4 ms·
> Without external restraints, any sufficiently large company will focus on eliminating competition either through pricing them out of the market or just outrig
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Without external restraints, any sufficiently large company will focus on eliminating competition either through pricing them out of the market or just outright buying them.
The counterargument is that this only happens in markets with high barriers to entry, which in turn are mostly caused by regulatory barriers.
For example, the government makes permanent spectrum auctions, so if all the holders of spectrum merge together, no new competitors can enter. Suppose instead they held a new auction every year or every month for use of the spectrum in a given region until the next auction. Then mergers wouldn't prevent competitors from entering; a new competitor goes to the next auction, places a bid and can get spectrum to launch a competing provider.
It's clear that this theory is sometimes true -- that regulatory barriers can do this. Whether it's always the cause is hard to say and depends mostly on how you define what "regulatory barriers" means. But consider the consequences either way.
If there are regulatory barriers causing monopolies, you have to break them up. If there are some other things causing monopolies, you have to break them up. Monopolies are bad. And breaking them up, if they are caused by regulatory barriers, can hamper the entities lobbying to keep the regulatory barriers.
The question is what comes after. You don't want them to just reform again, right? Antitrust is a necessary evil, but still an evil -- still means you had a monopoly for long enough to have to bust it up. So if it's mostly or entirely regulatory capture which is causing them, we still need to address that. And then we don't need antitrust enforcement as often.
But we still need it whenever a monopoly/oligopoly forms. That's just not a thing that can remain.
- tablespoon 5y ago>> Without external restraints, any sufficiently large company will focus on eliminating competition either through pricing them out of the market or just outright buying them. > The counterargument is that this only happens in markets with high barriers to entry, which in turn are mostly caused by regulatory barriers. Not necessarily. For instance: if the barriers to entry are zero but the monopoly can price things below cost (e.g. due to cash reserves or strength in other markets), it can bury any competitor. The mere existence of that ability could have a deterrent effect that prevents competitors from forming in the first place.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> For instance: if the barriers to entry are zero but the monopoly can price things below cost (e.g. due to cash reserves or strength in other markets), it can bury any competitor. The mere existence of that ability could have a deterrent effect that prevents competitors from forming in the first place. If barriers to entry are zero, the deterrent doesn't exist, because the deterrent works by forcing the competitor to pay the cost of entry without ever making any profits to recover it. Now suppose barriers to entry are low. Not even zero -- say it's $10,000. Some individual shows up, pays the $10,000, and the monopoly slashes prices so they can never recover their $10,000. But they got into it because they're a stubborn former customer who doesn't like how they've been treated, so making billions of dollars isn't the point. Their goal is to screw the monopolist. Which means all they have to do is sit on the ability to make product indefinitely and use it as soon as the monopolist attempts to raise prices above cost. To prevent this the monopolist would have to sell below cost indefinitely. But in that case the potential competition is keeping them in check as much as actual competition would. And this works even better when disgruntled former customers get together, so that it's not one guy willing to pay $10,000 to spite the monopolist but 10,000 customers each willing to pay $1. Where this falls down is when the price of entry becomes billions and involves a major risk of failure.
- lovich 5y agoI mean, I’m pretty sure it fails down when the theory relies on people willing to burn capital solely to stick it to someone else. That’s less like innovation and investment and more like warfare. It also runs counter to all observed behavior. A lot of these regulatory barriers can be overcome by money and we don’t see disgruntled people/groups banding together to provide services or goods at a loss
- dwohnitmok 5y ago> Which means all they have to do is sit on the ability to make product indefinitely and use it as soon as the monopolist attempts to raise prices above cost. You're underestimating the economic tools at the disposal of large companies. Lucrative contracts with suppliers that prevent selling to competitors, vertical integration where they just buy the suppliers outright, attack advertising, poaching employees, etc. A lot of these can happen even without active malice. Selling below cost is just one of many tools. There are many many ways an economically powerful player can strongarm competitors into submission. None of these are foolproof (and nothing in politics or economics is), but they all make the barrier to entry higher, sometimes almost impossibly high even in the absence of regulation (that is to say thinking of barrier to entry as something that is independent of a monopoly is not a good model, monopolies are intrinsically a barrier to entry).
- nostrademons 5y agoMany barriers to entry are caused by regulation, but not all, and perhaps not even most. Some problems are just hard, and tend to favor incumbents with economies of scale. Until very recently (post-GDPR), there were no regulatory barriers protecting Search, for example; nevertheless, new entrants found it very difficult to get traction because search is a hard problem. Same goes for putting up cell towers, and burying fiber lines, and maintaining an electric grid. I'd also argue that most oligopolies aren't formed by technical or government constraints, but rather by branding and consumer behavior. Consumers usually have a desire to stick with familiar, trusted brands, and to try new brands only when they've been recommended by people they trust. This creates barriers to new entrants, because you don't start out with any baseline trust and you have to compete against companies that have been in use for a century. There's nothing technically difficult about bottling carbonated sugar-water; regardless, Coca-Cola enjoys enormous margins because it's ingrained in the habits of hundreds of millions of people. When there's actual regulatory capture, we should address that, and untangle the regulations so new firms can enter. But don't expect that solving regulatory capture is going to fix all instances of monopoly.
- Osiris 5y agoMicrosoft, with massive resources, has been trying to break the Google search monopoly for over a decade without making a dent. Search startup DuckDuckGo uses Bing on the backend rather than building their own.
- letitbeirie 5y agoSpectrum is kind of a weird case though because it kind of has to be monopolistic - if you allow multiple, independent systems to share the same frequency band, none of them will work. > Suppose instead they held a new auction every year or every month for use of the spectrum in a given region until the next auction. This would work if the government or some common third party were responsible for putting up towers (and lease them to the telecoms like MVNOs), but as it is the telecoms build and operate the towers themselves, and the hardware loadout changes slightly depending on which frequency bands that telecom is allowed to use.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Spectrum is kind of a weird case though because it kind of has to be monopolistic - if you allow multiple, independent systems to share the same frequency band, none of them will work. In theory you could actually do this by using TDM with real time auctions for spectrum access. But "monopoly" is still the wrong word because you don't have to allocate 100% of the spectrum to the same company. If there are a hundred and they each have a "monopoly" on a specific 1% of it, they're still in competition with each other. > This would work if the government or some common third party were responsible for putting up towers (and lease them to the telecoms like MVNOs) So have the third parties do that. "That would work if we do that thing that would work" means it would work.
- agentdrtran 5y ago> The counterargument is that this only happens in markets with high barriers to entry, which in turn are mostly caused by regulatory barriers. There are hundreds of entire industries that have gigantic barriers to entry no matter what the regulations are. Covering the country in cell towers, building fleets of container ships, designing an operating systems and full suite of applications — these things aren't cheap
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThat's only because you're defining the market as "has an entire fleet of container ships," which is just assuming the existence of a consolidated industry. Each container ship could be its own entity and then you just need marketplaces for people to hire them to ship things. You don't have to build a national cellular network, you can put up one tower and then sell service to a market of MVNOs which buy service from different tower providers in different regions. Every piece of an operating system doesn't have to be built by the same entity. See Linux. For that matter, see macOS, which is full of BSD code written by many separate entities.
- OkayPhysicist 5y agoYou're grossly underestimating transaction costs. It is vastly preferrable from a company's perspective to be able to make 1 deal with 1 company that has many ships, as opposed to many deals woth many companies that have 1 ship each. Reducing that cost ends up looking like Uber, where you've just moved your monopoly point to the controller of the marketplace. Each individual deal an entity makes takes time and money.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe transaction costs problem is when you have 100,000 ships and 100,000 customers and it becomes ten billion individual relationships. You do solve this with things like Uber, but such things don't themselves have to be a monopoly, because you don't have to make it 100,000:1, you can make it 100,000:20 and have twenty competing marketplaces but still not an explosively large number of separate relationships. This works even better with federated marketplaces. There are a lot of problems with the international banking system, but the general idea that someone in New York can make a wire transfer to someone in London even though they each use a different bank is based on protocols rather than a single centralized world monopoly bank, and in that respect is better than the more centralized alternative.
- Rury 5y ago>Monopolies are bad. Not entirely... there's a tradeoff. People forget that monopolies can be a good thing in that it can force a standard. For example, if English were said to have a monopoly on language, it would become very easy to speak and communicate around the world, as it would be the only language spoken everywhere. Contrast, if we have 200 versions of spoken languages, we'd have communication barriers to overcome when we try to communicate with someone foreign.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> For example, if English were said to have a monopoly on language, it would become very easy to speak and communicate around the world, as it would be the only language spoken everywhere. Contrast, if we have 200 versions of spoken languages, we'd have communication barriers to overcome when we try to communicate with someone foreign. You don't need a monopoly to do this because people can be bilingual. English is the de facto language of international websites on the internet, so people in Spain who speak Spanish and English and people in Russia who speak Russian and English go to Twitter or Reddit and talk to each other in English. The same is true of internet standards. Everybody uses TCP/IP. Everybody. But nobody has a monopoly on it and nobody is prohibiting anyone from using a competitor out of anything other than network effect. If IPv8 turns out to be super amazing and has many advantages that overcome the inertia of IPv4, everyone could switch. Which is the thing you don't get with a corporate monopoly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Rury 5y ago>You don't need a monopoly to do this because people can be bilingual True, but it takes more work/effort to learn two languages than one. Whereas if we had one language (as in a monopoly), it'd be even simpler/easier. >The same is true of internet standards. Everybody uses TCP/IP. Yes, if protocols were businesses, they then could be thought of as having a monopoly on their domains.
- 5y ago