3 ms·
Respectfully, no. My wife’s pregnancy and expected due date were available on a list sold by zip code, which I know because I purchased it after it was identif
by Spooky23 5y ago
Respectfully, no.
My wife’s pregnancy and expected due date were available on a list sold by zip code, which I know because I purchased it after it was identified by Enfamil. I also learned that my neighbor has type-2 diabetes and another has a child with ADHD, among other things.
In my wife’s case, she suffered from an ectopic pregnancy that resulted in a near death experience, and subsequent admission to the OB floor of the hospital. The admission and drugs prescribed are sold/reported in near real-time to various data aggregators, who in turn are able to link them to the ob/gyn who performed the emergency surgery. We think that the admission to the obstetric floor, duration of hospital stay and certain prescriptions trigged a false hit of “pregnant”.
This data is poorly anonymized and can be trivially reconstructed. Both an attorney I hired and an investigator from the state health department confirmed that. There was no retail behavioral tracking because the events happened before my wife was aware that she was pregnant.
Insurance company and medical data is used for all sorts of practices. The state of Georgia, for example, has a anti-opioid surveillance system that uses Medicaid, private insurance, and behavioral data to identify pregnant women at risk of delivering an opioid addicted child. (Which will cost state Medicaid $1M or more)
- jtbayly 5y agoSo this is a slam dunk violation of HIPAA, no? What did the lawyer say? Edit: I see now that technically they say it’s anonymized. I’m assuming that’s the answer. So basically HIPAA is privacy theater, the same as we have security theater at the airport now and financial accountability theater and the latest: data privacy theater via GDPR.
- walnutclosefarm 5y agoIt is a clear cut HIPAA violation if the data sold to the data aggregator contained personal identifiers of any kind. The standard is not that data be "anonymized" but that all personal identifiers be redacted from the data. This includes dates, addresses (typically the finest grain of address information you can include is the first 3 digits of the zipcode, and sometimes not that), birthdays. The redaction does not mean that data cannot under some circumstances be re-identified, of course. But it's not trivial.