3 ms·
> Btrfs raid 1/10 is rock solid Maybe (though even then I've heard talk of bugs), but the article mainly talks about raid5/6-like modes and those are still mar
by lmm 5y ago
> Btrfs raid 1/10 is rock solid
Maybe (though even then I've heard talk of bugs), but the article mainly talks about raid5/6-like modes and those are still marked as unsafe AIUI.
> My understanding is ZFS (or any other raid) would offline the drive in this scenario, if this is true then btrfs raid is arguably better.
ZFS can certainly handle a large number of read errors (recording them but remaining running), but if you reach the point where a device node completely disappears then it won't automatically re-add it when it comes back (you have to explicitly "zpool online" or reboot, then the pool will be imported as dirty and recover). I don't know the full details of exactly what ZFS does in every scenario but to my mind having a level of error at which you offline a drive seems pretty reasonable - once a drive is completely broken it's a waste of everyone's effort to keep retrying indefinitely.