2 ms·
I think achievements can sometimes push you into playing the game in a way that is less fun than what you would have otherwise done. The opposite can be true to
by account42 5y ago
I think achievements can sometimes push you into playing the game in a way that is less fun than what you would have otherwise done. The opposite can be true too of course, but still for people that a predisposed to want to "complete" things they will inevitably run into bad experiences.
One variant of that problem is achievements for certain endings or outcomes that feel like discouraging you from choosing your own.
Another problem is not inherent with achievements but but with the common implementation: For immersive games a popup even if it is show only a short time can really take you out of the experience. On the other hand, it is possible to inegrate the achievement popups into the experience like the "The Part Where He Kills You" achievement in Portal 2 that adds of the comedic effect of the cutscene it appears in.
Overall, there are definitely games where achievements take more away than they add. Unfortunately they seem to get added to almost everything just due to cargo culting, because they also serve as telemetry or even player demand. Platforms should at least give you the option to never show them.