3 ms·
Your examples (emacs and ed) are intentionally silly, but as I recall the actual targets of those extensions were significantly less lighthearted: many were exp
by woodruffw 5y ago
Your examples (emacs and ed) are intentionally silly, but as I recall the actual targets of those extensions were significantly less lighthearted: many were explicitly racist or reactionary communities with histories of brigading/raiding other subreddits.
Put another way: we shouldn't confuse a civics problem with a platform problem. These extensions (again, as I remember them), were primarily created to eliminate a platform problem that Reddit themselves refused to address.
Edit: my personal anecdote with this is NYC's subreddit: accounts with histories that indicate no connection to NYC love to comment on every crime-blotter article with the same tired comments about the city. It's incredibly convenient and improves the quality of the discussion to be able to filter them.
- easton 5y agoYes, you're correct, they were mostly racist or far-right subreddits. But that didn't ever make much sense to me, because even if the person was evil elsewhere, a comment that didn't have that sort of content shouldn't be moderated IMO. Brigading should be detectable regardless of what subreddits a user is a part of, given it usually coincides with bizarre usage patterns (downvoting everything in new as soon as it appears or something). I get moderation is hard, but this makes it too easy. What if someone was evil but then saw the error of their ways? Should they be forced to make a new account? Or what if they were trying to start debates (as unlikely as that is) in said evil subreddit?
- woodruffw 5y ago> I get moderation is hard, but this makes it too easy. What if someone was evil but then saw the error of their ways? Should they be forced to make a new account? Or what if they were trying to start debates (as unlikely as that is) in said evil subreddit? This is a great point, and it's a problem that's created by these extensions. I'd argue that it's a lesser problem than the original one, and so it's a pill I'm willing to swallow (and subsequently tackle). In general, I think that anonymized reputation and vouching systems are the way forwards for online communities. Vouching solves the "blacklisting" problem: if we incentivize high-reputation people to vouch for good-faith accounts, then people who fall into the categories you've mentioned can be correctly exempted from the filter. But that's awfully hard to do.