23 ms·
Satellite finds methane leaks from gas pipelines
- go_elmo 5y agoInteresting ted talk [0], tl;dr fastest way to slow down global warming is exactly this [0] https://youtu.be/tlWuP7wESZw https://youtu.be/tlWuP7wESZw
- jacquesm 5y agoThat and reduction in cattle. (And the elephant in the room, that uncomfortable truth: consideration of the number of humans, which we sooner or later will have to address, even though that will be fraught with many ethics issues and is ripe for abuse).
- go_elmo 5y agoamount of people is irrelevant. Amount of people wanting to live US standard is the problem. Order new shitty clothes 3x a week and other consumption bs? Costs 300x of an average person in the developping world
- formvoltron 5y ago
- CPLNTN 5y agoWhat are you talking about? It totally isn’t, this generate profit! /s
- antocv 5y ago
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoI'm surprised we haven't seen it yet, it strikes me the environment is something people could become fanatical about.
- Bancakes 5y ago>(in Minecraft)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kmlx 5y agowait, you're advocating killing the executives of these companies because of methane leaks? or just bombing their homes? both feel completely disproportional, and completely divorced from reality. not only that, but i think this comment represents a crime in most jurisdictions across the planet. is advocating killing someone allowed on HN? what about droning their homes? @dang?
- formvoltron 5y agoImagine how quickly those leaks would get resolved! OK fine. Just round them up then and toss them into jail and throw away the key. There really is no greater crime. I was just trying to save the tax payer some money.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoI want to understand strikes as people stopping to work. I hope.
- aaron695 5y ago
- tentacleuno 5y ago> EDF is planning to launch its own methane-detecting satellite in about a year, which will take much sharper pictures, showing smaller leaks. Other organizations are developing their own methane detectors. When this does launch, the images taken should be open to public consumption, preferably on a website. Once we put these companies on blast with the hard facts, things will begin to change. Very quickly.
- gostsamo 5y agoYou read the part of the article where they mentioned Russia and Turkmenistan, right? The executives there won't be impressed by a protest.
- yoavm 5y agoI am assuming some of those companies are selling their gas and oil in Europe? We would need to trace that and just stop buying until they fix it.
- mc32 5y agoStop buying means not turning on the heater in winter… so go back to hearth and fireplace for heat to combat… pollution?
- henearkr 5y agoI know many electric-only houses: you can heat yourself without methane.
- mc32 5y agoThat’s fine for a long ye strategy. But asking people who are fitted for gas to go electric? Politicians tend to make delusional promises which can never happen. Something like this is a long term thing it’s not… stop using gas now!
- kajika91 5y agoI heard about this topic from the excellent youtube channel 'Engineering with Rosie' some months ago : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zuQLJIqFjkk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zuQLJIqFjkk If you are interesting about energy and environment I think this channel is very good.
- gefhfffh 5y agoTotally wasted "carbon" budget ...
- okl 5y agoKind of puzzling to me that this wasn't done earlier. Seems to be a low-hanging fruit, doesn't it?
- henearkr 5y agoThey needed the launch of specialized observation satellites, that doesn't sound like "low hanging" to me...
- okl 5y agoSure, but why didn't they come up with it 5-10-20 years ago? Technological reasons?
- baq 5y agoneed somebody with money. oil and gas companies are certainly interested in not paying for this.
- dannyz 5y agoThe short answer is yes. To characterize sources like this you need a very small pixel footprint size on the earth, which reduces the magnitude of the signal you actually observe, leading to higher technological requirements.
- mturmon 5y agoIt's a long road. I'll enlarge a bit on @dannyz's explanation you can see nearby. I happen to know one thread of work on the space-based CH4 detection problem...here is one early publication, from 2011: https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2010JD014849 https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/201... Not sure if the paper is behind a paywall for you, but you can see the xCH4 maps in Figs. 14 and following, on a 30km (1/3 degreee) grid. xCH4 = total air-column concentration of CH4, integrated from ground to top-of-atmosphere. The first author of the above paper, who is remarkably talented, continues to work on this problem all these years later. The maps you see there average many years of measurements to decrease noise. The signal is there, but you have to average a lot of measurements to extract it, and then your resolution is not helpful for the "real-time-detection" (leak) problem (small spatial/temporal footprint => averaging washes it out). The xCH4 signal is noisy partly because the CH4 is being measured spectroscopically, so you have to get a (bunch of) very fine slices of spectrum to see the CH4 absorption lines. There just aren't that many photons, and the detectors weren't that efficient. So yes, that's a technological/fabrication problem. Lots of people have worked to improve spectroscopic detectors over the meantime. Additionally, you have to disambiguate the CH4 signal from others that are much more impactful on spectra, like H2O vapor and CO2. You end up with a nonlinear inversion problem ("fiddle with the gas concentrations to optimize the fit of an atmospheric radiative transfer model to the observed spectrum"). This is a technical/modeling and algorithms problem, and again, lots of people have worked to improve models and methods, and on validation that they work. There has been a succession of instruments of higher capability launched to address this problem (OCO-2 by NASA, Tropomi by ESA as seen in OP). Usually you fly them in planes (https://avirisng.jpl.nasa.gov https://avirisng.jpl.nasa.gov) and move them to space as they are shown to work. And also a succession of very impactful papers in PNAS, Science, and Nature that discuss advances. And there will be more.
- joshspankit 5y ago“Oil and gas companies lie about the environmental damage they are causing intentionally” I feel like I’ve been reading some version of this headline for decades. How have we not been measuring and keeping them accountable every step of the way (and doubling down every time they get caught)?
- dewey 5y ago> How have we not been measuring and keeping them accountable every step of the way The answer is: money
- joshspankit 5y agoThis is the answer that makes me wild. I’m born and raised Canadian, and look at Norway as the small version of what Canada could be. Oil is a finite resource. We could simply say “you can extract some of it if you follow every single one of these environmental regulations, and pay enough in taxes that we can grow a massive fund while also investing in green energy AND the tools we need to hold you accountable. If you break one, it’s a crippling fine. If you break more or a referendum says you’re out, you’re out.”
- arbitrage 5y agoThe regulating organisations were compromised & captured decades ago. Yes, all of them.
- BurningFrog 5y agoThe oil operations in Russia and Turkmenistan are not what we usually mean by "the oil companies".
- wongarsu 5y agoIn the last 50 years we got a lot better with the types of localized damage the average voter can see, like polluting rivers. For everything else the incentives for politicians (in democracies) don't align: there's no upside for them to fixing something nobody complains about, but lots of potential downsides (worse relations with affected companies which might affect future jobs or favors, potential damage to the industry compared to international competitors resulting in job losses, etc). Studies like this that widen the range of damage we can see are an obvious step in the right direction. When enough voters see the damage and care about it it can be regulated. It's far from guaranteed, but without visibility it's basically guaranteed not to be fixed.
- baq 5y agooil and gas companies should be paying for building, launching and operating these birds and the data should be publicly available - this way they'll have at least somewhat proper incentive structure in place.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoNope, that would be a conflict of interest; they cannot be trusted to do all of these on time and adequately. They would need so much oversight that it'd be just as expensive to have an independent company run these things. I mean pay for it by all means, but that's where they stop. And even that's dubious, because it's never as simple as them handing over money; there will be terms and conditions. And of course, corruption would be widespread; the people working for this company monitoring methane emissions would get money or other benefits offered to them. And when you think about it, relatively speaking, people don't cost much. I'm confident I'd be up for hiding some data or other dodgy shit if the money was right. Think getting a bigger house kind of money.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y ago> it's never as simple as them handing over money; there will be terms and conditions. The "terms and conditions" would be "pay the tax or go to jail".
- davemp 5y agoOil and gas companies could easily do better right now (likely cheaper than the method in the OP). I know someone who worked at a fluid analysis modeling company and they claimed that pipelines could easily detect and fix leaks. Pipelines just don’t care until it passes a certain disturbingly high threshold where it affects profitability. The evil and greedy people at the helm of these companies cannot be trusted with the responsibility of managing our planets resources without oversight.
- joncrane 5y agoThey should pay for it but an independent body should be responsible for building, launching, maintaining, calibrating, etc. What we need is an incentive for the O&G companies to be squeaky clean and to rat each other out. Align the incentives.
- usgroup 5y agoI think a satellite product able to detect methane at a sub km resolution, layered by data products able to add meta such as the business it is related to, or show timeseries of emissions, would be splendid.
- Gadiguibou 5y agoTurns out this exists! The company I worked at last summer, GHGSAT [1], focuses exactly on this. They have a fleet of satellites and aircraft taking high-resolution (1-25m ground resolution) pictures of critical infrastructure on demand that allow oil and gas companies and landfills, notably, to identify those leaks and either patch them to recover the methane or torch the methane, greatly reducing the impact of the leak. The figures mentioned in the original article are very much what we observed as well. It wasn't all that uncommon to see leaks releasing 12 tons of methane per hour be left unpatched for *weeks*. Thanks to pressure from investors and to the additional revenue gained from identifying and patching those leaks, a lot of governments and the biggest oil companies have started paying for this service. [1]: https://www.ghgsat.com/en/ https://www.ghgsat.com/en/
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoSeems like the obvious first step would be requiring companies to buy emission certificates to cover those leaks. It'd very quickly become profitable to fix them.
- Gadiguibou 5y agoI agree that we should have larger financial incentives/pressure on these companies, but I don't know how good of a solution it is to tax at the emitter like this considering how hard it is to track those leaks still. The size of the images taken from GHGSAT's satellites could never cover a whole region reliably and they still require a lot of processing to allow for the detection of smaller leaks. I think that would create a situation where companies would underreport those leaks and the government wouldn't have a reliable way to check if they did. I think it'd be much more efficient to tax consumers in general for the oil they purchase and "let the free market do its thing". The transition or rather, letting the polluters pay their fair share, needs to happen much quicker than what we're seeing today and half-assed measures aren't getting us there anytime soon.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoBut remember to reduce your personal carbon footprint! /s We're expected to shave off a few kilos of CO2 here and there, usually at significant personal expense, while nothing is being done about these releases that a) could be avoided relatively easily b) have a much bigger impact. The abstract mentions ~8 million metric tons of methane per year. Using a GWP of 28 (which seems to be the value from the IPPC's AR5) that's equivalent to around 224 million tons of CO2. That's 224 billion kg CO2e, or around 28 kg CO2e for every human on the world, just from the large leaks (not from the ongoing smaller leaks which are >10x as big according to the article). So yeah, go ahead and tell me (and everyone else) to go vegan for a month [1] or make similarly impactful changes just so companies can continue venting methane. To avoid being only negative: The obvious solution would be to require companies to buy emission certificates for those emissions, with a penalty factor that accounts for the probability of detection if they didn't accurately self-report and had to get caught. This would create an immediate incentive to reduce those easily avoidable emissions, and should be relatively easy to implement if we can get accurate enough data from satellites or aircraft. It would also ensure these emissions are accounted for in the emissions trading framework, so we don't emit the allocated amount elsewhere and are then surprised by the unaccounted-for emissions. [1] Assuming I replace 250 kcal from pork per day with Tofu (around 100g of pork which seems to be considered "one serving"), this would be savings of ~1 kg CO2e per day: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/ghg-kcal-poore https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/ghg-kcal-poore
- marliechiller 5y agoAs a side, note, I'd like to point out that you should go vegan predominantly for the moral ethics of killing something for 5 mins of taste pleasure rather than purely environmental concerns (although valid)
- MayeulC 5y ago> you should go vegan Don't force anybody please. As for moral ethics, those are really different depending on where you come from, your current outlook on life, etc. Ethics are not universal. I'm personally 98% vegetarian due to the lesser ecologic impact. It's also healthier, not killing animals, and has a lot of side-benefits. But don't assume the reason you specifically picked will work for everyone.
- cascom 5y agoSeems like a great example where a carbon tax would incentivize the right behaviors.
- parenthesis 5y agoIt's like valgrind for the real world.
- ekanes 5y agoI'm pretty frustrated that we're societally focused on plastic straws and shopping bags when things like this or needless empty flights are happening (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29818050 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29818050)
- qqqwerty 5y agoYou are being overly cynical. Single use plastics are a pollution problem. I spend many hours a year volunteering at beach cleanups to try and help keep these things out of the ocean. It is absolutely absurd that we use single use disposable items that will pollute the environment for thousands of years. I also work in the clean energy industry and have devoted my entire career trying to fight climate change. I fully support efforts to curb single use plastic, and I fully support efforts to fight climate change. There are over 8 billion people in this world, we have more than enough human capacity to try and tackle both problems at once. The limiting factor is government inaction. So if you would like to point fingers, I suggest you aim them towards the politicians that have allowed the Oil and Gas companies to continue to pollute for so long.
- strainer 5y agoYou are being blind. Those campaigns were fig leafs from the outset and if you are interesting in real action on shutting down single use plastic economy, you should know better than to wag your finger at those who complain about how ridiculous focus on carrier bags and tooth picks has been. Those campaigns only antagonise some consumers against the general concept, and gave others a false sense of inclusion and progress. They could never have achieved any practical impact on the single use plastic economy and this is why they got singled out for attention. Since the 90s a great social fuss has been raised over whether feather-light plastic carrier bags are used to help carry a shopping load (and eventually bin the remains). While since then, essentially everyone has rather been forced to continue to buy products which include ever increasing amounts of plastic packaging, amounts which utterly dwarf a couple of bags or straws or toothpicks or whatever the latest prescribed moral obsession is supposed to be. Ever increasingly, small portions of food are sold in thick plastic packets, every individual snack/bar is contained in plastic, and every pack of bars in another layer. It is even increasingly rare and difficult to source tea bags, tissues, and surprising products like toothpaste without plastics manufactured into them. The dissolution of the un-compostable and practically un-recyclable plastics economy, can not wait until everyone agrees to dutifully avoid the latest convenience item where 'effort' is systematically focused. Every little counts -> LITTLE. And that is what the wider industry counts on when it comes to these campaigns. They are nonsense obsessions promoted to waste attention. I spent last year cleaning up a beach too btw - fishing and shipping garbage overwhelmingly.
- PaywallBuster 5y ago> Gas companies simply vented gas from pipelines or other equipment before carrying out repairs or maintenance operations. Not a regular "leak"
- nashashmi 5y agoDon't forget the article is a hit piece on oil gas companies. The rest of it supposition and narratives and anecdotes, not evidence, that promote the premise of the article. In fact there is very little objectivity in the telling of the findings.
- dannyz 5y agoIt is starting to be understood that there is a huge need for global methane measurements. Lot's of companies are starting to (or already have) move into this space, and I've seen several mentioned in the comments here. But I think it is worth mentioning that measuring methane (and other greenhouse gases) from space is an extremely hard problem. The precision/accuracy requirements to be able be able to globally characterize methane sources/sinks, which is one of the goals of TROPOMI (the instrument used here), are extremely stringent. These commercial methane sensors are mostly designed with the goal of identifying sources, rather than rigorously determining their influence on the global methane budget.
- spenrose 5y agoSource paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.06387.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.06387.pdf
- jbkiv 5y agoFirst, hats off to "Laboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l'Environnement". I looked them up, it is a research lab based in France https://www.lsce.ipsl.fr/Phocea/Vie_des_labos/Ast/ast_service.php?id_unit=1 https://www.lsce.ipsl.fr/Phocea/Vie_des_labos/Ast/ast_servic... They do research but also higher education with 60 PhDs at any given time. Compared to US standards they are very small. Our National Labs have probably a budget 1,000 times bigger. It is not a think tank like the ones we have in Washington DC where you just "buy opinions" augmented with political endorsements (= lobbyists ready to "fund the political campaign" of any politician, Republican or Democrat). That shows that good research teams with limited budgets can produce great output. Unfortunately everything is in French, so their audience is limited. As for the culprits we know WHO they are and WHERE they are. But like the war on illegal drugs against Mexican and Colombian cartels we should not forget that they would not exist without consumers. Consumers who are mostly in the US. We can target the polluters in Kazakhstan or anywhere else. The White House will issue a press release "condemning those irresponsible operators" and providing reassurance that "we will do everything we can to bring that activity to a complete stop". But we are consumers, and the US more specifically is a voracious consumer. We have built cities out of nowhere in places where the temperature is so high that you can’t live without A/C. We have golf courses in the middle of the desert and ice hockey teams in places that have seen ice. Our gigantic houses, our culture around freedom (=individual cars and pathetic public transportation systems) Sure we drive a Bolt, a Tesla or a Prius in San Francisco. But it is our second, third or fourth car. The others are pickups or large SUVs to go skiing on weekends. Uber instead of public transportation, private jets for work or extended weekends, vacations with the family on the other side of the world at least 2-4 times/year. Ask our beloved Senator in California, Nancy Pelosi, who commands a military jet when she heads back home from DC for the weekend. I don’t know what the solutions are. Shame the largest consumers? Shame and uncover politicians who condemn the pratices? Heavy taxes on gas (very impopular)? Honestly I don’t think I will witness any significant change in my lifetime. Note: gas in the US is petrol, not natural gas.
- sbmthakur 5y agoIs there an API/webpage available to access this satellite data?
- alexose 5y agoThe specific satellite referred to in the article is Sentinel 5P, and has a website here: https://sentinels.copernicus.eu/web/sentinel/missions/sentinel-5p/data-products https://sentinels.copernicus.eu/web/sentinel/missions/sentin... . Technically the methane product is a combination of data from Sentinel 5P and Sentinel 2. It's available via Google Earth Engine: https://developers.google.com/earth-engine/datasets/catalog/COPERNICUS_S5P_OFFL_L3_CH4?hl=en https://developers.google.com/earth-engine/datasets/catalog/... The resolution is... less than I expected. The GHGSat-D satellite seems to have much better resolution, and has a nice public-facing map here: https://pulse.ghgsat.com/ https://pulse.ghgsat.com/
- smm11 5y agoMaybe it's just me, but I bet that human farts account for the majority of green house emissions. And if vegan, even more so.
- FpUser 5y ago>But remember to reduce your personal carbon footprint! /s Same as taxes. It is us peasants who pay mostly.
- flerchin 5y agoIf we just charge them for the pollution, they'll fix it. The cost of fixing their equipment will actually save them money, but they won't fix it right now because they don't have the activation energy. This is easy, let's do it.
- opensores 5y agoabout a month ago I stopped midway on a x country ski session, for a beer at a commercial venue. they had these natural gas flames in the outdoor seating area (very popular in the US). Nobody else was sitting there; it was a pretty windy and cold night/evening. I noticed a sound and smelled the distinct odor of city natural gas (a sulfur marker element added to the methane). There was a poorly functioning nozzle where the flame had been snuffed by the wind. This had probably been going on for hours if not almost the whole day. (I did manage to reignite the flame, but given that the nozzle wasn't functioning well and the windy conditions, who knows how long that fix lasted). I think key is that populations should be very aware of the problem that strong greenhouse gases cause. NG and petrolium poducers should be required to do a lot of monitoring, and get fined if they are ineffective at catching issues. Commercial venues such as above, should also be very aware of this. Basically, everyone should be aware.