3 ms·
The annoying thing about this is that, if the new California metering rules do end up passing, I will definitely not be installing solar on my roof, because it
by kelnos 5y ago
The annoying thing about this is that, if the new California metering rules do end up passing, I will definitely not be installing solar on my roof, because it will end up either costing more in the long run, or the break-even point will be so far out that it's not worth it to me.
Now, as the article says (or at least hints at), maybe there are better things we can do as a society to reduce carbon emissions than have individuals install solar panels on their house, to the point that it doesn't make sense to subsidize it quite as much as we do today. I don't think I've heard regulators and utilities make that argument, though.
I do agree that the generation and transmission infra needs to be paid for, and if I'm giving the grid excess power instead of money, that reduces the utility's ability to maintain their infra (and PG&E is already lacking in that area). And if I do get much lower utility bills (from a solar installation), then that means that eventually utility rates will have to go up. And then essentially lower-income folks, who can't afford solar panels, will be subsidizing people like me who can... which is not remotely fair.
However, if we do believe that residential rooftop solar is something that we need to be promoting and incentivizing, then the current/old net metering rules need to stay. And to make up the difference on the infra side, one of two things needs to happen: 1) utility prices should go up, and the government should offer subsidies and credits to low-income folks, or 2) the government should just fund maintenance of the grid directly.
- GravitasFailure 5y agoCalifornia requires[0] new construction to have solar now, so while you might not have to worry about installing it you very well may be stuck with a system if you move. I'm not sure I agree with your assertion that increased solar installs will leave less money for grid infrastructure. With the moves away from gas for heating and cooking and the proliferation of electric cars, it seems that demand for residential power is only going to go up with solar offsetting it, so demand on the grid should stay fairly steady with increases in areas that solar doesn't work as well. Higher density housing will also increase energy demands with limited ability to offset the demand with solar. Overall, that should mean income to maintain the grid should hold steady or even go up, though I suppose only time will tell. [0]https://www.energy.ca.gov/news/2018-05/energy-commission-adopts-standards-requiring-solar-systems-new-homes-first https://www.energy.ca.gov/news/2018-05/energy-commission-ado...
- hedora 5y agoYes, but the proposed interconnect rates include a monthly fee if you connect to the grid. The fee is approximately 100% the price of the panels, spread out over 30 years. I'll hopefully be grandfathered in for 20 years, but after that, I plan to just stop paying my electric bill. I imagine such "cord cutting" for new installs will become more common. As a middle ground, I might just opt out of net metering, and pay for gross usage and the line connection. That forces PG&E to take the electrons, which at least screws over the natural gas peaker plants they're building out. However, if current equipment price trends continue it will only make sense to do that out of charity/spite.
- zbrozek 5y agoI have no idea if you're allowed to push the energy back on the grid. You may be better off with batteries to store your excess and use it yourself later. I did that, but I got the batteries for free and did the install myself for less than a hundred dollars.
- sagarm 5y agoThe California requirements can be met with off-site solar, though this is currently being litigated.
- kelnos 5y ago> With the moves away from gas for heating and cooking and the proliferation of electric cars, it seems that demand for residential power is only going to go up with solar offsetting it I see your point with EVs, but the utility (at least here) that provides gas and electric is the same. So a shift from gas to electric for cooking and heating won't really change the amount of money or where it goes (unless electric costs more than gas). Hell, if heating/cooking shifts more toward electric, people could power those off solar, so that shift would be a net negative for the utility's revenue. I don't think I could give up my gas stove, but if I did get solar at my current place, I would likely replace my hot water heater with an electric one the next time it needs replacing, and run it off the panels. Ditto for the furnace, though those tend to have longer replacement cycles than hot water heaters. Certainly if everything moves from gas to electric, then the utility can just stop providing gas entirely, and start dismantling that infrastructure, so sure, over a long time, that would save them money. But I honestly can't see that happening, even in a place like CA, for... a century? More? I think any legislature that mandated people replace their gas appliances with electric would get voted out in a heartbeat. Then again, who knows how popular attitudes will change in the coming decades.
- maxerickson 5y agoWhy not fund the solar panels directly if the goal is to have solar panels? Net metering is a terrible deal for the utility, there's not really anyone that gets a terrible deal if you directly subsidize panels.
- hedora 5y agoIf you did that, poor people could afford panels. Not sure if that's a political advantage or disadvantage out here.