4 ms·
Plan 28: Babbage's Analytical Engine project gets underway
- ericHosick 15y agoKinda Relevant: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Difference_Engine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Difference_Engine And a great book. Gibson rocks.
- rmc 15y agoThe Science Museum doesn't have the resources to immediately make them available to the general public I always wonder when I hear that. Why not just upload a torrent to The Pirate Bay (or use amazon s3 & torrents). The geeks will make it available to the general public.
- jgrahamc 15y agoBecause what The Science Museum wants to do is interpret them rather than simply dumping them out there. There are thousands of pages of documents which the Science Museum has already catalogued. What they are going to do (if I understand correctly) is build a web site so that people can access and search them in an intelligent and useful manner. This is not about bandwidth.
- Jun8 15y agoThanks for spearheading this effort, it would be great if the Engine could be built. As for the documents, your post gives the impression that it was mostly about bandwidth, i.e. "but the museum needs just a little more time before they can cope with a flood of inquiries". While I fully agree that the best way to put it out is a nicely designed web page giving all the historical context and interpretations, well, "better is the enemy of good", these things are always low on the priority list for cash-strapped organizations. If they can't create such a site then nobody will have access to them. I don't quite like this all or nothing approach of such institutions.
- jgrahamc 15y agoDon't read into this an 'all or nothing' approach from the museum.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoThis is sort of like asking why we need to bother to produce a careful English translation of the works of Stanislaw Lem. Why not just paste the Polish editions of all of his works into a big spreadsheet, one word per row, then sort it alphabetically by word, feed it through Google's translation bot, and upload the long list of words to Bittorrent? Then the world can have all the words Lem ever wrote! All we'll be missing is their order. What's wrong with this project? Everything. It's not going to serve anyone (except, perhaps, a very tiny number of Polish linguists), it's a terrible insult to Lem, it's a terrible insult to Lem's audience, and it reflects very badly on the intelligence or taste of the person who carried out the plan (i.e., me). My understanding is that the plans for the Analytical Engine resemble any other set of unrealized preliminary plans: They're incomplete, they're out of order, they don't make great internal sense on the surface (because Babbage and his collaborators didn't bother to rewrite all the old notes every time they had a new idea), they use archaic terms and convoluted expressions for concepts that are now simple (they weren't simple concepts when they were first being conceived, a century before they were realized in practice), and therefore they aren't as impressive as they could be if, say, a bright and motivated historian spent some time piecing them together first. But, of course, I'm no expert on the Analytical Engine; I'm just guessing based on a few rumors I've overheard. If only I could pull an actual expert out from behind this nearby curtain! [cue] [god I love the internet]
- jgrahamc 15y agoAlso, Babbage invented his own notation for describing the movement and interaction of cogs, levers etc. inside the machine. He used this notation to augment the static plans to describe the motion. He also constantly refined the notation. What he left behind were hundreds of nice plans of the Analytical Engine all of which are incomplete. Plus he left his notebooks. Thousands and thousands of pages of jottings, sketches, and thoughts. Interpreting all that is going to be a lot of work.
- 0x12 15y agoThey claim they don't have the resources to make them available to the public. You are answering a completely different question. They seem to be saying they don't have the funds and/or infrastructure, not that they don't want to make them available. (unless the parent post has been edited)
- michael_dorfman 15y agoWonderful work, jgc. I remain, as always, impressed by your efforts to bring proper attention and respect to our intellectual forefathers. A tip of the hat to you, sir.
- jgrahamc 15y agoVery kind of you. Here's the BBC's version: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-15001514 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-15001514
- arethuza 15y agoSo how are you going to power this thing once it is built? Wind, water or steam? :-) Edit: I do hope it will be steam powered! (At least once - just so someone can record what it would sound like).
- jgrahamc 15y agoSteam. The goal of the project is to be historically accurate and it appears that Babbage himself felt that steam would be necessary (unlike the hand-cranked Difference Engine No. 2). Only a small steam engine is likely to be needed and I have had offers from various people of expertise.
- 0x12 15y agoDo you need a license to operate a steam engine in the UK?
- Tinned_Tuna 15y agoDoes anyone think that these plans in conjunction with 3D printers would result in a lot of fun?
- jgrahamc 15y agoIt's not outside the realm of possibility that by the time we have done the study of the plans followed by a computer simulation that the construction of the machine may be simply File -> Print... On the other hand, we probably want to hand build it for historical reasons.
- stan_rogers 15y agoIt would seem to me that building the Analytical Engine without following the same sort of material and construction constraints that the Difference Engine #2 project followed would be, in a sense, invalid. The theoretical validity of the means of computation, the "instruction set" and so on could be proven by a "perfect materials" simulation of the machine alone, but things like "signal propagation" (or, rather, the mechanical equivalent thereof) are part and parcel of the physical construction of the machine. There has to be at least some degree of vindicating Babbage involved in a project of this sort. If it turns out that personality conflicts and a certain shortsightedness on the par of the BA were all that stood between the machine as dream and a major change in the course of history (as some people believe), that makes a very different story than the one that posits that the machine could not have been constructed as imagined; that the partial mill's errors were at least partly due to the fundamental limitations of the materials and processes available for construction at the time. Yes, it would be nice to know whether the machine could have worked in theory, but it's a much more interesting question to consider what difference the machine might have made if it could have worked in practice.
- jgrahamc 15y agoI am with you 100% on this. That's why I got Doron Swade involved. It is absolutely vital that this be done in a manner that means we can know whether Babbage would have been able to construct a computer if other obstacles were removed (such as money and his personality).