8 ms·
Burgeoning bike cities emerge across America
- keeganjw 5y agoI will say, not all bike lanes are created equal. In the Netherlands, a lot of bike lanes are built as proper infrastructure. They're separated with a curb, nicely paved, free of debris, heck they often have their own traffic lights. In many US cities, they just slap some paint on the ground and call it good. Having ridden on both types, the Dutch style bike lane feels much safer.
- germinalphrase 5y agoThey objectively are safer.
- chapium 5y agoA bike lane in the doorzone encourages biking in the most dangerous region of the lane.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- consp 5y agoWith proper education and driver training you can pretty much limit that to a few scratch marks here and there. There are plenty of cycle-gutters painted on the road here in places where the preferred path for cyclists is not that path with parked cars next to them as you describe, yet accidents rarely happen and are almost never serious. Though they can be completely avoided with proper separation .
- chapium 5y ago> With proper education and driver training This will not happen in the US, and as a safety mechanism it ranks low on effectiveness.
- knolan 5y agoPaint is not infrastructure. I regularly cycle to work clocking up about 200km a week. Entitlement, aggression and abuse by motorists has a major impact on the numbers of people cycling. Segregated cycle routes are essential.
- dwater 5y agoI first became a US urban biker in 2003 before urban bike infrastructure really existed in the US, and I always felt and still feel safest riding on streets that have lots of traffic and no bike lane. Most US bike lanes are just paint between the parking spaces on the curb and the travel lanes. As such you can never predict if cars will enter the bike lane. I personally feel less safe in these unprotected bike lanes than I do riding in the normal travel lane because I find it less predictable. In the US if a car can physically get into a space, a driver will eventually go there.
- peatmoss 5y agoThis works for fit people with the wherewithal to approximate average speeds on the choked roadways. Bike lanes are towards the low end of what constitutes bicycle infrastructure, but they do give a great number of people the confidence to get out on their bikes. This is good for all cyclists, as all evidence points to “more bicycles; better average safety.” Look to parents with kids in tow as an indicator species for the health of a bicycling ecosystem. That said, I am personally wary of bike lanes for the reason I suspect you are: I’m constantly needing to be hyper vigilant about cars turning right across the bike lane. When I’m clipping along in traffic, I’ll move left in the lane at intersections to prevent this. Bike lanes can make this maneuver harder, especially if they have a painted buffer that is littered with tire-shredding debris. I suspect, but haven’t seen research, that the right hook scenario is lessened for slower moving bicycles (i.e. the kind that are perhaps more drawn to bike lanes). There is a longer span of time for an overtaking vehicle to observe a slower bicyclist in the bike lane, which I’d guess reduces the risk of the driver turning across. Add to that, a slower moving bicyclist isn’t going to run into the side panel of a car turning across the bike lane with as much force.
- ianai 5y ago
- walleeee 5y agoBike lanes in the US can be pretty haphazard, in many cases they're sprinkled discontinuously around the area like a tease it almost feels more dangerous to merge into and out of motor traffic at every other intersection
- jniedrauer 5y agoWorse still is having to merge in/out of traffic to avoid parked vehicles. In the state of Oregon, you are legally entitled to the same rights as any other vehicle on the road, but that also means you are legally obligated to move over when possible so faster vehicles can pass. In practice, this means swerving into the lane of car traffic to get around cars parked on the curb, and then moving back into the "bike lane", repeatedly. It's frightening, even if drivers here tend to be very considerate to pedestrians.
- loeg 5y agoThere is probably an exception for safety — you don’t have to merge into the rightmost lane if it is not safe. (You’re describing a scenario where it isn’t safe.) I know WA cycling law has such an exception, but I don’t know about OR specifically.
- monkeybutton 5y agoThe discontinuity is silliest part. What's the point of a bike lane that just... ends?
- ryukafalz 5y agoWorse still, the fact that few are using the bike lane to nowhere is used as a justification for not building any more of them and completing the network. It's just incredibly backwards.
- alamortsubite 5y agoThe Dutch-style infrastructure is safer. It's important to mention that earlier bike lanes in the Netherlands weren't initially implemented in their current form; they, too, started out as painted lanes. It's when the roads they were on required resurfacing that they were then properly separated from automotive lanes.
- forinti 5y agoAlthough it is a first step, most bike lanes in Brazil are put where they won't take space from cars and tend to be just some paint (not very good paint at that) on a few disconnected paths or in places of leisure because, you know, bikes aren't serious transportation.
- kqr 5y agoYeah, I'll take a proper (i.e. well-maintained surface, free of debris, etc.) separated bike road if there is one. If it's badly maintained, or just painted some part of the road that could be spared, I prefer riding in a proper "car" Lane.
- RivieraKid 5y agoFor me it's not about safety, but visual and noise pollution.
- kovek 5y agoI wish the ground on the bike lanes was a different color. Color is a nice cue that you’re entering the bike lane when walking
- agumonkey 5y agoSame in my area. Sometimes the lane is cut every 400m and changes sides. But even then, a bad bike lane is often safer than no marking at all, which signals car owns the road. Hoping to see more safe variants.
- andersco 5y agoThere is no mention of traditionally car-centric sprawling cities such as LA or Phoenix and their biking infrastructure or lack thereof. Anyone living in such a city seeing progress on biking infrastructure?
- grardb 5y agoI lived in LA from 2016 to 2021. There were improvements made, but as far as I could tell, most of it was in Downtown LA, which is already fairly walkable and the place with the most transit. Outside of Downtown, it's mostly a nightmare. Even within Downtown, I would say progress was fairly slow, but the changes were typically much more involved than simply painting the road. The biggest change was probably on Figueroa Street, though the infrastructure doesn't span much distance, as is the case with most of the improvements. If you're interested in keeping up with this kind of stuff, Streetsblog is a good resource: https://la.streetsblog.org/ https://la.streetsblog.org/
- javajosh 5y agoI grew up in LA and OC and the bike situation is very uneven. It is certainly wrong to say "its a nightmare outside of Downtown". There is substantial, protected bike infrastructure along all the major waterways. You can ride from downtown to Newport Beach without touching a street. Venice beach and in general the beach cities are quite bike friendly. The places that could use some bike TLC are places like Echo Park or Silverlake, where there's a lot of demand but no infra.
- Simon_O_Rourke 5y agoI lived in Venice Beach a few years ago and it definitely did start up open up and become more bike friendly. The rest of LA outside of downtown is a mix of non-existent to horrendous cycling infrastructure.
- hondo77 5y agoWell, there's no one L.A.. right? Until I had to move in 2019, I used to ride long commutes from the Valley and Santa Clarita to Pasadena, Burbank, and Westlake Village. I was able to ride very bike-friendly routes most of the way. Of course, riding longer distances is often easier to route than shorter distances so there you go. Didn't do much riding south of the 101 so I'm just a data point.
- 0des 5y agoMy city wants to support bikes but it is poorly executed. Ideally you have a street for cars and trucks, then outside the lanes you have parking for vehicles separating the traffic from the cyclists, and beyond that a sidewalk for pedestrians and wheelchairs. What we have is a shoulder that is now painted and has plastic guards that separate the cars from bikes. What that results in is you now have a painted bike path inaccessible to the street sweep that accumulates glass and debris and is very slick during rain which is often. There is no signage except for the main path either. Everything remains a grassroots effort with citizens making signage and apps for maps.
- kiliantics 5y agoIt's as if the designers just went with the very first idea they had, without any reflection on its pros and cons. How does this kind of thing happen? How did they not do even the smallest bit of research into all the possible options and successful examples that are out there? It's so frustrating how short-sighted and incompetent these efforts tend to be.
- alamortsubite 5y agoI share your frustration but it's unfair to look at it this way. If you attend some city planning meetings you'll see how entrenched and irrational the opposition is to any cycling infrastructure that could be perceived as affecting car traffic or parking. It's like pulling teeth, and I agree it's a tricky compromise, but we should consider any ground gained a success.
- larrymyers 5y agoI bike in Chicago year round, and have done so for the past decade. What Chicago has done well: * Curb and bollard protected bike lanes (Elston and Dearborn are examples) * Large areas painted green at the front of intersections, giving bikes a dedicated place to stop at the head of traffic. * Connecting trails and bike lanes to form a network of paths * Dedicated bike ways like the 606 and the Chicago river flyover * Adding more lane capacity on the Lake Shore Trail * The parks district does a great job keeping essential commuting routes on trails clear of snow and maintained * Continuing to invest in the rollout of Divvy and add more e-bikes to the fleet That being said, there are still too many sharrows and painted lanes with no buffer zone (getting doored sucks). There are still too many heavy commuting routes like Clark St where the bike lanes disappear in many sections (near the zoo is still awful). Bikes are still very much de-prioritized for cars, especially when there's construction. We've had significant snow the past few weeks and many bike lanes will just be wastelands of ice and slush until the weather gets warm enough for it to melt. But we have multiple cargo bike and e-bike dealers in the city, and the more families and non-competitive cyclists we get on the road the better things will get. It really helps normalize cycling as a form of essential transportation, instead of being viewed as recreation and sport.
- Wonnk13 5y agoOf course as soon as I move away they convert Milwaukee ave to a protected bike lane. I'm not crazy about the midwest overall, but I thought Chicago was one of (if not the most) bikeable city in the country. The combination of bike lanes, lakefront path, and grid layout make it very easy to get around on a bike. Damn now I miss that city :(
- throwaway894345 5y agoI don’t bike, but I’d love to see some enforcement for the ubers and delivery vehicles that block bike lanes (and alleys and so on). But it’s Chicago so I’m not holding my breath.
- alamortsubite 5y agoCreepy municipal surveillance cameras are everywhere in my city, ostensibly for our security. If they were used for the enforcement you describe, my opinion of them would change completely.
- Wonnk13 5y agoI'm considering moving back to Boston after a decade away. COL aside- I'm curious how much actual progress has been made with respect to proper bike infrastructure. Last time I lived there you were really risking your safety. The layout of the city just isn't conducive to cycling from what I remember.
- generalenvelope 5y agoCambridge has some really good bike infrastructure
- Texasian 5y agoI’ve moved here roughly when you moved away, it seems. For Boston proper, it seems like things are finally picking up again after kinda falling off a cliff during the Walsh years. Wu ran on a campaign that prioritized transit, biking etc so we’re seeing some big, quick projects implemented (the temp Mass Ave bridge bike lanes for one). Add that to the cycling ordinance in Cambridge and a cyclist mayor in Somerville and it feels like we have a chance for a comprehensive regional cycling network coming into reality.
- cbm-vic-20 5y agoThe footbridge between the Charles River Bikeway and the Longfellow Bridge has make it a lot easier to get between Boston and Cambridge/Somerville. https://goo.gl/maps/1hSgt2Q6PRSqbH6Q7 https://goo.gl/maps/1hSgt2Q6PRSqbH6Q7 https://goo.gl/maps/AjdNAhQAjXeDcuTj8 https://goo.gl/maps/AjdNAhQAjXeDcuTj8
- kibwen 5y agoI am immensely impressed at the degree to which Boston and Cambridge have improved their bicycling infrastructure in only the past few years. It's not Dutch-level, but relative to the US it's a dream. Get on street view and check out the new bike lane around the Common, which when paired with the footbridge over Storrow and the car-free Washington Street means you can get from the Charles River Path nearly all the way to Haymarket without sharing a lane with cars: https://maps.app.goo.gl/LXHJaEcaqnWbzt9E9 https://maps.app.goo.gl/LXHJaEcaqnWbzt9E9 Or see the lovely separated lanes running past BU: https://maps.app.goo.gl/B6n5JyKd783wZjSv9 https://maps.app.goo.gl/B6n5JyKd783wZjSv9 Or the new Harvard Square intersection: https://maps.app.goo.gl/CPxaadsJnqfskyNs7 https://maps.app.goo.gl/CPxaadsJnqfskyNs7
- kibwen 5y agoI spent my childhood and young adulthood living in rural/suburban zones in Appalachia where cars were a requirement for living. No car means no groceries, no socialization, and not even any recreation, because even to safely walk or bike I had to drive somewhere to do it. I actually find driving to be somewhat fun and meditative, but I hate being forced to drive. I want to walk to places, and I want to bike to places. I sold my car and moved to a bike-friendly city, and I'm determined to never again live anywhere that requires me to own a car to survive. Of course, rents are higher here--I pay $910 a month--but given that the average TCO of a car in the US is $950 a month, I'm actually saving money by living somewhere that I can get away with not owning a car (to be fair I should try to estimate the TCO of my bike, which might generously be $200 per year). I'm thrilled that my city keeps investing in more and more bike infrastructure, and it makes me proud to live here. I'm not even opposed to the possibility of owning a car again someday, but now I have a choice rather than an obligation.
- throwaway894345 5y ago> but given that the average TCO of a car in the US is $950 a month FWIW, the average TCO of a car reflects what the average person can afford, not the minimum. I’m also pretty skeptical of that figure because my brand new Tesla payment + insurance + electricity costs about that much. So (1) I don’t think the average car is as expensive as a brand new Tesla and (2) even for my Tesla, the monthly TCO will be far, far lower because the payments for the car would need to be amortized over its lifetime. I’m sure you’re probably saving money by cycling, but I don’t think it’s anywhere near $950/month unless I’m mathing wrong. Note also that rideshare, car rental, delivery services, etc also cut into your savings. Further, if the car is shared between several people (e.g., a family) switching to cycling + supplementary services might not make sense.
- acdha 5y ago> So (1) I don’t think the average car is as expensive as a brand new Tesla and (2) even for my Tesla, the monthly TCO will be far, far lower because the payments for the car would need to be amortized over its lifetime. These are somewhat contradictory: someone spending less upfront on an internal combustion engine will be paying considerably more for maintenance and fuel. It's also a bit of a challenge to talk about this since it's a distribution — the _average_ new car bought in the United States was $47,000 which is more than the Tesla Model 3's base price of $40k: https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a38748092/new-car-average-sale-prices-47100/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a38748092/new-car-average-... The other big thing to remember is that taxes, insurance, parking, and tolls add up quickly. If you bought a Model 3 at $40k you're probably not getting the cheapest tier of insurance. Now, if we look at used cars it's cheaper but that's still $28k and since a used car is going to need more maintenance you're definitely looking at a substantial amount of money: https://www.kbb.com/car-news/average-used-car-price-now-over-28000/ https://www.kbb.com/car-news/average-used-car-price-now-over... In all cases, a lot of this is going to come down to where you live. In a city or area with high car theft rates, insurance is going to be steep even if you're a low-mileage driver and the cost of parking can easily hundreds of dollars a month. If you live and work in less dense suburb or rural area, you probably don't have to worry about paying much for parking but you're also almost certainly racking up the mileage.
- alamortsubite 5y agoAs an intermediate step toward real biking infrastructure, one thing I'd love to see in addition to painted lanes is some sort of tactile affordance to remind drivers they've left their lane and are now driving in a space reserved for bicycles. Cat's eyes or the like would do the trick.
- subpixel 5y agoWhat is very prevalent in America and I believe less so in more bike-friendly countries is that places are designed to keep others out. This has longstanding racial undertones (google why bridges are too low for buses to pass under in Queen, NY) but the same desire to keep the 'other' out has a grounding in class as well. Where I live, you can't visit unless you have a car _and_ a place to park it, so visitor traffic is minimized, by circumstance that has become design.
- acdha 5y agoThere was an almost comedic example of that around here a couple of years back: people were publicly claiming that expanding a bike path to their suburb would cause increased crime, by which they meant the possibility of black people riding the trail out from Baltimore. Meanwhile, the actual robbers drive because you can't fit enough on a bike to be worth the risk but oddly there's no call to stop building roads.
- maxerickson 5y agoIsn't a lot of property crime targeting cash, drugs, jewelry and small electronics at this point? And then things like bikes and cars. Like looking around my house, there's not much other stuff that you could fence for $1,000 laying around. Which is not to say I think that the concern there was valid.
- acdha 5y agoTrue (although electronics are getting harder as manufacturers increasingly use cloud services which can brick a stolen device) but I think the bigger point is just that most crime happens relatively locally — nobody bikes 20 miles to steal an XBox. I think you’re right that the value density is going down, too - nobody is breaking in to steal CDs and DVDs any more.
- gkop 5y agoThis exception having generated significant interest on HN, proves the rule, so to speak: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29037860 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29037860
- fassssst 5y agoI love ebiking around Seattle, we’ve determined it’s faster than our car for 2 mile trips too. Also feels like cheating because you can always park right outside wherever you’re going. The “utility” ebike with cargo basket was the game changer since we can now do all our grocery and errand runs comfortably by bike.
- dylan604 5y agoI've found the same for my city, except the parking. There's only one shopping strip I goto that has grocery, pet supplies, hardware, etc that has a proper bike rack. Everywhere else, it's a game of finding something suitable to lock by bike against. Other than that, I love using my ebike over a car
- alamortsubite 5y agoA friendly-worded email to the owners of the businesses you frequent might be worth the effort. :)
- twomoonsbysurf 5y ago
- tehchromic 5y agoEven in Davis CA which prides itself on being a primier bike friendy city and most people have bikes, it's similar to what I'm reading in the comments: bike lanes are painted in and irregular. Bikers second class citizens. Every few years a biker gets killed by an automobile. That says there are beautiful greenbelts which can get you around the outskirts of the city with no cars in sight.
- CalRobert 5y agoA very important topic, but this article is almost nothing! Regardless, this is hugely important. My wife and I have two little kids (under 5) and we really, really want them to be independent young people when they're a little older. I want them to be able to hop on their bikes and ride to the shop, school, the train/metro/bus, etc. and most of all, I want them to survive. Drivers are the leading cause of dead kids, and deaths among vulnerable road users (pedestrians, cyclists, etc.) have risen dramatically in the US in the last couple years. There are approximately 0 places in the US meeting this bar. https://culdesac.com/ https://culdesac.com/ near Phoenix is interesting but 1) very small and 2) in Phoenix, which will struggle with summer survivability by the time my kids are middle ages. American Fietser - https://twitter.com/AmericanFietser https://twitter.com/AmericanFietser - has been beating the drum for Carmel, Indiana, which apparently has made great strides in their downtown - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94-kxjgOtdU&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94-kxjgOtdU&feature=youtu.be I grew up in suburban Sacramento and it was basically a prison. I _did_ ride my bike when I was 14 and older, dozens of miles in some cases, but in retrospect it's shocking I lived. I was nearly killed in multiple instances. I chatted briefly with Jason Slaughter of NotJustBikes fame (maybe the best urbanist channel on youtube) and he was very reassuring about moving to Amsterdam with kids older than my own. I just got naturalised as an EU citizen and Utrecht in particular is on the short list. But I hope US cities can improve.
- Pacers31Colts18 5y agoCarmel is nice, but man, they have some of the worst drivers ever.
- CalRobert 5y agoA great argument for separated infra :-)
- addy13 5y agoAs someone that moved to Utrecht five years ago (and also from California)....you could not have picked a better place. Infrastructure is amazing and quality of life is superb. Of course not everything is perfect and cost of living has sky rocketed but I assume you work in tech and everything will be fine. There's quite a lot of high quality cities but Utrecht is really nice (although the Netherlands is a bit boring but that's subjective of course).
- anoplus 5y agoTaking cars out of some urban areas is such an upgrade. Once in a while I revisit a street in a city I didn't visit for long, where the road has been appropriated for pedestrians and sitting area. Just like that, the street transforms – from a passage through which to go – to become the go-to attraction.
- alamortsubite 5y agoWhen I tell people in my city they could instantly double their property values by greatly restricting car traffic and parking on their street, they look at me like I'm crazy.
- christophilus 5y agoMy little town did this, and it’s wonderful. Downtown is now constantly packed with people. All I can say is, I hope this is the beginning of a long term turn towards human-scale cities in the US.
- durovo 5y agoMy knowledge about biking infrastructure is lacking but doesn't it make sense to allow/promote biking on the sidewalks as a start? Once biking gains more acceptance, allocating more budget for proper biking lanes would become much easier.
- rossdavidh 5y agoIn, for example, Austin (my home), most sidewalks allow biking. There's a city code that lists which sidewalks are NOT allowed for biking, and it mostly amounts to "any sidewalk that people actually use for walking" (which is a small minority). I think one issue is that motorists notice bikes on the road or bike lane more than they notice bikes on sidewalks, hence more likely to hit them when turning. But I agree it's a way to bootstrap up.
- alamortsubite 5y agoUnfortunately, no. Sidewalks are for pedestrians. Mixing in bikes makes them unsafe for foot traffic. It's also dangerous for a cyclist to ride across an intersection in a crosswalk because drivers turning through it may not be able to see them before they're able to stop. Furthermore, sidewalks are irregular and not conducive to biking.
- analog31 5y agoI get around a lot by bike. Riding bikes on sidewalks is dangerous. You're not visible to cars when you're crossing driveways or going through intersections. Likewise, mixing with pedestrians is pretty unpleasant for everybody. You won't make a lot of friends that way. Sidewalks are safe when you're moving at the speed of walking. When I'm on a sidewalk with my bike and there are pedestrians around, I hop off and walk. My city has some master plan for bike infra, but really it's a matter of waiting until a road or intersection has to be rebuilt (frequently due to hard winters) and thinking about bike traffic at that point. There's also a network of sleepy neighborhood streets that are used by cyclists including myself.
- acdha 5y agoThis is allowed in many areas but it's a bad compromise: in much of the country, there aren't many sidewalks and they're not safe — e.g. you'll have a sidewalk in front of a strip mall but then it just ends on a busy road, driveways are often blocked by cars and are high risk zones with people flooring it as they leave or pulling in without slowing down much, there are random barriers and obstacles between properties, it's not cleared of trash effectively, etc. — and they're often _much_ longer trips. The last time I went to PyCon I was disappointed to see that the path from my hotel to the conference was like 0.7 miles in car and almost 2 on foot because there was a gnarly freeway bridge which forced pedestrians to walk around some unsafe roads. Maintenance is also a big problem: a sidewalk which is cracked or full of snow / puddles is unpleasant even if it's relatively safe to ride through. One indicator you can use are the number of people riding motorized wheelchairs on the road shoulders — we generally have decent sidewalks here in DC but a lot of the neighboring suburbs added bike lanes during the pandemic and every time that happens you'll notice a ton of people using wheelchairs and strollers there because it's so much better than bumping around over broken concrete and dealing with random poles in the middle of the sidewalk. The single most important thing which needs to happen is thinking about connectivity: what a lot of places do is make a couple of bike lanes which don't connect places people live/work/shop and then say nobody's using them without recognizing that the miles of unsafe streets on either end are probably the explanation.
- dayjah 5y agoAnecdotally, as an Austin, TX, resident and cyclist — this city is so far away from adequate cycling infrastructure that it’s inclusion in this piece taints the rest of it for me. Clearly this piece is light on meaningful details. One example is how the increase includes areas that are completely unsafe to ride — for example adding lanes that are essentially storm drain run offs which are generally unfinished - so you have to bike in the road. Our local news has a great example of a lane with an electricity pole right in the middle of it… :facepalm: https://www.kxan.com/news/local/austin/austin-cyclists-flag-mobility-safety-concerns-in-newly-installed-bike-lanes/ https://www.kxan.com/news/local/austin/austin-cyclists-flag-...
- mplanchard 5y agoI live in Austin and largely stopped cycling after a motorist tried to run me off the road on trinity south of MLK. I was going straight and had taken the lane a little early to pass a bus that was stopped in the bike lane and to avoid that dangerous spot closer to the intersection where the bike lane crosses _through_ the right turn lane, with plenty of room behind me and open lanes to the left. This guy was not having it. Got maybe 2 inches from my rear wheel, then jerked around to the left, sped up, and then swerved right into my lane when he was even with me. This is all maybe 100 ft from the intersection, where there was a red light. I passed him less than ten seconds after all this, since he was sitting in the more congested right turn lane and I was going straight.
- billsmithaustin 5y agoI live in Austin. The bike infrastructure varies a lot depending on what part of town you’re in. No doubt that’s true for most places — including around the University of Texas. I’ve ridden many trips up and down Dean Keeton Street without any trouble from motorists. The electrical pole story is ridiculous — someone didn’t know what they were doing. But readers should not assume the entirety of Austin’s bike lanes are like that.
- dayjah 5y agoThat’s fair feedback! I found my OP started to meander with my calling out the bits of Austin that aren’t bad; but clearly in culling those my piece made it sound like a terrible-to-cycle-in-city. It’s not… Except in the summer obvi, when anything outside sucks ^_^ I guess my main schtick with the Axios piece is that it lacks any form of nuance; starting percentage increases as uniformly good.
- rossdavidh 5y ago" Compare that with the Netherlands, where 27% of the country commutes by bike. The difference is infrastructure." Well, infrastructure is certainly one big difference, but it's not _the_ difference. The Netherlands is quite flat. Some parts of the US (for example Austin, Texas where I live) is rather hilly in spots. Biking is getting more widely used anyway, but it's not irrelevant that it is much easier to bike on flat terrain. I'm also surprised to see absolutely no mention of electric scooters (Bird, Lime, etc.). Those unwilling to bike could still add to the critical mass needed for support of infrastructure, if bikes and scooters share that infrastructure. If they're arguing that the other should not be allowed in their lanes, however, I think neither is numerous enough to get support.
- Muromec 5y ago>Well, infrastructure is certainly one big difference, but it's not _the_ difference. The Netherlands is quite flat Ground in the Netherlands is flat, but bike paths also go over bridges. And what the Netherlands also has is the North Sea, with its winds, which turn cycling on nicely-paved flat terrain into rather serious physical exercise. Sometimes I wish I wasn't that cheap and got pedal-assist as an option.
- alamortsubite 5y agoPeople who argue against bike infrastructure in the U.S. are always quick to bring up the lack of hills in the Netherlands, but they never make the connection with the strong winds there (doubly ironic, given the romantic affinity we all have for Dutch windmills). It's frustrating, but I think e-bikes will finally be the death knell for this meme. (I've also heard that some infrastructure in NL actually takes wind into account by providing windbreaks for cyclists.)
- consp 5y agoThe Dutch Headwind Cycling Championship is tomorrow for example (expected 7 to 8bft so it will be tough). There is a good cycle path where they will hold it and people regularly cycle there, it's almost never below 4bft there. Also there are plenty of hilly parts of the Netherlands which have the same cycle infrastructure and usage. The fairy tale of "but it's flat" has been around for a while and used plenty of times by opponents without actually looking into it.
- Hbruz0 5y ago> The difference is infrastructure Ah yes, the USA has the same density of population than the Netherlands
- alamortsubite 5y agoThe article discusses bike infrastructure in the context of cities. Population density of U.S. cities is comparable to those in the Netherlands. Some are much more dense, some are less. I'm unsure what point you're trying to make.
- ryukafalz 5y agoParts of it do, and they don't see nearly the cycling mode-share as places in the Netherlands with equivalent density. The difference is infrastructure.
- beardicus 5y agoi guess you're trying to be snarky here, but, the density of the US as a whole has nothing to do with supporting urban cycling infrastructure. nobody here is talking about facilitating long-haul inter-urban bike routes.
- _8j50 5y agoI vaguely remember learning to bike when I was 8, what they say is true! I bought a bike a few weeks ago and decades later I could still ride. But a few obstacles I had: - At least right now, I can bike at best 2 miles round trip without getting too tired. That's not far enough in most US cities, can't even bike to the nearest walmart/target/whole foods just to a convenience store. - even with bike lanes, cars are scary, especially when the bike lane runs into puddles of uknown depths and isn't flat/stable. - Is it allowed to bike on roads without a bike lane? If so, that's even more dangerous. I think converting sidewalks into wider bike trails would please everyone. Pedestrians (rare) can walk on right side and less risk of some inattentive driver steering just over the lane killing you. Westcoast bike friendly city sounds like dream
- geraldwhen 5y agoBoulder, CO has a setup like this. There’s even markers on the ground for pedestrians to keep right
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>At least right now, I can bike at best 2 miles round trip without getting too tired. If you do it regularly then that will soon become very easy. >Is it allowed to bike on roads without a bike lane? If so, that's even more dangerous. I do it in the UK and it's mostly OK although I did have a very close pass at speed last week. It was clearly malicious as the driver was gesticulating out of his window. That's the first time I've had something quite so egregious in the last five years of e-biking.
- vanilla_nut 5y ago> Is it allowed to bike on roads without a bike lane? Yes! You should probably educate yourself a bit about biking laws in your area if you don't know this. In the vast majority of the US, you have as much right to the road as any other vehicle -- though of course some car drivers don't respect that right. I regularly bike 40 miles or more for day trips around my area to go to breweries, coffee shops, and parks. I also enjoy exploring new towns and cities by bike -- I've done 100 miles in a day before, just exploring a few towns with great bike infrastructure. Keep biking and that will become easy for you too!
- leishman 5y agoThey should focus on making cities more walkable, and less on making them bikeable.
- alamortsubite 5y agoThat's an odd take considering bicycles are among the most efficient machines ever invented, quiet, environmentally-friendly, a great excuse to exercise, capable of carrying cargo, and allow people to easily cover ground too far to travel on foot. Why can't we have both?
- kiliantics 5y agoIt's basically the same thing, and the only way is to dramatically reduce the space given to cars.
- RivieraKid 5y agoI find the increase in popularity of the pro-pedestrian / pro-bike / anti-car sentiment interesting. It seems like it increased 10x in the last few years.
- newsbinator 5y agoI suspect it's no coincidence this shifted when so many more people stopped driving to and from work everyday.
- alamortsubite 5y agoIt's a huge win everywhere it catches on. Let's hope it's a generational thing and it accelerates.
- ryukafalz 5y agoI think it is, at least to some extent. The younger you are, the more likely you'll be the ones dealing with the effects of climate change, and car-dominance is a big part of that. It's pretty top-of-mind for a lot of us.
- zozbot234 5y agoThe sentiment is mostly popular in dense city centers where it does make a lot of sense. Manhattan NYC has always been "anti-car", as has London UK. The car will still be king in less dense areas.
- letouj 5y agoThere are plenty of small-to-medium-sized cities (25K–250K) with sufficiently intact city cores and higher-density corridors where it's still very reasonable to imagine increased cycling uptake if the infrastructure were just put in place. It's not about making every person ride a bike on every trip, it's about making more bike trips possible for more people. Obviously someone who lives in Montana five miles from the nearest stoplight isn't going to be using a bike for their primary transportation, but there's a big spectrum in between that and midtown Manhattan.
- shagmin 5y agoThis article resonates with me. The city where I work built a road that makes my commute 20% shorter, and they made this road very bike-able. As soon as I could I rode my bike to work, then covid came shortly after and I started working from home. But I've tried to maintain the habit of walking to the grocery store and things like that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- animal_spirits 5y agoAre there any bike organizations in the USA that lobby to improve bicycle infrastructure?
- 4887d30omd8 5y agoThere are many such organizations that are active at a city or county level (eg https://sfbike.org/ https://sfbike.org/) and there are others at state level and even one or two at national level (https://www.bikeleague.org/ https://www.bikeleague.org/). In my experience the most resources and most effective advocacy happen on the local level. I’d love to see national or state level organizations get more resources though.
- Tade0 5y ago> Compare that with the Netherlands, where 27% of the country commutes by bike. I hate this statistic, because while it's true, it doesn't tell the whole story. There's an interesting (and recent) study which presents transport modalities in various European cities: https://www2.deloitte.com/xe/en/insights/focus/future-of-mobility/deloitte-urban-mobility-index-for-cities.html https://www2.deloitte.com/xe/en/insights/focus/future-of-mob... If you look at the two Dutch cities there, you'll see that 40%+ people still drive! That's low by American standards, but more than e.g. in London or Paris. On the other hand public transport is less utilized and walking is unpopular. Now if you look at e.g. Zürich, few people cycle there - they mostly walk: https://www.eltis.org/discover/news/zurich-plans-make-walking-primary-mobility-mode-switzerland-0 https://www.eltis.org/discover/news/zurich-plans-make-walkin... Turns out that cycling just replaces walking and public transport.
- cudgy 5y agoWhat burgeoning bike cities? The sparse article only mentions cities that were already favorable toward bicycles with the possible exception of Austin.
- exabrial 5y agoAs an avid cyclist in multiple biking disciplines: MTB XC, Road, Gravel, and Enduro, I hate bike lanes. By far, they are the most lethal place to ride a bike. Being 3ft from 45mph traffic with no protective barrier is not safe by any stretch of the imagination. All it takes is one drunk or high driver or someone posting selfies on instagram to kill me. You are safer careening down a mountainside over rocks and roots than you are in a bike lane. What is much safer for cyclists are dedicated bike paths [like streamway buffer paths], bike lanes separated by barriers, and Bentonville, Arkansas is the pioneer in Mountain Bike trails as local transportation. Unprotected bike lanes are stupid idea postured by the media with 0 scientific thought into their safety.