3 ms·
With complete transparency we could have hundreds of volunteer deficit reduction Super Committees to look for the best places to cut costs and improve efficienc
by nl 15y ago
With complete transparency we could have hundreds of volunteer deficit reduction Super Committees to look for the best places to cut costs and improve efficiency.
This sounds like a great idea, but I worry...
A lack of shared values means each "Super Committee" seems likely to fall into a battle over values. Some will insist on cutting defence spending, other will cut welfare programs. Compromises won't be based on what makes sense, but by trading off between sides.
I'm not sure that is any better than the existing system - and in some ways it is worse. It slows down government even more, and it is likely to increase partisanship.
- lucasjung 15y agoI think the idea is more that ineffective (or at least terribly inefficient) programs would be much less likely to survive in such an environment. If program a is designed to achieve effect B, some people will argue for it because they think that B is desirable, and others will argue against it because they think that B is undesirable, or because it produces some side effect C which they find undesirable. However, if it is shown that program a does not achieve effect B, or is terribly inefficient at doing so, then even proponents of effect B would have to agree that it should be eliminated. Presumably, those proponents would then push for some new program aimed at achieving effect B, but that's a separate issue.
- nl 15y agoYou have much more faith in people relying on facts than I do. Given that some people actively discount expert opinion, I can't see how concepts like logical reasoning would work...