3 ms·
This bar is not low at all. Anything involving reward can cause addiction and harm. All of those things you cited are just methods of scheduling rewards. You le
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
This bar is not low at all. Anything involving reward can cause addiction and harm. All of those things you cited are just methods of scheduling rewards. You level up every X amount of time, you get an item every Y amount of time.
These things are not some unforeseen emergent feature, they are deliberately designed. What makes it malicious is the behavior these rewards are designed to create.
An RPG using a leveling system to make sure you can't survive certain challenges until you've progressed enough is not malicious at all.
An RPG that pits players against each other, imposes the same leveling system on players, rates limit their progression with a timer and allows people to reset the timer by paying money essentially turns the game into a spending competition whose goal is to see who can pay some corporation the most money. Not to mention their blatant attempt to form habits in players by giving them daily login rewards and tasks.
- TulliusCicero 5y ago> An RPG using a leveling system to make sure you can't survive certain challenges until you've progressed enough is not malicious at all. I agree with the distinction you're making here -- it can be used to malicious ends, but isn't always -- but saying that it's categorically a "dark pattern" is still making a judgment, and that's what the website is doing. Read the webpage yourself if you don't believe me: https://www.darkpattern.games/pattern/24/invested-endowed-value.html https://www.darkpattern.games/pattern/24/invested-endowed-va... Note that not only does the body text make no distinction between reasonable vs malicious use of leveling systems, the examples make it clear that they consider all forms of this to be tainted: > Galaga Wars > "The more time you play, the more ships you get." > DISGAEA RPG > "Owned character progress and levelling up." Even if you try to say, "well, it's a dark pattern that can be completely non-malicious," well, that's just shitty UX if you're gonna label things misleadingly like that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- p1necone 5y agoThe distinction between your two examples is not in the specific game design techniques. In your first example the game designers are trying to make their game more enjoyable for players. In the second example they're trying to extract more money out of players. Listing a bunch of different game design tools that might be used to try to extract money out of people by a dishonest developer is missing the point because the specific mechanics are irrelevant, as you've pointed out with your examples.