google or otherwise). Is this still the case? I couldn't find anything conclusive in my searching.
- Kadrith 15y agoFrom what I understand that is an issue with the Telcom, not with Google.
- magicalist 15y agoI don't see an option for it, but you can replace the entire home screen app (though maybe not if your carrier has locked it?), which could accomplish the same thing if there was a good bing-based home screen out there.
- nextparadigms 15y agoI'm not sure what you mean. You can't try a new widget instead of the Google Search one? Or are you saying that widget should allow you to switch to Bing?
- myko 15y agoI think generally this is a very simple thing to do, by installing a widget for another search engine for instance. Also once you install Chrome on the desktop you get a choice of Google, Bing, or Yahoo as your default.
- itswindy 15y agoEric Schmidt: I am not a cook. So who cooks the algo Eric?
- dmpayton 15y agoSomething that kind of irked me about Jeremy Stoppelman's testimony: He failed to mention that Yelp provides an API and, in essence, gives away their data. If Google was consuming their API (vs. scraping content directly from their site), would this even be an issue? Let's assume, hypothetically, that Google used the API provided by Yelp to enhance their search results. If Yelp said, "We don't like what you're doing, so stop because we said so", I feel that it would totally be within Googles rights to say, "Fine, we no longer wish to do business with you and will exclude you from our index". Of course, I'm not entirely sure what the Yelp API of 2010 looked like, nor have I read their TOS. However, I still feel that Stoppelman's testimony did more to remove my desire to ever use Yelp than it did to convince me that Google is this big evil monopoly that's destroying the little guy.
- vogonj 15y agohttp://www.yelp.com/developers/getting_started/api_terms http://www.yelp.com/developers/getting_started/api_terms http://www.yelp.com/developers/getting_started/display_requirements http://www.yelp.com/developers/getting_started/display_requi... http://www.yelp.com/static?p=tos http://www.yelp.com/static?p=tos "5. Restrictions You agree that you will not, and will not assist or enable others to: ... B. modify the Yelp Content, or use it to update or create your own database of business listing information;" "As between you and Yelp, you own Your Content. We own the Yelp Content, including but not limited to visual interfaces, interactive features, graphics, design, compilation, computer code, products, software, aggregate user review ratings, and all other elements and components of the Site excluding Your Content, User Content and Third Party Content. We also own the copyrights, trademarks, service marks, trade names, and other intellectual and proprietary rights throughout the world ("IP Rights") associated with the Yelp Content and the Site, which are protected by copyright, trade dress, patent, trademark laws and all other applicable intellectual and proprietary rights and laws. As such, you may not modify, reproduce, distribute, create derivative works or adaptations of, publicly display or in any way exploit any of the Yelp Content in whole or in part except as expressly authorized by us." republishing of Yelp's content, except as allowed by its Terms of Use, Terms of Service, and Display Requirements, is against the terms of your agreement with Yelp, and illegal. even though someone grants you an API to remix their data, their intellectual property rights to that data are not waived.
- jinushaun 15y agoI hope the politicians don't confuse plain old search result rankings with smart searches. http://www.google.com/landing/searchtips/ http://www.google.com/landing/searchtips/ When I enter "1+1" into Google, I expect back "2", not a link to a calculator website. When I enter a street address, I want the first result to be a map, not a link to a mapping website. When I enter a stock symbol, I want the current stock price at the top of the results, not a link to a slow loading website. Google has had these smart search results since day one and the functionality keeps expanding much to the displeasure of some companies. One could argue that this is an example of Google "favouring" its own services, but as a consumer, that's what I expect and that's why I keep using Google! I don't want links, I want answers. Bing likes to talk about being a "decision engines", but Google did it first.
- Volpe 15y agoIs this not similar to "Free-to-Air" TV stations promoting their own shows rather than competing stations shows. Seems identical given the fact they both generate revenue from advertising, are "anti-competitive", and free (to the viewer of ads)
- dennisgorelik 15y agoIt sounds like both questions and answers are scripted. Edit: that was my impression in the beginning of that show. After warming up the questions became deeper and more interesting.
- itsnotvalid 15y agoThey still haven't open sourced Android 3.0, in which they said they would never release that part of Apache licensed code to the public. So there could then be a possibility, again be hidden APIs so that their tablet app offerings could be better than others. I personally think that, if you claim open source, some should be able to obtain the code if they are using the software itself. I clearly don't think a normal android tablet user would reasonably grab a copy of that source code.
- myko 15y agoDo you have a reason to believe the source code will not be released for Ice Cream Sandwich?
- itsnotvalid 15y agoIf ICS would run nicely on tablets, it would have some meaning.
- ashishgandhi 15y ago> "Jeremy Stoppelman, CEO of Yelp and also a witness at today's hearing, said otherwise. He said Google demanded that Yelp comply with Google demands to be included in Google's search engine, including providing its content to Google." Is that quoted out of context? If not, that sounds worrying.
- ybot 15y agoFrom Jeremy Stoppelman's written testimony, as posted on Yelp's blog (here: http://officialblog.yelp.com/2011/09/seeking-a-level-playing-field.html http://officialblog.yelp.com/2011/09/seeking-a-level-playing...): "In 2010, Google began incorporating the content that it indexed from its competitors into Google Local without permission. Although Google had previously acknowledged that it needed a license to use Yelp’s content, it was now using it without permission to prop up its own, less effective product. In some instances, Google even presented this content to its users as if it were its own. [See Exhibit C] Google’s Offers a False Choice In response to our objections, Google informed us that it would cease the practice only if we agreed to be removed from Google’s web search index, thereby preventing Yelp from appearing anywhere in Google web search results. This, of course, was a false choice. Google’s dominant position in the market prevents services like Yelp from exercising any sort of meaningful choice in the matter: it is a choice between allowing Google to co-opt one’s content and not competing at all."
- ashishgandhi 15y agoThat sounds evil.
- arron61 15y agoGoogle Places is just another search engine but specifically for places (aka restaurants and stores). It used to be the case that it will aggregate all reviews from multiple review sites and show snippets of the reviews and then have a corresponding link for them to click on to go to the real site. So in a sense, it's really just another search engine again, no different than the universal Google search, image search, product search, and etc. It's using the same indexed data but presented in two forms. Yelp wanted Google to remove them from product search and not universal search. This is why the google lawyer said this requires extra engineering. Yelp basically wants one thing and not another. If you do a product search now, of course, you don't see any Yelp links at all (since they requested Google to remove them) and you see no snippets from any other review sites. All you see are google's own reviews and then some links on the bottom showing show more reviews from other sites. This was changed - and I think it makes it worse for Yelp and other review sites - but they wanted it this way.