2 ms·
I'm not endorsing the term, but it's the established term of art for what you're talking about. "Amateur science" in particular has its own implications of sho
by zozbot234 5y ago
I'm not endorsing the term, but it's the established term of art for what you're talking about. "Amateur science" in particular has its own implications of shoddy, low-quality work, so that's out too. And "Gentleman scientist", which is the most historically accurate in many ways, is just too classist and sexist for modern sensibilities!
- kragen 5y agoThe "Amateur Scientist" column in Scientific American wasn't about shoddy, low-quality work (though it often was about making do with substandard apparatus), and neither is Bill Beaty's wonderful http://amasci.com/ http://amasci.com/, nor are "radio amateurs" known for shoddy, low-quality work, so I think that term might be salvageable. Beaty's site suggests "science hobbyist" as well. Probably none of "amateur scientist", "science hobbyist", or "citizen scientist" is good enough to serve as a reasonable reputational BATNA for professors considering leaving a university. "Independent researcher", maybe? In the research literature I very rarely see references to "scientists"; that's mostly confined to the vulgar press. Instead it talks about "researchers", "workers", "investigators", or "authors", or until recently "philosophers". So from a shibboleth perspective "citizen scientist" is pretty bad; if you say "I'm a citizen scientist" you're implicitly contradicting your claim of membership by using the exonym.
- zozbot234 5y agoThe real BATNA for professors at a university is a job in the private sector, where PhD's and professorships are a valuable credential and 'independent' publication as part of research reports, etc. might still be possible. More independent research is all well and good, but it would not alter that arrangement significantly.
- kragen 5y agoThat's what the BATNA is right now, but it's disastrous from the perspective of public welfare because it requires you to dedicate most of your mental energy to the job.