9 ms·
Those unsubscribe links should be there, for several reasons. - The service-based economy means that entities (individuals and businesses) have numerous relati
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Those unsubscribe links should be there, for several reasons.
- The service-based economy means that entities (individuals and businesses) have numerous relationships. For the typical individual the number of password-based accounts crossed the 100 threshold years ago, at a doubling rate of every 2--3 years.
- Responsibilities can be transferred. The person who signed up for your service 5 years ago may no longer be at the company.
- List purging is a Real Thing. A few years back I'd worked for an organisation that had ... numerous relationships ... with individuals and corporations. These received regular email messages. Nominally, requested. Included amongst these was a major Wall Street financial firm whose implosion years earlier hit lead news and headlines worldwide. Despite not existing for years, there remained hundreds if not thousands of addresses being sent email on a regular ongoing basis.
- Mail can be forwarded. It's quite possible that you're sending mail to one address that is is being forwarded, manually or automatically, to others. This raises issues in unsubscribe requests, but might at the least be an opportunity to reach out to your customer to clarify the situation.
- I don't know if revisiting email contact approval on a regular basis (say once every year or two) is yet a recommended practice, but I'd strongly suggest that it be so.
Your hat may be less blisteringly white than you presume.
- contravariant 5y agoI've also had email from the wrong person delivered to me some times. One company in particular kept sending updates for a service I had no way of using. An unsubscribe link would have been handy, though confirming email addresses before linking them to an account would also be a good idea, probably.
- rsync 5y agoEverything you've said makes perfect sense - for a contact management function. We have that. You can change contact info, set owner/technical/emergency contacts, alert thresholds, etc. But unsubscribe means something totally different: When I click on unsubscribe I want it to be the end of all communications. Period. In this case, that makes no sense. Ceasing communications for all purposes implies service cancellation and, in our case, service cancellation implies a human interaction confirming data destruction. How would we confirm data destruction for your implied cancellation if no further contact is permitted ? You, and the blacklist operators, have become so jaded by the abuse you've suffered that you've forgotten that legitimate, paid services exist. I'm sorry.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou may have missed that bit in my earlier comment about working for a paid service provider.
- seszett 5y agoAn unsubscribe link doesn't have to immediately cancel all service and communication. It can simply lead to account settings or even to a page explaining how to cancel the account.
- xist 5y agoFrom a comment below from the other side of the equation it sounds like the email in question WAS indeed marketing for a lifetime promotion. People should have every right to unsubscribe themselves from that, and thus should have some sort of feedback loop attached to the email being sent (to the detriment of your bottom line I fully understand and sympathize with). If this was indeed a marketing email, then I don't think it matters if it comes from a "legitimate, paid service" - the receiver still should be able to choose if they want to receive sales related emails wouldn't you agree?
- rsync 5y ago"People should have every right to unsubscribe themselves from that, and thus should have some sort of feedback loop attached to the email being sent (to the detriment of your bottom line I fully understand and sympathize with)." I agree. We have a flag for such a thing and set that flag when people ask us to. They ask us in a nice email exchange between human beings. We're very responsive to this since they are our paying customers. That's the big disconnect here: it's inconceivable to many people (including abusix, et. al) that healthy, straightforward interactions like this occur in 2022. In their mind there are nothing but robots and newsletter subscribers forever locked in an arms race. I'm sorry that is the case.
- areeh 5y agoYour earlier argument about unsubscribe being effectively an informal termination only works if you properly separate that side from all promotional/marketing/new features/etc material, otherwise it seems you are avoiding the main point and purpose of the unsubscribe button
- newaccount74 5y agoI strongly disagree. There is absolutely no need to put an unsubscribe link into a transactional email. All emails should of course contain enough information to make it clear who the message is from, why the message is being sent, and who it was sent to. But there is no point in adding unsubscribe links to messages and notifications that are essential to the service. I mean, what are you going to do if the user accidentally clicks "unsubscribe", and then a payment doesn't go through? Should you just cancel their account without informing them? That's absurd. I'd be really pissed if eg. my backups were deleted because I accidentally unsubscribed from emails from a cloud service provider.
- mgkimsal 5y ago> There is absolutely no need to put an unsubscribe link into a transactional email. Agreed. rsync alluded to it below as well. 'unsubscribe'... from what? If I just bought something from service ABC, and I get an email from ABC saying "you just bought foo from us"... what would an 'unsubscribe' even mean? "Do not ever email me about this purchase again?" "Do not ever email me about future purchases?"
- thesimon 5y ago> Do not ever email me about this purchase again Please send me the order, just don't send me the PDF invoice :)
- Silhouette 5y agoThose unsubscribe links should be there, for several reasons. In some jurisdictions there is information that businesses are legally required to provide to their customers in a permanent form and email is the conventional (and potentially the only) way of satisfying that requirement. IMHO, it is not helpful for anyone to have a system where recipients may not understand this and may treat that mail as spam, yet businesses are compelled to send it anyway.
- RunSet 5y agoI treat every unsubscribe link as though it read "click here to confirm your email address is live and being used by a human being so it will command a higher value when we resell it". If I don't like an email I never unsub. I add it to the spam filter.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cge 5y agoMail may also be simply going to the completely wrong address, for some reason, and there needs to be some way to ask that this be corrected without requiring credentials that the recipient might not have. If not an unsubscribe link, then at least a reply-to address that actually works, or some way to handle a mistake. I had one email address that for some reason often ended up being mistakenly used for other people, and ended up enormously frustrated by the usual combinations of no unsubscribe links, no-reply senders, and notes that any changes should be made by logging in. In the worst case, the US Department of Education, for several years, sent the address private personal and financial details about a complete stranger at a university with student loans. There was no way for me to unsubscribe, and no monitored address to reply to: in their view, they were important emails for the recipient, and they were, but I was not the intended recipient at all.