3 ms·
Consider what is collected today: If you video chat with doctors, look at the privacy policies of the video chat platform. IME, it doesn't differ from most oth
by wolverine876 5y ago
Consider what is collected today:
If you video chat with doctors, look at the privacy policies of the video chat platform. IME, it doesn't differ from most other applications: We collect what we want, including medical data; we share it with partners for marketing, etc. And of course the only clause that matters: We can change our policy at any time by posting a new one to this page (i.e., without notification, effectively), so effectively we have no policy and can do whatever we want.
Someone I know needed a prescription medication that they didn't want in public records, for understandable reasons (I would be concerned too). It wasn't a 'controlled substance' like a narcotic; what they wanted was perfectly legal and appropriate; it was just a prescription drug that implied a certain underlying condition and related events, and they wanted privacy. They asked me for suggestions. I suggested that the best they could do was to find a small, independent pharmacy; call ahead to verify that the pharmacy didn't share its data; and pay with cash (apparently ID was required to obtain any prescription drug). They did all that and reconfirmed all that at the pharmacy. The next time they were at a doctor in the giant local health co, the nurse asked about the drug, which appeared in the health system's medical records. Later, for unrelated reasons, they obtained their own credit report and it included the drug (!).
Epilogue: When I go to the doctor these days, as I'm signing in they tell me to sign on a small touch-sensitive pad. The pad is about the size of a signature line and displays nothing. What am I signing? That I received their privacy notifications. (I didn't omit a step - they never mentioned or offered them otherwise.) My pharmacy is similar - 'sign', they tell me.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI would need hard evidence to believe a credit report had someone’s prescription medication listed on it. Or anything non borrowing money related / identity / location history listed. https://www.usa.gov/credit-reports https://www.usa.gov/credit-reports Even the Medical Information Bureau report should not list medications: > Doctors, hospitals, pharmacies, and other health professionals can’t submit information to MIB. The report won’t include every diagnosis, blood test, or a list of your medicines.
- wolverine876 5y agoI actually saw it. It was in a separate section of the report. Also, how did their hospital chain obtain the data? Connecting dots - a dangerous form of reasoning - I guessed it was via this report. Looking around: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/how-can-i-find-out-whats-in-my-medical-payment-history-en-1837/ https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/how-can-i-find-out-... How can I find out what’s in my medical payment history? You should contact the consumer reporting agencies that specialize in medical records or payments. These agencies may supply reports on your prescription drug purchase histories, medical conditions, data from your insurance applications, and data from other sources. Life insurance companies, for example, commonly use these reports to evaluate policy applications from potential customers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 5y agoCredit reports come from the credit reporting agencies, of which there are 3 - Equifax, Experian, and Transunion. You are legally entitled to get one free credit report per credit reporting agency per year from annualcreditreport.com The above quote: > the consumer reporting agencies that specialize in medical records or payments. indicates to me that the consumerfinance.gov website is not talking about the credit reporting agencies because they do not specialize in medical records, and hence medication information would not appear on a credit report. As I understand, a healthcare provider would have to sell the unpaid bill to a debt collector and only then would the debt show up in a credit report (but it would not have details about what you purchased, just like any other debt does not on your credit report). Perhaps you did see details of medications on a credit report from Equifax/Experian/Transunion, but it makes no sense to me, so I would need extra proof.
- wolverine876 5y agoIt was a pretty standard-looking credit report, though it was long and detailed. IME, 'what makes sense to me' is an unreliable signal of truth. It does strongly signal my limits, however. If I treat it as a signal of truth, I limit the world to what I already believe - a very narrow subset that is also subject to my biases and misunderstandings, and one that excludes the most ripe areas for learning: things I have no idea about, that are a corrective for my many errors, or that I had no idea even existed.