5 ms·
As someone who have worked a lot for banks and actually already done some of this work let me offer a viewpoint. Last year my company managed to get a large Da
by ThomPete 15y ago
As someone who have worked a lot for banks and actually already done some of this work let me offer a viewpoint.
Last year my company managed to get a large Danish bank to implement tracking into their netbank. This is no small accomplishment, which anyone knowing just a little bit about how the IT departments in the banking industry normally works, the systems they work on are arcane.
It took us 18 months from getting the bank to like the idea into actually getting it launched.
The results have been nothing but extraordinary everyone loves it.
The reason they love it is because it's automatic. They get insights into their economy that they could not previously get. There is something quite amazing about seeing your spendings categorized for the first time without you having to do anything.
The banks have a unique identifier on each transaction that can be measured up against a category list. This is something Mint and Wesabe can't do because you can't export that unique identifer from the banks.
The big advantage of BankSimple and why I think it's going to be huge is because they don't have a legacy system to deal with.
In other words BankSimple can potentially be anything you could ever dream of a bank being, because BankSimple will be able to cross reference the data in order to provide not just cost reduction but service improvement.
The banking industry are just waiting to be disrupted by someone like BS. There are thousands of ways to create a better banking experience. BS is a good first stab at it IMHO.
- jtbigwoo 15y agoI've said this here before, but when I worked at a big bank all the visionaries weren't worried about other banks, they were worried about Google and Ebay. The core business of a bank is built on hardware and software. They knew that a bank built on distributed systems instead of mainframes could beat the big banks on features and cost. It'll be interesting to see if BankSimple can scale up fast enough to compete or if it'll attract the attention of someone with even deeper pockets who can catch up by simply outspending them.
- alwillis 15y agoThere are lots of banks that could easily outspend BankSimple, what they lack is vision, which is far more scarce than money these days.
- jtbigwoo 15y agoBanks are in a rough spot, actually. The big ones have a HUGE installed base which makes any changes very, very difficult. My division of the bank had tens of thousands of cobol jobs that ran daily or weekly. (We also had thousands of ETL jobs, web apps, etc. that depended on those cobol jobs.) Trying to shift the core functionality away the mainframe would have been a decade-long boondoggle.
- alastairpat 15y agoAs somebody else mentioned, it's not just about money. Here in Australia, we have four massive banks. They're some of the most profitable in the world and three of them are currently in the process of major technology renewal programmes. The problem is that the systems are so complex, inter-linked and old (the last upgrade was apparently in the 80s) that making changes is a nightmare. Indeed, one particular bank, NAB, has had huge problems leaving people unable to access their money for several days, caused by upgrades. Downtime is completely out of the question and making radical changes (could render some obscure system inoperable) is impossible. While there is a lack of vision, I think it goes far deeper than that.
- yxhuvud 15y agoI believe there will be a big shift coming, but not that it will come from established tech companies in the developed world. Rather, I believe it is banks from third world countries that will push the envelope. This for a few reasons: They already have a large customer base. Their economies are growing very fast, which creates a steadily increasing pressure on old systems. Also, this creates shifting marketplaces where new players in the area can pop up a lot more easy than in old settled markets. Less preconceptions on what can or cannot be done.
- foobarbazetc 15y agoConsidering that BankSimple is "just" a distributed interface to a mainframe system... that's an amusing statement.
- bergie 15y agoOne of the reasons I'm so eagerly waiting for SEPA (Single European Payment Area) to really come into force. Now banks compete mostly on country level, but when you can easily switch banks inside EU, there is bound to be some competition and innovation. In Finland we're kind of suffering from being pioneers. Finnish banks deployed nice (for the time) web banking interfaces more than a decade ago. But then, having made the big investments in them and seeing little competition, innovation stopped. Nordea rolled out a slightly improved web interface a couple of years ago, and ever since then their login page has had the message "the new banking interface is coming to our business customers soon"...
- jarek 15y agoEven without SEPA in full swing, your banking situation is still miles ahead of anyone in North America. A nice web interface is one thing, a $25 wire transfer or relying on external, often slow payment processors like Paypal or Certapay/e-Transfer quite another.
- mahyarm 15y agoBanks can give these interfaces easily, like generalized ACH interfaces, like some merchants have already, but then it would expose to the general public how badly secured the entire design of the system is.