6 ms·
Mergers ruin everything
- oli5679 5y agoThis is a really thorough article on the topic [1]. Here is the conclusion. "American antitrust laws date from a time when changes in transportation, communications, and manufacturing technologies generated unprecedented economies of scale, fueling the rise of industrial behemoths. Today, dramatic advances in information technology, combined with globalization, are fueling the growth of large and efficient “superstar firms” that are capturing a growing share of economic activity. The emergence of the tech titans is especially dramatic. These economic conditions call for a reinvigoration of antitrust enforcement in the United States to promote competition, protect consumers and workers, and spur economic growth. These valuable aims can be achieved by taking a tougher stance toward mergers involving market leaders and by vigilantly preventing dominant firms from engaging in conduct that excludes their rivals. However, moving in that direction is a slow process, requiring the antitrust enforcement agencies to take the lead and convince inertial and possibly skeptical courts to follow. Those who expect dramatic and rapid changes in antitrust will be disappointed, unless new legislation is passed. Likewise, those who expect antitrust to solve problems unrelated to competition will be disappointed. Stronger antitrust enforcement, while needed, is not a substitute for badly needed regulations directed at reducing the political influence of corporations, protecting privacy and data security, and limiting the spread of disinformation." [1] https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.33.3.69 https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.33.3.69
- Spooky23 5y agoPositive progress is not going to happen anytime soon. When the more reactionary members of the legal profession moved beyond the various topics that interested then in the 50s and 60s, the new generation moved on to business matters, as big companies were getting tired of dealing with unions and tight regulatory controls. Over time, the interpretation of the antitrust law was changed by “judicial legislation” to narrowly define monopolies to a standard involving price increases for consumers. That’s why the government allows, say oil distribution infrastructure to regionally consolidate to two players, while Staples and OfficeMax cannot merge despite their irrelevance. The current system incentives cartels. So when Microsoft buys Walmart or Google buys Verizon, that will be fine. 20 years from now, 80% of consumer spending will probably be directed at a half dozen companies. Eventually, something really bad will happen. The US will get spanked in a war, a regional natural disaster will trigger a famine, etc. At that point, maybe you’ll see some change. But change is slow - the US House passed anti-lynching legislation for like 40 years and it never got out of Senate committee until Lyndon Johnson championed it.
- elliekelly 5y ago> Over time, the interpretation of the antitrust law was changed by “judicial legislation” to narrowly define monopolies to a standard involving price increases for consumers. And many of today's biggest tech companies largely get a pass because antitrust law focuses on price and ignores all other negative externalities that result from monopolistic behavior like quality, timeliness, ease of access to customer service, user privacy, and corporate social responsibility. But the product is "free" so how can the consumer possibly derive any further benefit?(/s) When there is competition in a market not only do prices fall but the customer experience improves. Businesses don't (and can't) compete on price. They compete on value. But US antitrust law ignores value entirely and consumers everywhere pay the price.
- elcritch 5y agoThere was a lot of progress in the 1910's, iirc. It's possible that enough people will become frustrated enough to lobby for effective change. Generally that requires a few leaders capable of capturing the angst in a useful way.
- voidfunc 5y agoPeople are significantly more exposed to the stock market these days than in 1910. Considering tons of people's 401k's are basically made up of the biggest companies in the US thanks to index funds there is a lot of incentive to not fuck with those companies. If any leaders gets really serious about breaking up some of the Big Tech companies you'll see enormous pressure to get them out of office ASAP.
- maxwell 5y agoGoogle's brand protection racket [1] and manipulation of ad exchanges [2] has resulted in lost economic activity. Apple's crippling of the iOS ecosystem [3] has resulted in lost economic activity. Breaking them up should raise overall economic activity, nationally and globally, along with actually increasing the value of the Baby Googs and Apple Seeds, as previously with Standard Oil and, until allowed to reassemble in '96 [4], AT&T. I would think that index funds vs. individual stocks would translate to investors caring less about particular firms and more about economic activity and the resulting increases in asset values. Pressured out of office? Most U.S. politicians have now spoken out against Big Tech, the Department of Justice and several states have active antitrust suits, a House report concluded that Amazon, Facebook, Apple, and Google have monopoly power and should be split up [5], etc. 1. https://altitudemarketing.com/blog/competitors-buying-my-name-google-ads https://altitudemarketing.com/blog/competitors-buying-my-nam... 2. https://www.wired.com/story/google-antitrust-ad-market-lawsuit https://www.wired.com/story/google-antitrust-ad-market-lawsu... 3. https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU05/20190716/109793/HHRG-116-JU05-20190716-SD036.pdf https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU05/20190716/109793/HHRG... 4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996#Claims_made_in_opposition_to_the_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996... 5. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/10/house-amazon-facebook-apple-google-have-monopoly-power-should-be-split https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/10/house-amazon-fac...
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Likewise, those who expect antitrust to solve problems unrelated to competition will be disappointed. Stronger antitrust enforcement, while needed, is not a substitute for badly needed regulations directed at reducing the political influence of corporations, protecting privacy and data security, and limiting the spread of disinformation. This is wrong. The "political influence of corporations" comes from their size and vertical integration. Google has outsized influence in politics because it controls the dominant search engine and YouTube etc., which gives political influence to every other subsidiary of the same company in a way that would not occur if they were independent entities. Privacy and security problems are proportional to size. Bigger entities attract stronger attacks (because the benefit to the attacker is larger) and then more people are compromised at once. Misinformation is primarily a problem as a result of filter bubbles that prevent people from hearing the rebuttal to incorrect arguments. Diversity of information distribution addresses this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Osiris 5y agoIn an unregulated capitalist economy, the inevitable end result is monopoly. The best way to compete in the economy is to not have to compete. Without external restraints, any sufficiently large company will focus on eliminating competition either through pricing them out of the market or just outright buying them. The only reason the US has more than one cellular network right now it because the government has prevented multiple attempts at mergers, and even with that effort we're down to three. edit: if you disagree, I'd love to hear your opinion. The government has entire agencies dedicated to maintaining competition in the economy. If monopoly was not the inevitable end result of capitalism, then such agencies would not be required.
- milkytron 5y ago> The only reason the US has more than one cellular network right now it because the government has prevented multiple attempts at mergers, and even with that effort we're down to three. There actually was a monopoly in the telephone system[0] in the US that had to be broken up via antitrust. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell_System
- Osiris 5y agoAnd over the last 40 years has slowly consolidated back again.
- 0_____0 5y agoThanks, Reagan.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe AT&T breakup actually happened under Reagan, and was initiated in 1974 (which was Nixon/Ford). The reconsolidation happened under both parties throughout the 90s and 2000s.
- 5y ago
- misterbishop 5y ago[flagged]
- dang 5y ago"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Also, please don't take HN threads further into generic ideological battle—on internet forums, that's a step towards repetitive, dumbed-down discussion that usually just turns nasty. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=generic%20ideolog%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- baybal2 5y agoUS is a very, very regulated economy. And if you go into securities space, you basically can't even slice a piece of bread without a lawyer. There are countries with much lower amount of regulation, without everything rolling into one giant monopoly. I would say it is exactly that legal minefield, and active dirigisme that greatly distorts natural conduct of business into non-stop search of how to game the policy. One thing deserving a look is to what length US legal system is set to go to intervene into sale of public companies, which is taken as purely a contractual matter in between two companies, rather than dispute over "fairness" in pretty much every normal country. An outright fraud should of course be prevented, but courts should not be allowed to order somebody to basically be compensated for a bad deal.
- wpietri 5y agoYour theory is that Microsoft and Google and Facebook ended up with monopoly power because their industries were just too darned regulated at the time they established themselves?
- baybal2 5y agoYes, they repeatedly sued their respective competitors, and disruptors out of business
- MontagFTB 5y agoThe regulations may not have existed at the time these companies established themselves, but could have evolved over time. It's a known practice of larger corporations to promote regulations that take them little effort to adhere to. However, those same regulations raise the bar for startups to gain entry and compete in an industry. Ironically enough, it's the regulations themselves that become anti-competitive. This isn't true for regulations categorically, to be sure- the established companies can wield lobbying power for particular regulations to pass. That makes them look good in the public eye, the government wins for adding "oversight", but the actual competitive landscape becomes more encumbered, not less.
- good-idea 5y agoShould they be squashing instead?
- zentiggr 5y agoThis looks entirely offtopic. Commenting on wrong post?
- oplav 5y agoIt sounds like a git joke about squashing vs merging.
- blendergeek 5y agoIt looks to me like GP may have commented without reading the article. "Mergers ruin everything" could be misread as "Merges ruin everything". Just reading the title could lead someone to think this was a discussion about git best-practices.
- brimstedt 5y agoI was actually hoping for a nuanced view on code branch/merge tactics. Got any suggestions on the topic?
- good-idea 5y agoI don't have any good resources off-hand (other than what shows up in a quick search), but my "best practices" are to always squash and keep PRs as small as possible. When a working branch falls behind main, I prefer to rebase it instead of merging from main to keep it up to date. However, if you've already pushed your working branch to a repo, after rebasing you need to `git push --force` - which is a problem if there are others who have previously cloned the working branch.
- vincentmarle 5y agoSquashing also introduces problems when you are resolving merge conflicts in your branch: squashing doesn’t preserve merge conflict resolution so you end up having to resolve those conflicts again after merging.
- antihero 5y agoThis is fascinating but to read the series is it $8/mo? I’m confused, that is more than most magazine subscriptions.
- robinjhuang 5y agoAs matt says, you can pay for the truth or get lies for free ;) I've been a subscriber for two years and a paid one as soon as it was offered. Really recommend it! We also have open forums and a discord to talk about anything anti-monopoly.
- antihero 5y agoIt does sound cool but I wish there was like a dollar sub. I already pay so much in Patreon fees…I see there’s a free subscription so I’ll see if I keep reading that
- jacobr1 5y agoI want substack to have some kind of overall subscription where I can allocate my overall subscription spend to the newsletters, rather than having a per-newsletter fee. Maybe something like Kindle's system that has some kind page-read/engagement metric against the monthly revenue pool. Maybe something where I get discounting for buying in bulk. 10 newsletters for the price of 5 a la carte or whatever, and I can allocate my "newsletter credits" at will, even switching between them. Also how can libraries and other institutions subscribe and delegate their access?
- WJW 5y agoI'm sure anyone writing lies can also charge money though, just because you pay for something does not make it good.
- pessimizer 5y agoMaybe 1/10 of of the entries are exclusive to subscribers, and they're 95% of the time "open threads" where the commenters are talking to each other with Stoller giving them a few topics to kick it off. So really, the price is $0/mo.
- treis 5y ago>Americans pay $50 billion more per year than Europeans for similar cell phone service, which is about $14/month in pure profit for every single American This doesn't really add up. T-mobile's net income is 3-4 billion a year on 80 billion on revenue. They're not generating monopoly profits. IMHO I don't think you can really merge your way into a monopoly. The existence of multiple companies to merge is effective proof that whatever business they're in is not a natural monopoly. Look at social media as an example. Facebook is the dominant player but in the course of their existence Instagram, WhatsApp, TikTok, and Snapchat have all become billion+ companies while another dozen or so have made it to 100+ million. Allowing them to buy Instagram and WhatsApp didn't prevent the rise of Tiktok or the continued existence of Snapchat. There's no natural monopoly here and probably should be little concern to anti-trust regulators. Compare with phones. You have a stable Android/Apple duopoly but it didn't come from mergers. It's a natural monopoly business so naturally monopolies formed. Facebook, Amazon, and Microsoft all trying to break into the market and failing miserably is also strong evidence. This should be a huge concern to anti-trust regulators.
- ultrasaurus 5y agoMaybe "profit" is the wrong word. Anecdotally, the US has a lot of dedicated & spacious cell phone stores compared to other countries I've been in (where selling SIM cards is part of another store, like a 7-11 or an electronics store). It's possible there's an extra $14/month in revenue going towards cell phones as an industry but due to the competition such as it is, it's mostly being spent on more aggressive GTM expenses.
- RamblingCTO 5y agoI always find it fascinating what monopolies are allowed in other countries. As a European I can only shake my head at the consolidation of the gaming industry right now. That would most probably not be allowed here. How can two companies buy up companies like Bungie and Activision? That's toxic to the economy imho.
- orlovs 5y agoDefining monopoly by marketshare is shallow. Best monopoly is when your customers switching costs are high. Thats why some of FAMG is with so good friends with Lawmakers. To provide political protection. I am not from US, but what I see from my experience there is one huge problem with mergers (besides all other): too big to fail. If you become systematical player like big banks and if you intentionally or non-intentionally get in trouble. You will be bailed out, not go bankrupt. This turns on God mode for Corporations, this create intention become reckless. If big banks would not be bailled out in 2008. Most likely we would see at least some kind of fragmetation.
- julienb_sea 5y agoThere are coherent, legitimate reasons for some degree of consolidation within industries. Technology sharing, combining assets, reducing the overhead from separate operations and larger scale in theory lead to a more efficient business, enabling cost reductions that create both profits and a competitive advantage. Consolidated industries can be highly competitive. An industry with multiple large players is more competitive compared to a single large player surrounded by many small players. I acknowledge this is not uniformly the case. Mergers do definitionally eliminate competition between the merged players and efficiency gains do not always materialize. But, the broad theory is well established and has shown success across practically any industrial vertical.
- Kinrany 5y agoIt's worse: every possible advantage of mergers is a good thing made impossible by competition. Mergers are a sign of the market itself being inefficient.
- danaris 5y agoWhile this is true, to some extent, it also implies that "being inefficient" is necessarily bad. Optimizing for efficiency has led to some of the worst problems we've seen in recent years. Just off the top of my head, "lean staffing", which is an abusive management practice, and the inability to comfortably withstand shocks to the system, as we saw when COVID hit.
- bsder 5y agoA merger is an admission that a company has no better internal development project to put money into. (This also applies to stock buybacks.) This is an admission that the management has failed. Doubly so if they simply shut down the acquired business. The proper "capitalistic" solution would be to allow the competitor to grow big and kill the dinosaur. We need to block mergers even from a purely "capitalist" viewpoint because it prevents the efficient new competitors from displacing the old inefficient ones.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- summari 5y agoQuick summary of this for those short on time looking to get the gist. https://share.summari.com/mergers-ruin-everything https://share.summari.com/mergers-ruin-everything
- samgtx 5y agoWhat a neat little tool that is. Bookmarked.
- perlgeek 5y agoToday I learned that in the US, cheerleading is an industry. I always thought this was mostly done by enthusiastic school and college kids, not much money in it. How naive of me :-)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- evancox100 5y agoIt is mostly done by enthusiastic students, Varsity's monopoly is in the apparel, supplies, and accessories that said students purchase.
- Invictus0 5y agoThey also manipulate the competitions to favor those purchasing their products. There’s more than blocking advertising and distribution at these competitions. Webb admitted that in at least one contest, cheerleaders got more points if they used more Varsity equipment as props. In other words, it’s not just a rigged game as some sort of metaphor, Varsity actually rigged the rules of its cheerleading competition to coerce purchases of Varsity products. Indeed, Webb has testified in court that the competitions exist solely for the “promotion of his cheerleading supply business.” https://mattstoller.substack.com/p/this-is-not-a-democracy-its-a-cheerocracy https://mattstoller.substack.com/p/this-is-not-a-democracy-i...
- summari 5y ago