2 ms·
> You shouldn't force memorization. It should come naturally as you use certain things many times. If you use 7*6 often, you will remember it. If not, you will
by kragen 5y ago
> You shouldn't force memorization. It should come naturally as you use certain things many times. If you use 7*6 often, you will remember it. If not, you will forget it. That should be totally fine. Why should it matter if you memorized 7*6 or you had to go the long way and say 7*5 is 35 so add 7 to 35 and you'll get 7*6?
As it turns out, though intuitively appealing, this idea is wrong.
You can't learn to touch-type by programming. You have to focus some effort on specifically the touch-typing aspect of things. Half an hour a day of directed practice at touch-typing for a month will improve your typing speed more than ten hours a day of programming for a year. Similarly with multiplication tables: if you devote the necessary effort to memorizing the 28 or so necessary facts and speeding up recall on them, your speed at long multiplication increases dramatically. In my childhood I refused. When confronted with a multiplication problem, I would get medieval on it: mediation and duplation! This was a bad strategy.
In fact, I've often wondered if committing more lookup tables to memory might help more. Consider the Briggsian logarithms:
log₁₀ 1.1 = .0414
log₁₀ 1.2 = .0792
log₁₀ 1.3 = .1139
log₁₀ 1.4 = .1461
log₁₀ 1.5 = .1761
log₁₀ 1.6 = .2041
log₁₀ 1.7 = .2304
log₁₀ 1.8 = .2553
log₁₀ 1.9 = .2788
log₁₀ 2.0 = .3010
log₁₀ 3.0 = .4771
log₁₀ 4.0 = .6021
log₁₀ 5.0 = .6990
log₁₀ 6.0 = .7782
log₁₀ 7.0 = .8451
log₁₀ 8.0 = .9031
log₁₀ 9.0 = .9542
Consider the problem of computing the horizontal scan frequency of a minimal viable text terminal CRT. It refreshes at 60 Hz, contains 24 lines of text of 8 scanlines each, and has a 10% VBI, so the problem is multiplying 60 · 24 · 8 · 1.09. In Magic Logarithm Land, we just have to add the logarithms. We can mentally interpolate log₁₀ 24 as 1.30 + .4 · (.48 - .30) = 1.38 and log₁₀ 1.09 = .9 · .04 = .04, so we have 1.78 + 1.38 + .90 + .04 = 4.10, which is between 4.08 and 4.11, so the answer is about 12800 Hz. The exact answer with the multiplicands as given is 12556.8, so that's less than 2% error, as it usually is when rounding to two places. Even that is excessive precision given the fuzziness implicit in the VBI figure.
I can't actually do this mentally, partly because I haven't memorized even the list of 17 logarithms listed above, so instead what I end up doing is something like, well, 24 · 8 is about 25 · 8, which is 200, and ×60 gives 600 + 600 = 12000, and then we add 10% for 13200, and then we'll be about 5% high because of rounding up the 24 and the 1.09, which also gives 12700 or 12800. But I can't help thinking that mentally adding 78 + 38 + 90 + 4 would be easier!
Memorizing a quarter-square table for the integers up to 100 would also help with this kind of thing.
Agreed, though, that a typing test for programmers or a times-table test for mathematicians would be counterproductive.
- mdp2021 5y agoSorry but I have difficulties in reading your intention in > We can mentally interpolate log₁₀ 24 as 1.30 + .4 · (.48 - .30) = 1.38 Easily one could go log₁₀ 24 = log₁₀ (6*4) = .78+.60 = 1.38, for example, but you went something along the lines of "log₁₀20 + .4 · log₁₀(3/2)", making "24" read as something like "20x(3/2)^(4/10)"... What was the intended process?
- kragen 5y agoSorry! I was saying that 2.4 is between 2.0 and 3.0, whose logarithms are .3010 and .4771. The distance from .3010 to .4771 is .1761, or .18 to two places, so if we linearly interpolate .4 of the way from .3010 to .4771, we get .3010 + .4 · .1761 = .3010 + .0704 = .3714. Doing it with two-place logs, we get .30 + .4 · .18 = .37. The correct value for log₁₀ 2.4 rounds to .3802, so the linear interpolation is not very precise. In fact I happened to make an error in the mental interpolation that coincidentally was in the right direction: I estimated .4 · .18 ≈ .4 · .2 = .08, giving me the more correct .38 by luck. It is of course true that if you factor your numbers you can get better precision with fewer table entries, as you did. But I think it's easier to mentally routinize linear interpolation between table entries so you can do it instantly than to mentally routinize factorization. Such mental linear interpolation was commonplace when using physical printed books of logarithm tables because it easily gives you, say, 4-place precision out of a 3-place table, allowing you to use a book that's one tenth the size and contains one tenth the incorrect entries. Even very small amounts of memorization can give you lots of logarithms if you do mental work with them. With just log₁₀ 2 ≈ .3010 (and log₁₀ 10 ≡ 1), we can easily derive log₁₀ 5 ≈ .6990, log₁₀ 4 ≈ .6020, log₁₀ 8 ≈ .9030, log₁₀ 2.5 ≈ .3980, log₁₀ 1.6 ≈ .2040, log₁₀ 1.25 ≈ .0970, etc. If you additionally know log₁₀ 3 ≈ .4771, you can easily get 6 = 2·3, 9 = 3·3, 1.2 = 6·2/10, 1.8 = 9·2/10, 2.4 = 1.2·2 (as you said), 1.5 = 5·3/10, etc. Equal temperament takes advantage of the fact that 3 is very close to 2 to the 19/12 power, about 0.3% larger; note numbers are frequency logarithms to the base of the 12th root of 2. Unfortunately that isn't very helpful if the numbers you need to calculate with are given in decimal form...
- mdp2021 5y agoSure having your tools ready - in some cases this means, memorized - will be useful when needed, but. Consider your example of the CRT. You are for interpolating, I tend towards factoring - no issue. First we memorize the log₁₀ of the main factors: 2→ .3 , 3→ .48 , 5→ .7 , 7→ .845 , 11→ 1.04 , 13→ 1.115 , 17→ 1.23 , 19→ 1.28 ...a good exercise that may allow us, potentially, to perform mental computations through simpler operations within a 1% error margin. And we could, in the example, perform (.78+1)+(.9+.48)+.9+(1.04-1) = 4.1 . Good. But now, one still needs a calculator to perform 10^4.1 ... :) This does not happen when we mentally multiply - we have ways to remain within acceptable approximation and still not need "crutches" printed in paper or silicon. Though of course, again: better with than without resources. For what I am concerned, that handful of factors will be memorized with priority not inferior to the date of the battle of Bosworth.