4 ms·
Ask HN: Free-to-Premium business models. Any working examples?
Just like 'ad supported,' I get the feeling that a 'premium accounts supporting free accounts' model is thrown around too freely. Something that can be thrown in later in the game, after you're popular, to generate revenue. How many examples do we have of this model working out? I'm not really referring to the high price-per-unit premium services (customised/B2B), I think they're an independent category. I am also not referring to services where the 'free' version is essentially a sample. I think the free version would need to be useful in itself to qualify for this category. So I'd naturally expect the majority of users to be using the free version.
I think this is an natural in context example:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=302142
My immediate thought is that unless the service is immune to competition, a service with virtually 0 marginal cost per customer, is a bad fit. From that I'd further speculate that using premium-only features & ad removal to differentiate free from basic is not the best route to take. A premium service that costs the service provider something (eg storage) is probably preferable.
One to watch is naturally Google Apps Premium Edition. Interestingly Google Apps uses all three selling points - more storage, ad removal & additional features to upsell. Considering the resources that have gone into these apps over the years & their level of success in the free end of the market, it's a high bar before you could plausibly take this as a case study in the success of this particular business model. Maybe 1/2 - 1 million paid accounts ($25m - $50m per year) could be called a borderline case.
http://www.google.com/a/help/intl/en/admins/editions.html
So. If anyone has interesting examples please share. Info on how they're doing, as well as stuff like what the free/premium ratio is like would go down well.
- jacobscott 18y agoChris Anderson's article on Free in Wired is six months old but probably a good reference if you haven't seen it: http://www.wired.com/techbiz/it/magazine/16-03/ff_free?currentPage=all http://www.wired.com/techbiz/it/magazine/16-03/ff_free?curre... I guess his book isn't out yet but it looks like he's blogging about free @ the long tail: http://www.longtail.com/the_long_tail/ http://www.longtail.com/the_long_tail/
- netcan 18y agoActually, I had read that article but forgot about it. It's probably where I got my description of the model. It's a good article. Gives you a feel for the context of all this. I totally agree that free services have gotten a major upgrade as part of the economy & that it makes sense. But on the incentives to service providers, they just list a few: advertising, cross subsidy & freemium. Advertising is an old one. We know that one from the TV/Radio/Magazine world. We also know it's not capable of funding every type of popular free web thing. (Great on Search, less great on Facebook). Cross subsidies - Also pretty straightforward. Real estate site provides tools, Google gets people to like them etc. etc. Freemium, on the other is not as well trodden. Especially if your strict about excluding free samples from the category.
- webwright 18y ago37Signals stuff, Wufoo, BlinkSale, Flickr, Freshbooks, RescueTime, Harvest, etc. If you want some good data, you'll really want to read this: http://particletree.com/features/web-app-autopsy/ http://particletree.com/features/web-app-autopsy/
- netcan 18y agoThanks for the link. Wufoo & BlinkSale are interesting cases. I was surprised to see their conversion rates so transparently out there. But services like Freshbooks, RegOnline, RescueTime & 37 signals stuff are not really what I'd call part of the 'Freemium' business model. The free version is either limited in time or functionality to the point where you can't be a 'real' user (like you can with Gmail or Dropbox) without being a paid user. Even BlinkSale is kind of borderline case. Serious users would 90% of the time need a paid account. Wufoo is also near the 'sample' end of the spectrum though it looks highly usable with a free account. Nothing wrong with that of course, non one says you can't sell services. Also they're all in the business tools arena. That's definitely an area where paid tools are likely to succeed. But it's an area that (as you can see from those examples) it's pretty straightforward to sell software subscriptions. But they really don't get us anywhere near a facebook premium. Flickr is potentially a good example. It's consumer oriented & I'd guess the great majority of users are always going to be free users. But is it earning it's salt this way yet? Or is it still in the wait & see category with Google Apps Premium? BTW I downloaded dropbox today & I can see myself paying for the service, but also see myself using the free version.
- webwright 18y agoWhere you put the "pay wall" is a big decision. I think a lot of companies have learned that if you offer a largely functional product, people don't jump the penny gap ( http://redeye.firstround.com/2007/03/the_first_penny.html http://redeye.firstround.com/2007/03/the_first_penny.html ) for a few slick premium touches. FWIW, we have tens of thousands of free users at RescueTime who seem pretty enthusiastic. We've got a mess of paying customers, too-- but I've often pondered the idea of crippling the free version a bit more. If you're looking at selling stuff to consumers, rather than businesses... I think you're in a scary world (unless you're an iphone app and you can offer the 1 click buy). No matter what you sell, there are always a dozen idiots who will give it away and throw adsense on there-- and consumers are well-trained at this point to find the free alternative.
- rantfoil 18y agoSmugmug is a pioneer in this.
- tstegart 18y agoIsn't Flickr the perfect example? I know a lot of people that pay for it, and a lot of people that don't. Some blogging platforms also use the model successfully.