6 ms·
A little bit of central planning can go a long way. Nobody was in charge of figuring out how to gracefully shed load at capacity, so when demand went up by 20%,
by skybrian 5y ago
A little bit of central planning can go a long way. Nobody was in charge of figuring out how to gracefully shed load at capacity, so when demand went up by 20%, the system overloaded and latency went through the roof.
Market fundamentalism (we don't need to plan, the market will do it) obviously screwed up here, but it doesn't follow that everything that the American Prospect hates is actually bad.
- nine_k 5y agoThe problem with central planning is that the incentives of the planners are skewed by their position. They are not the ones whose business would be affected by the plans they make, or by failure of these plans. Look at the history of the Soviet Union which pioneered the practice; eventually they developed very intricate workarounds. Look at China with its empty cities built through central planning. Look at the efficiency of the US military spending which goes in a large part through some kind of central planning by DoD. Markets are far from ideal, but alternatives are often even further.
- arrosenberg 5y agoThe Soviet Union and China aren't "a little bit of central planning" though. They're entirely centrally planned, with little to no market influence. Having the markets captured by private actors winds up badly too - that's why "a little bit of a central planning" goes a long way - it can take the rough edges off of Capitalism and structure markets to result in fair, distributed outcomes.
- lmm 5y agoOne could argue that if we actually committed to market fundamentalism it would work, but price-gouging laws prevent the market from addressing this kind of risk.
- pessimizer 5y agoRaising the prices of what has been stocked won't feed any more people, it'll just guarantee that the wealthiest won't go without. If you're talking about raising demand in order to raise supply, that implies that the virus will react to that and retreat accordingly. Or that regulations will be relaxed. Or that people will be paid enough to show up to work sick.
- lmm 5y ago> Raising the prices of what has been stocked won't feed any more people, it'll just guarantee that the wealthiest won't go without. But making it profitable to be the one with stock on hand in an emergency would encourage holding bigger buffers during the good times. > Or that regulations will be relaxed. Or that people will be paid enough to show up to work sick. Or healthy employees will get paid enough where it's worth working double shifts, selling back holiday, delaying retirement... very few people work as hard as they possibly can all the time (and why should they?), if there's truly a desperate need then a correspondingly desperate price can unlock all sorts of capacity.
- thephyber 5y ago> But making it profitable to be the one with stock on hand in an emergency would encourage holding bigger buffers during the good times. This isn’t always true. It is only the case if the long term incentives outweigh the short term incentives. If the good has a long shelf life and it is a good use of the retailer’s capital, sure. Those are not certain conditions. Also, goods can go obsolete. Would it have been a good investment for CircuitCity to keep an extra 1000 units of Microsoft Zune in stock in case there was a pandemic?
- lmm 5y ago> If the good has a long shelf life and it is a good use of the retailer’s capital, sure. Those are not certain conditions. Also, goods can go obsolete. Would it have been a good investment for CircuitCity to keep an extra 1000 units of Microsoft Zune in stock in case there was a pandemic? Those are the kind of questions that markets are great at figuring out, if it wasn't illegal to sell at an actual market-clearing price.
- twblalock 5y agoWhat makes you think any central planners would have done a better job predicting our current shortages than the other market participants?
- skybrian 5y agoSome companies do a decent job of it internally.