4 ms·
Your average Karikó would not benefit directly from Universal Basic Income. Not that solving extreme poverty/deprivation while preserving economic freedom and
by zozbot234 5y ago
Your average Karikó would not benefit directly from Universal Basic Income. Not that solving extreme poverty/deprivation while preserving economic freedom and efficiency isn't a good idea for plenty of other reasons, but it's not a free lunch either. The modal UBI recipient will probably be expending their time and effort on training for productive work, not long-term research with no immediate benefits for themselves.
- kragen 5y agoThe modal UBI recipient is not your average Karikó; the modal UBI recipient will probably sit around beating their children and watching music videos on whatever the equivalent of MTV or YouTube is in 02039. No conceivable intervention will turn the majority of the population into inventors and scientists, so we shouldn't try unless it's a low-risk effort. But we can certainly aspire to liberate science from bibliometrics, dollar-auction postdoc rat races, grantwriting, mandatory reporting requirements, and especially prosecution, so that the people who do want to spend their time on advancing human knowledge have the opportunity to do so. And we can work to change the public perception of innovation and research from Frankenstein and Walter White to Edison, Tesla, and Einstein.
- ok_dad 5y agoThat’s a very negative view of humanity. Everyone I know, from phds to blue collar workers, have great things they aspire to, if only they had the time. You must hang out with real losers if that’s what you think is reality, or you must be listening to the media representations of the worst of us.
- kragen 5y agoI have great things I aspire to, too, that I'm not actively working on. Instead I'm wasting my time getting flamed on some toxic website. I guess I'm a real loser! But I don't think I'm much worse than average. At least I don't beat my kids. You can see what people do with total freedom by looking at retirees, the rich, the temporarily unemployed, people on disability, and NEETs. Some of them do the great things they aspire to. Most of them don't. I still think more freedom is a net good.
- yetihehe 5y agoYour problem was that you stated that most people on UBI will resort to beating their children. What is ironic: This is only one anecdote, but the only person I know which perfectly matches your typical child-beater profile, couldn't stand being unproductive on retirement and got back to work at local carpentry shop, as a helper. Not because he needs money, but because he needs something to do.
- kragen 5y agoWhat's "your typical child-beater profile"? I don't think there is one, other than "human" or possibly "male human". Plenty of exceptions even to that. Child abuse is not universal but dishearteningly common.
- yetihehe 5y agoApart from exactly matching what media and popular culture portrays as child-beaters, his daughter confirmed that he abused her many years ago. He also cheated his wife, and done many things which are stupid or considered by popular culture approptiate for what could be called pathology-circles. I don't know how you call such people in english.
- kragen 5y agoPsychopaths?
- keithalewis 5y ago"Doctor, it hurts when I do that."