10 ms·
If this isn't a lie and Apple flipping that switch cost Facebook $10bn, then that tells me my personal information is worth a lot. What I was getting from Faceb
by criddell 5y ago
If this isn't a lie and Apple flipping that switch cost Facebook $10bn, then that tells me my personal information is worth a lot. What I was getting from Facebook in exchange for my data was too little. I use Google a lot more than Facebook and frankly what I get from them in exchange for my data is probably also way too little.
I wish there was some type of consumer union where we could negotiate with these companies as a block.
- eric4smith 5y ago
- DonHopkins 5y agoNot different??!
- airza 5y agoThe concept you are describing is a government.
- sfe22 5y agoExcept the government is a monopoly with its own agenda. In addition it already kind of owns us (well a large percentage), what would it gain if it negotiated this deal for us? I would argue it can gain more power by making a deal with facebook.
- newsclues 5y agoDigital direct democracy is a potential opportunity that has only become possible with ubiquitous computing devices (iPhones)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pnutjam 5y agoEveryone who doesn't vote and ignores their role in Democracy let's this happen. The president matters much less then the Mayor or the Governor.
- sfe22 5y ago
- sfe22 5y agoThere is no democracy other than direct democracy. If you cant fire your government this afternoon, they own you, not the other way around.
- codechad 5y ago
- CaptainZapp 5y agoThat's not how direct democracy works. If we assume that Switzerland is probably closest to the ideal of a direct democracy please take note that voters can not directly vote for the executive government (The Bundesrat, or federal council). They elect members of the two houses, which in turn elects the 7 executives. Usually this is based on the recommendation by the parties and with a specific formula considering party, language and area of the country. We also can't fire government members this afternoon. It's just like everywhere else. We can just not re-elect them.
- sfe22 5y agoI looked up the Swiss system, and it certainly is not direct democracy.
- ghaff 5y agoSo many towns where I live put issues on the agenda for town meetings. How this works in practice is that, if there's some issue that someone (like a developer) feels strongly about, they pack the town meeting with allies and push it through because most people probably don't care much and don't even attend the meeting.
- hn_neverguess 5y ago
- germinalphrase 5y ago“ In short, if you're excited about iOS 14, you are more likely to be poor than not” Why are supposing that all rich people made their money through online advertising? It’s clearly untrue and certainly not a robust enough a conclusion to feel bad about your relative success.
- hn_neverguess 5y agoI said "more likely," not "guaranteed to be." > Why are supposing that all rich people made their money through online advertising If you replace "all" with "most," which is how I phrased it, then your sentence sounds like this: > Why are supposing that most rich people made their money through online advertising Ok now we're onto something interesting, but I can see how you might be still struggling with the phrasing. May I suggest to reformulate as follows: > Why are supposing that most rich people made their money by selling something for more than they paid for it? Perfect! So we just have to answer if in the context of most people who became rich, "online advertising" = "selling something for more than they paid for it." I would argue that you can sell things without advertising them, but you certainly have to make people aware that you're selling those things one way or another (and mind you, in the context of rich people, you have to do that at a very large scale). So when answering how MOST rich people attracted attention in 2021, and that AT SCALE, I think the above is not so untrue (you will certainly find many who ALSO used TV and other channels, but very few people with a TV budget had a $0 paid social budget).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gms 5y agoThere is no need as there is no coercion involved: just stop using them if you don’t like it.
- criddell 5y agoAnd never have email correspondence with anybody who uses GMail?
- r0m4n0 5y agoHow do you know what you are getting from them is too little until the service itself is gone? I suppose you can estimate but I feel like without targeted advertising the web would be a dark place. Personally I don’t pay for much (prime, Netflix, NY Times) and expect a lot. The people I know are the same
- throwoutway 5y ago> I suppose you can estimate but I feel like without targeted advertising the web would be a dark place. Is this sarcasm? The web is a dark place because of targeted advertisement. I’d rather pay than be tracked and my data sold through bidding processes.
- visarga 5y agoThis comes up again and again. People will continue creating and posting even without ad money. They will post for art, for study, hobbies, social issues or just to organize events. There are also those who publish free content and make a profit on something related. That's how the good old internet was working back in the day. The problem with current internet is that everyone is trying to get the ad money so they don't really align their interests with us who want quality content.
- r0m4n0 5y agoThe problem is the freeloaders of the internet far outweigh the people that want to pay for services. Until that changes, we will continue to see the internet dominated by targeted advertising. Honestly, it will be interesting to see what happens to services like DDG. I think it will be a true test of what the world wants, an extremely well funded machine like Google or a more lean privacy centric tool. Capitalism is an interesting thing though. Targeted advertising naturally brings in more money (back to the freeloaders point)
- bko 5y agoIt's not perfect but you can look at average revenue per user on Facebook. There are huge differences based on the country (note this is quarterly): Q4 '20 Worldwide: 10.14 US: 53.56 Europe: 16.87 Asia Pacific: 4.05 Rest of world: 2.77 So you're worth just over $200 a year. This has gone up a lot over time and is considerably higher than other social networks. Just a year ago, it was 41.41 (23% less) and a year before that is was 34.86 (15% less). It's harder to do a comparison to google, but I'm sure you're very valuable to them as well, increasingly so. https://www.statista.com/statistics/251328/facebooks-average-revenue-per-user-by-region/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/251328/facebooks-average...
- d_watt 5y agoAnd likely a working professional adult who can afford an iPhone is worth at least a deviation or two above that.
- pessimizer 5y agoMaybe, but I'm not sure a working professional adult is an ad-clicker, and I'm not sure that the ads they click on can con them into doing something they wouldn't normally do very often.
- arepublicadoceu 5y ago> Maybe, but I'm not sure a working professional adult is an ad-clicker, and I'm not sure that the ads they click on can con them into doing something they wouldn't normally do very often. As a working professional adult, who has access to many others working professional adults, I assure you, ads work. You’re simplifying ads to a barebones click to rate exchange. Ads are way more subtle than that.
- pessimizer 5y agoI don't doubt they work. I doubt the margin of work done by facebook ads on working professional adults over the work of ads that they are exposed to through other means and by word of mouth. And not that that margin doesn't exist and not that it's not worthwhile to advertise on facebook, but the doubt is that as compared to any other demographic being advertised to that it's worth so much more. Advertising to impulsive spenders is worth more than advertising to less impulsive spenders. Less impulsive spenders are informed by ads, more impulsive spenders are convinced by ads.
- sporkland 5y ago$10B per year divided by say 150M users equals about $5.50 a month. Not bad, but not gonna cover your $20 Netflix fees.
- aerosmile 5y agoYour data are only as valuable to Facebook as your buying power. Obviously that's not the same across all people, and while the average revenue per US user might be in the teens per month, many US consumer are in the single digits. So presumably a consumer union might get you a fraction of that value back - a few bucks per month. Why not - who wouldn't want a free monthly cup of coffee? I suppose the only catch here is the more excited you get about this concept, the less money your union could negotiate on your behalf.
- echelon 5y agoNot a lie at all. Apple is as dirty as they come. Apple is a cartel and Google pays the protection money that Facebook failed to. If Apple really cared about privacy and not money, they'd block Google from the platform too. A single policy changed wiped 25% of a trillion dollar company's market cap. That's a gravitational wave that shows what kind of overwhelming monopoly power Apple wields. To be clear, I hate Facebook and ads, but Apple is an incredibly dirty business and is doing massive amounts of harm to startups and our industry as a whole. Apple owns "America's computer" (50+% of average American's internet usage), and they control it like a dictatorship. High taxes, close inspection of every deploy, arbitrary rulings, forced use of Apple platform pieces, no possible business relationships with your customers. The DOJ needs to step in and remove the App Store monopoly, its tax, and its arbitrary rules. When you run a device this pervasive and entrenched, it's no longer a platform. It's a common carrier. App installs need to happen over web, where they'd still be just as safely sandboxed, monitored, and remote killswitchable.
- CaptainZapp 5y ago> they'd block Google from the platform too. To be fair, they didn't block Facebook from their platform. Users now just need to agree that they want to be tracked (spoiler: practically no one wants to be tracked). I don't disagree with your general take and save for an iPod classic I don't own any Apple gear. But in my book that was one of the better moves that Apple ever pulled.
- philistine 5y agoYeah. More privacy by getting rid of third-party cookies and having the prompt for apps is a great thing. That it also reduces the revenue of the two monopolists who didn’t even bother to differentiate that revenue (Facebook is 98% ads, Google is at something like 81%) is the cherry on top.
- scarface74 5y agoSo, you’re complaining that Apple gave users a choice not to be tracked?
- scarface74 5y ago“I care a lot about my privacy. That’s why I use Google”…
- criddell 5y agoIt's more about my privacy being worth a lot more than what Google is willing to pay in the form of services. As an individual, the only thing I can do is stop using Google and Google wouldn't miss me.