5 ms·
This isn't a solution and doesn't excuse Adobe's shitty behavior, but I use privacy.com which gives you single-purpose cards. That way, I can just pause the car
by stavros 5y ago
This isn't a solution and doesn't excuse Adobe's shitty behavior, but I use privacy.com which gives you single-purpose cards. That way, I can just pause the card and subsequent charges will fail. Then let them try to get their money.
Pull-based payments are such a bad idea, implemented even worse. Privacy.com at least gives you per-merchant controls and limits, even though this really should have been a Visa default.
- av8avenger 5y agoYou're right here, they won't be able to charge you automatically via the credit card, but you're still legally obligated to pay for the subscription since you have agreed to the terms of service during sign up. Depending on the action that they would take, you could easily end up paying a higher amount than the original subscription price if they put additional charges on you...
- torstenvl 5y ago> you're still legally obligated to pay for the subscription since you have agreed to the terms of service during sign up Except they didn't agree to them, because they didn't know about them, and they might not be legally obligated to pay, depending on the jurisdiction. It's pretty clear that there wasn't a "meeting of the minds" in most of these situations. I don't use Adobe but if I got bit by this I'd definitely take them to small claims.
- Jare 5y ago> because they didn't know about them I want to agree with this, but can't in strict terms. "Annual plan, paid monthly" item description next to the price is hard to defend as something unreadable. Maybe it's just me, but anytime I see "annual plan", I know I'm signing up for a year, and that commitment pretty much always comes with advantages (less total price) and disadvantages (cancellation fees) compared to shorter commitments. It's hard to deny the pileup of dark patterns in this and many other subscription services is disgusting and I wish the legal precedent was clear that customer clarity and control always trumps service clauses. Over a decade ago I established as a rule for myself that anything "free" that requires me to enter my credit card is in fact not free. Anytime I consider sidestepping the rule, I know I have to be REALLY sure and read everything. Yep, "limited trial with pre-accepted subscription but hey you can cancel anytime!" which is common in mobile, is always a no no from me.
- torstenvl 5y agoI think this is a question of fact, but isn't consistent with OP. Either Adobe tricked them and they genuinely didn't know and it's a dark pattern.... or it isn't a trick/dark pattern and they did know. But if the part of the agreement that talks about canceling is above the fold and the part that says there are liquidated damages of half the remaining annual payments is hidden behind invisible scroll bars, I know which way I would be likely to rule if I were the judge.
- TobTobXX 5y agoThe problem is only that they can throw lawyers at you. Normally a contract is invalid if one side can show to have been deceived.
- rdtwo 5y agoThey can sue joe fartnoggin all the want. I’m not sure they will get very far. Virtual cards only require a valid zip code nothing else has to match
- vel0city 5y agoHow were they deceived? The workflow clearly states "Annual plan, billed monthly." This wasn't something hidden from the user.
- empalms 5y agoTechnically but enforcement’s another matter. Many subscription services are just going to cancel your plan and paywall you
- prirun 5y agoCan they report you to a credit bureau and get your credit score lowered? I recently had my credit score lowered, I think because I canceled a Chase / Amazon credit card after only 1 month. Apparently that is a credit faux paus. No balance owed, but I did hit the measly $500 limit once - another thing bad for credit scores. When my car + homeowner insurance renewed, it had a special section about how Lexus Nexus had lowered my insurance score, which is partially based on my credit score. Cost me several hundred dollars extra in insurance premiums.
- borski 5y agoNo. The worst they can do is send you to collections, which they won’t do, or charge you for back charges if you sign up again. Canceling a credit card as you did may hurt your score though.
- judge2020 5y agoIn general, they can and do send this sort of stuff to collections since you did sign up for the terms and it's a non-trivial amount of money owed. Gyms do it for far less, so I don't see why Adobe wouldn't.
- lukevp 5y agoWe had Time Warner send us to collections which then reported my wife to the bureaus, alleging that we had never returned our cable modem (this was just for $60, and it was 5+ years ago!!). First of all, I’m incredibly sure that we did. We had fiber after that, what would I want with an old DOCSIS modem anyway? And second of all, they were unable to offer any proof that we had not returned it. The company that was collecting tried to strongarm us, but after a few documented phone calls, it all went away. But why are companies allowed to report a fraudulent payment to collections, when they have no proof (if they had some proof surely they wouldn’t have dropped it) and there is literally no follow-up or accountability required of them? I’m glad we have the financial literacy and confidence to tell them to stuff it, but how many people get scammed by stuff like this? We also spent a bunch of time on the phone with TWC directly, and they had no account in our name or any history of our account.
- erklik 5y ago> privacy.com Not for those of us who don't live in the US unfortunately.
- phphphphp 5y agoWhere are you located? Privacy.com were first to bring this feature to the mainstream as a product but it exists as an add-on in various places. For example, in the UK it’s offered by Monzo and offered by Revolut in the many countries they operate in. If you want to use virtual cards, it should be possible where you live.
- Nextgrid 5y agoWise (formerly Transferwise) also offers virtual debit cards. I don't think you can limit the amount or merchant, but it still works if all you need is to be able to cancel a card on-demand.
- Marsymars 5y agoWhile virtual cards are technically a thing in Canada (e.g. you get a virtual cards if you add a card to Apple Pay), I’m not aware of any services that let you generate more than one at a time in a useful way.
- achow 5y agoThis is why last year India's policy for auto debit rules for credit debit card makes very good sense. Under the new norms, banks will be required to inform customers in advance about recurring payment due and transaction would be carried following nod from the customer (will need additional factor authentication from 1 April). This rule is likely to impact your monthly subscription charges for different streaming platforms including Netflix, Amazon Prime, Disney+... https://www.livemint.com/industry/banking/debit-card-credit-card-auto-payment-rules-change-from-april-know-details-11617108811026.html https://www.livemint.com/industry/banking/debit-card-credit-...
- 41b696ef1113 5y agoLove that. I wonder how much money is flowing from consumers on forgotten subscriptions. My bank should have a separate highlighted section for any recurring charge.
- daniel-thompson 5y agoTheir "free" plan says you can > Create up to 12 cards per month Does that mean you can create 12 in January, 12 more in February, etc? Or is it capped at 12 total?
- stavros 5y agoAFAIK it's 12 every month (I have hundreds by now) but I've never reached the limit. They're vendor-locked so you need one per vendor.