3 ms·
> We've made a real mess in some third world countries with the cash spigot. Has there been a comparable scenario of direct cash transfers to poor people?
by sofixa 5y ago
> We've made a real mess in some third world countries with the cash spigot.
Has there been a comparable scenario of direct cash transfers to poor people?
- zozbot234 5y agoGiveDirectly has studied this, and it's absolutely not making a "mess". What makes a mess is foreign aid directed at corrupt, large-scale, government- or NGO-driven "development" schemes. Giving cash just leaves the choice as to how to use the money to those who are best equipped to make it.
- dado3212 5y agoI agree with the former (GiveDirectly and other institutions like J-PAL have been huge in putting together randomized trials around aid effectiveness, [1] for a specific example). The latter I think is more up for debate. There are papers showing that aid is still effective in areas with high government corruption. Definitely a pretty debated area though in terms of effectiveness of foreign aid. [1]. https://www.povertyactionlab.org/case-study/giving-directly-support-poor-households https://www.povertyactionlab.org/case-study/giving-directly-...