3 ms·
Oh, universities are great! I'm not saying universities should stop existing or that they aren't important. They're very important! But we can't expect them
by kragen 5y ago
Oh, universities are great! I'm not saying universities should stop existing or that they aren't important. They're very important! But we can't expect them to provide unlimited resources for free to anyone who is curious about something. They have to pick and choose who they fund, which means excluding the majority of possible Karikós. Perhaps just as bad, the mechanism consigns many of the most promising researchers to administrative tasks like grantwriting and personnel management instead of science. If you're a PI supervising 30 RAs you aren't going to spend a lot of time at the bench.
And most women who get a Ph.D. sacrifice the chance to have kids in their 20s in the process, which is a big deal for many of them; life isn't easy for "nontraditional" postdocs.
And 95% of people don't live in the US.
Finally, universities aren't omnipotent. Gang Chen, David Gelernter, Aaron Swartz, Steve Kurtz, Star Simpson, and Majid Shahriari were all affiliated with universities, and they were persecuted for their research anyway, resulting in their deaths in two cases.
Also, many of the measures I suggest would substantially ease the path of researchers who want to form a new institution to pool resources, such as a hackerspace or a mail-order DNA synthesis company.
So, I think giving people more freedom to pursue research as they see fit would substantially increase the amount of research that gets done, and so would placing more social value on it.