3 ms·
> In order to consume good, I must purchase good from company. I have no say in how good was produced. You can buy from a different company, or a subsitute go
by wolverine876 5y ago
> In order to consume good, I must purchase good from company. I have no say in how good was produced.
You can buy from a different company, or a subsitute good, or not buy it. We aren't powerless at all. Companies live and die by consumer purchasing decisions.
> The goal is to align incentives such that companies can produce goods without destroying the planet. The goods themselves are not the issue.
It depends on the goods. Some can't be produced without destroying the planet.
- dibujante 5y agoYep! Just buy from a non-emitting company. They wouldn't lie to you and claim to be non-emitting, because that would be mean.
- wolverine876 5y ago> They wouldn't lie to you and claim to be non-emitting I don't understand: Everyone is always lying? You have no power to identify the truth and act on it?
- dibujante 5y agoHow would you verify a company's emissions? With your monitoring satellite? Otherwise, it's their word against your inability to verify anything.
- jrgoff 5y agoIt is not feasible for consumers to be informed at that level about all of the goods they consume and for most of us there I doubt there is a practical way to be informed about these sorts of things for most products even if we were to try. Furthermore, even if we were informed for a particular product there may be no better behaved alternatives in the marketplace for something we consider to be a necessity.
- wolverine876 5y ago> It is not feasible for consumers to be informed at that level about all of the goods they consume Nobody said "all", we don't have to live in a world of perfection and extremes. We can buy electric cars, use renewable energy. > even if we were informed for a particular product there may be no better behaved alternatives in the marketplace for something we consider to be a necessity. Things might not turn out well if you try something, so don't try? How do someone get out of bed in the morning on that basis? Your point is that you are absolutely powerless to do anything? It's obviously false, but why is that important to you?
- keymone 5y agoYes, that is exactly what the “personal carbon footprint” propaganda wants you to believe. Majority of the planet is close to living in poverty, majority don’t have the luxury to go for the more expensive option because of their love of the environment.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Majority of the planet is close to living in poverty Who said anything about the majority? And that's certainly not the demographic of HN, or the people creating most of the carbon footprint. Also, by advanced economy standards, most of the world is deep in poverty. > majority don’t have the luxury to go for the more expensive option because of their love of the environment. It's not luxury and love, but necessity, responsibility, and survival. The impovrished people will suffer the most. Also, the options aren't necessarily more expensive, and are generally much cheaper if you account for the costs of climate change.
- keymone 5y ago> if you account for the costs of climate change. either you were led to believe it's only personal responsibility of direct consumers to account for the costs of climate change, or you were paid to propagandize that claim. if first - you're wrong, if second - i'll leave it unsaid.