7 ms·
Yeah, it's a privacy nightmare. The exchanges refuse our money if it has ever passed through a privacy service and they continue to track what we do with it eve
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
Yeah, it's a privacy nightmare. The exchanges refuse our money if it has ever passed through a privacy service and they continue to track what we do with it even after it's been withdrawn from our accounts. Nice to have a collection of examples I can point to whenever someone says bitcoin is fungible.
It makes no sense to me how bitcoin is still number one cryptocurrency despite it's garbage fundamentals. Failed at everything it was supposed to do.
- alienalp 5y agoWhat are you expecting exchanges to do? If you passed through privacy service you need to prove that your money is not associated with crimes. It is completely your fault. I am actually happy to hear that people who are laundering money will have hard time. On the other hand bitcoin is shitcoin. That is a fact anybody shills bitcoin is possible scammer. Anybody says bitcoin is future is retarded.
- delusional 5y agoBecause the intersection of the stated goals and the actual goals is essentially empty. The actual goal isn't to be useful, it's to make the early adopters rich.
- dandare 5y agoThat's brilliantly said! The argumentation of typical crypto fan is like the motte and bailey fallacy mounted on a helicopter rotor, constantly oscillating between some noble goals (decentralisation, freedom, privacy, anti-inflation, anti-fractional banking) and the "have fun staying poor" snark.
- TillE 5y agoIt's such a bizarre industry because I think the technical issues are really interesting and the potential for cryptocurrency is huge, but in practice it's 99% about speculators trying to get rich quick. That's really boring!
- leppr 5y agoIt is, but there's probably more actual interesting development and design activity going on than you realize. There's simply a real discovery problem, because of the aforementioned gold rush. Participants have too many incentives to bury accurate information that speaks against their investment, spread misinformation that embellishes it, suppress information about projects they want to invest in but didn't yet, ...
- astrange 5y ago"The technical issues are really interesting" is how you know it's a scam. It's like working for Facebook; they keep everyone interested by having them write unnecessary but interesting projects like new build systems and new PHP runtimes. Except that every contribution makes the price of ETH go up, and FB pays you.
- edrxty 5y agoI...think you just described society
- _alex_ 5y agothat's an ignorant statement. There is a ton of development and deployment happening to make the Lightning Network be a high-throughput, low cost way to move bitcoin around the world. A lot of people are working to make bitcoin more useful to more people.
- wmf 5y agoEven with Lightning, Bitcoin won't ever be good digital cash because it won't have stable value and it isn't as private as, say, ZCash.
- freebuju 5y agoTo be fair, we have given Bitcoin more than enough time to mature into the ideals Nakamoto had envisioned. Can we just call it a failed project and move on to cryptos that actually deliver on the promise.
- magicjosh 5y agoIt really does seem like the main purpose Bitcoin is succeeding at is sort of a digital gold. It's not good as cash, privacy, or anything else. Lightning seems like a joke compared to the types of efforts happening on Ethereum. Appreciate this thorough analysis of problems with cryptocurrency. Disclosure: crypto owner
- dmihal 5y agoOne project I'm following is Aztec Protocol. It's an Ethereum L2 (so faster & cheaper transactions, similar to Lightning) but it supports any Ethereum asset (ETH, USDC, WBTC) and is fully private.
- itvision 5y agoThe only thing that goes for Ethereum is the fact that it's used for creating worthless numerous other pump and dump crypto currencies on top of its blockchain where Shiba Inu is the latest glorious example. Solves nothing, serves no purpose but increases the demand for Ethereum transactions which ultimately drives the cost of Ethereum. All those poor sods who have invested in Shiba Inu? Plain idiots to put it mildly. Oh, and NFTs as well. Another worthless crap just to create more Ethereum transactions. Why worthless? Because ... Ethereum is just one of multiple crypto currencies/block chains and tell me again why your particular NFT on top of Ethereum is worth more than the same object on another blockchain? And how many times can the same object be (re)sold on all other blockchains? Do you need to own all of them? Or Ethereum NFT is somehow better?
- stavros 5y agoAren't NFTs very very useful for money laundering?
- dlubarov 5y agoNo affiliation with Aztec, but it's absurd to lump them in the same bucket as Shiba. > pump and dump crypto currencies Aztec has been in development since 2017, and has solved some real problems in cryptography in order to accomplish their goals. Besides, it doesn't have its own token, so there's nothing to pump. > Solves nothing, serves no purpose It allows Ethereum users to transact in private. > but increases the demand for Ethereum transactions which ultimately drives the cost of Ethereum It does the opposite, since it's a rollup - the transactions happen off-chain.
- can16358p 5y agoEven though Bitcoin failed at many things, I don't see it as a failure as it literally started it all. All the other cryptos are created after Bitcoin and learned from its shortcomings to build something better.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoIt did create and then prove an incredible and utterly novel and important concept. Your downvotes are invalid. I don't own and never have owned any btc, or any other crypto, and at this point wouldn't touch btc in particular with a 10' pole for several different reasons. But the very concept of a distributed ledger that may actually be trusted is both revolutionary and proved. It's collossal despite all the current degenerate uses and wasteful implementations.
- z3c0 5y agoAgreed. When the integrity of the chain is compromised, I'll call it a failure. In the meantime, I'll leave it to the opinionated pissants on both sides to continue acting like they understand anything about what's to come from a system with so little precedence.
- itvision 5y ago> It makes no sense to me how bitcoin is still number one cryptocurrency despite it's garbage fundamentals. Failed at everything it was supposed to do. It hasn't failed at not being controlled by people which fiat currencies have failed completely. Do you control the inflation rate? Do you control how much currency is being minted? And tons of other things.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> hasn't failed at not being controlled by people which fiat currencies have failed completely. Do you control the inflation rate? Bitcoin has proven to be a worthless dollar inflation hedge. It’s more correlated to the stock market than any real dollar.
- trhway 5y agoLike a marshland for tidal water, stock is best inflation hedge working by sponging the overflowing inflational liquidity, and no wonder that Bitcoin behave similarly.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> stock is best inflation hedge working by sponging the overflowing inflational liquidity, and no wonder that Bitcoin behave similarly Agree on the mechanics. Equities are a classic inflation hedge. But the reality is that if three people, in the last year, attempted an inflation hedge, one with TIPs or Series I bonds; one with equities; and one with Bitcoin, the last gained little over the middle. Both likely lost value relative to the first. If your inflation hedge loses value during inflation because the Fed will raise interest rates because of inflation, yes, there were external factors at play, but no, they’re not to blame, you hedged badly.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> Do you control the inflation rate? Do you control how much currency is being minted? Exchanges are essentially banks. They offer bitcoin loans, essentially creating new coins out of nowhere. Fixed money supply is utterly powerless before the inflationary power of debt.
- analognoise 5y agoIt's Pokemon cards, but for tech bros.
- Geee 5y agoIf you compare to Monero, you see that Monero isn't even allowed on these exchanges. So, it seems that you can't really have privacy combined with high exchange liquidity.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI was under the impression the exchanges chose not to list Monero voluntarily. After all, Binance does have it.
- sgp_ 5y agoKraken US supports Monero, so clearly it can be done. If another exchange chooses not to, that's a company making their own decision.
- magicjosh 5y agoCan you explain what you mean by "high exchange liquidity"? My understanding is it's a policy issue not tech. Automated exchanges like Uniswap have Monero. edit: Uniswap has Wrapped Monero, not actual Monero.
- popol12 5y agoNot answering to the question, just correcting your last phrase: Uniswap has wrapped monero (WXMR) which is not quite the same as Monero, and with a ridiculous liquidity of ~200k$ currently (https://geckoterminal.com/eth/pools/0x14c10b4bdccd9d3f8940fb79e0ee00121391d6de?utm_source=coingecko&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=livechart https://geckoterminal.com/eth/pools/0x14c10b4bdccd9d3f8940fb...)
- matheusmoreira 5y agoHow does wrapped monero work? I've seen a lot of wrapped coins but I'm not sure why they exist or why I would want to use them.
- 5y ago
- notRobot 5y ago> The exchanges refuse our money if it has ever passed through a privacy service I'd love to learn more about this, does anyone have relevant links or info?
- magicjosh 5y agoHere's a relevant episode of the ZK Podcast about cryptocurrency mixers: https://zeroknowledge.fm/111-2/ https://zeroknowledge.fm/111-2/
- shubhamkrm 5y agoIt's called "tainted Bitcoin". Basically, you can get a list of all transactions a coin was involved in since it was minted. If any of those transactions contain a blacklisted address, exchanges would refuse the token.
- ur-whale 5y ago> I'd love to learn more about this, It's worse than this. Coinbase, for example, will close your account if you use you Bitcoins for things they don't approve of AFTER you withdraw them.
- AlexandrB 5y agoThis is... remarkable. Many cryptocurrency advocates have promoted bitcoin by making exaggerated claims regarding fiat currency's centralized control and lack of privacy. Now bitcoin itself exhibits the very characteristics that were often claimed about fiat currency, except it's not an exaggeration.
- jakupovic 5y agoEasy solution don't use Coinbase. It's not the end of the world.
- ur-whale 5y ago> Easy solution don't use Coinbase I most certainly don't. But the hordes of clueless users who continue to flock to the platform are blissfully ignorant of that fact. Worse, the fact that coinbase is behaving in a way that's completely violating the spirit of Bitcoin while profiting from it doesn't solve the problem that what they are doing is possible because of a severe limitation of the platform. I am a big and very long time fan of Bitcoin, but the traceability / fungibility issue has bugged me from day one. I really wish the dev. community would focus on introducing a fork with an technical solution to this problem instead of polishing the turd with minor stuff no one really cares about like taproot.
- mattalex 5y ago> It makes no sense to me how bitcoin is still number one cryptocurrency despite it's garbage fundamentals. Failed at everything it was supposed to do. It doesn't matter that bitcoin failed in everything it set out to do (and more) because people don't "hodl" bitcoin for the things bitcoin set out to solve. They do so because the want to go "to the moon". If your only interest in crypto is speculative investment, then you aren't interested in the fact that bitcoin is broken beyond belief: The important thing is the market-recognition since that maximises the chance for high demand, which induces hyper-deflation, which sends you to the moon. Nobody, or very few people, care about crypto for any of its features and the people that tell you they do probably "hodl" substantial amounts of crypto and hope to drag you into the pump. There's not a single problem crypto solves without inducing a new party with equal amounts of leverage (i.e. you don't need VISA, but you do need exchanges) because at the end of the day, crypto is built to change the people that control the money rather than remove control structures entirely because that's impossible: there are always going to be people that facilitate the interaction of the blockchain with the real world and these interpreters/resolvers are the powers in crypto. However, that doesn't matter: nobody buys crypto the currency, they buy crypto the investment and from that POV bitcoin is still the non-plus-ultra in speculative hyper-deflations.
- creamyhorror 5y ago> crypto is built to change the people that control the money Yep, crypto is a revolution being staged to replace the establishment (central banks and traditional finance) with a new one (crypto/defi founders and adopters). The goal is to use the new marketing to draw people to the new system and become the new rich. The earlier and more you buy into it, the more incentive you have to spread the word. This is why it makes sense to rebuild everything in crypto despite it being less efficient. It needs to be done, so that the new system (that replaces all parts of the old) is ready for people to be drawn into it.
- gingeropolous 5y agoits less efficient because decentralized things are less efficient by design. they sacrifice efficiency for the authoritiless nature. That is the goal - to remove authority from money. Money should just exist and have rules and thats it. That's what cryptocurrencies are. to me, its that even if what is happening is that some new ruling class is being established, the difference is that the new ruling class won't be able to fundamentally change the rules anymore. Currently our monetary system is managed by rooms of Very Smart People that can change things at a whim and the cracks are starting to show. but yeah, things are interesting though.... there is a recent upswell of proof of stake, which is just central banking all over again. So the new system might end up looking the same as the old system if these PoS coins become more common. The difference is though is that bitcoin is unstoppable. Like, its price could be 40k, its price could be 400k. The protocol will still work. The old system has no choice but to adapt or whatever.
- leppr 5y agoThere's one thing that Bitcoin does better than almost any other cryptocurrency right now, and it's being secure against consensus attacks. Ethereum comes close, Chia arguably surpasses it, but otherwise most cryptocurrencies could very easily succomb to collusion and majority attacks.
- gnramires 5y agoProof of stake chains are virtually immune to collusion and majority attacks. A single actor would need to own huge amount of resources and then essentially burn the coins. To purchase such a dominant stake the price would rise very quickly... making it very unlikely to be feasible. In comparison, attacking the larger Proof of work chains only requires a few $100M in hardware (the harder ones) and a MW-scale power source used sparingly. I don't see why PoW is still used...
- leppr 5y agoThey are not immune at all. The security assumptions are different. > A single actor would need to own huge amount of resources and then essentially burn the coins. To purchase such a dominant stake the price would rise very quickly... making it very unlikely to be feasible. You are assuming here a single-sided market where the existing majority holders are not interested in realizing profits on their holdings. For many cryptocurrencies this is not the case, especially the hyped VC-funded ones.
- gnramires 5y agoIf you are a large majority holder, selling off to a known exploiter is a very risky move. You might be able to realize great profits of the price increases. But you don't know how much the attacker has gathered from other sources. I think realistically it can happen, but a takeover attempt from buying a large stake should be plainly obvious. The community could even organize price fixing (i.e. "hold", which we've seen on WSB) to fend off the attack. You can even pull off something like forking the chain to invalidate the funds of the attacker -- it would be pretty obvious which stakeholders are responsible for the attack. For a chain where those coins are tainted or deleted from the chain. Those avenues are not really available for PoW chains... if an attacker gets the necessary hardware, there's not much you can do. You can try changing protocol, changing algorithms, etc. but this has obvious consequences of its own (making all mining hardware so far near worthless)... it's a bit scary to be honest.
- hyperhopper 5y agoHow did it fail at creating a distributed database of a finite digital good made up of non-trustworthy actors? Yeah it's not a good currency but many design goals were reached.
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoI think it was a proof of concept. It did its job, but the speculators can't let go.
- w_TF 5y agoIt's amazing how they keep shifting the goal posts every couple years. First it was supposed to be digital cash, but then suddenly it's gold and now "digital property". When it became apparent that it's very wasteful they said the only thing hard money can be backed by is pure entropy.
- Quindecillion 5y ago> It makes no sense to me how bitcoin is still number one cryptocurrency despite it's garbage fundamentals. Failed at everything it was supposed to do. Peer-to-peer, permissionless, trustless (i.e. not controlled by any one entity), known issuance schedule, fixed maximum supply, and unyielding consensus parameters all still hold up today. Seems to be doing just fine at what it was "supposed to do".