5 ms·
Why should I care what "anyone who knows anything about this virus" is expecting? The people writing the policies around vaccination are the ones who matter. T
by roenxi 5y ago
Why should I care what "anyone who knows anything about this virus" is expecting? The people writing the policies around vaccination are the ones who matter.
There have been mass firings on the basis that this vaccination will end the pandemic and people who don't get vaccinated are actively harming everyone else. The truth of that claim is far too murky to justify the agressive policies that are being used to force people to get vacinated. Policies which, I note, appear to be deploy what are effectively human rights violations. These are not policieis that should be used. The policy response is what is important here.
- arrrg 5y agoPeople who are not vaccinate are definitely behaving in a deeply antisocial way and enforcing vaccines is very much a justified policy in my eyes, even if “only” to smooth over the transition from pandemic to endemic. To my eyes vaccine mandates are not, in general, human rights violations. They just are not.
- nsxwolf 5y agoTie them down and forcibly inject them then. Have some courage. Quit pussy footing around with economic threats and shaming.
- yetanotherath 5y ago
- thrown939181 5y ago
- spookthesunset 5y ago> To my eyes vaccine mandates are not, in general, human rights violations. They just are not. Are they really though? If vaccines work so damn great why do I still need to wear a mask in a place where everybody is vaccinated? And why did Ontario shut down most of the places that required proof of vaccine during this omicron wave? Shouldn't those places be exempt from shutdowns? If proof of vaccine still requires masking and shutdowns... maybe it isn't a really an effective policy?
- MagnumOpus 5y agoIf stop signs and traffic lights work so dann well why am I being forced to wear a seat belt? If I require a seatbelt even after taking a drivers licence exam, maybe following traffic rules isn’t really an effective policy? One would think that on this forum of all places, people would understand the concept of defence-in-depth. Furrfu…
- spookthesunset 5y agoVaccines are both the seat belt and the airbags. Masks? Those aren’t even close. They are more like rain dances or amulets. Besides why does the government get to decide if a vaccinated person has to wear a mask? Makes no sense. You can add as many layers of defense as you want. Don’t force me to. I’m boosted. I could care less about Covid. If I still have to wear a mask post shot, why the hell did I even bother?
- Spivak 5y ago> Masks? Those aren’t even close. They're to reduce transmission to others. You can call them not good enough but it's a respiratory disease, it's what we've got. The alternative is lockdowns. > Besides why does the government get to decide if a vaccinated person has to wear a mask? Why do they get to decide if an unvaccinated person has to wear a mask? You're simultaneously arguing that vaccines are effective and so masks are pointless but also that vaccines are ineffective. Which is it? > Don’t force me to. I’m boosted. I could care less about Covid. It's not about you. If the only risk was only to yourself then nobody would care. > If I still have to wear a mask post shot, why the hell did I even bother? Because if you get covid you'll have a mild flu instead of being hospitalized or die? You can say it's low chance but 3,000 corpses today I guess were unlucky.
- rastignack 5y ago> People who are not vaccinate are definitely behaving in a deeply antisocial way Are chain smokers antisocial ? What about over eating obese ? I hate risk-adverse fearful societies.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoSecond-hand smoke strikes me as antisocial if produced in an unavoidable setting. Obesity ... seems like an entirely personal matter, except perhaps in children where they might be considered victims. Highly infectious viruses several times more harmful than the usual ones are indeed turning the world upside down. I imagine with time most societies will come to accept such things after they've become endemic for a while.
- rastignack 5y ago> Obesity ... seems like an entirely personal matter Just like vaccination for Covid is personal. Remember that the vaccine does not prevent transmission of omicron. And that if the vaccine works, if an unvaccinated person transmits the virus to a vaccinated one, there should be no risk, right ? Also, obese and overweight people account for 50% of hospitalizations in ICU for Covid in France.
- bavell 5y agoI disagree with every one of your statements. > To my eyes vaccine mandates are not, in general, human rights violations. They just are not. We're talking specifically about the Covid vaccine mandates, not mandates in general. I think there's certainly a serious debate to be had on whether these morally questionable Covid policies are human rights violations.
- jahnu 5y agoPlease define what you mean by ending the pandemic. > human rights violations. Which ones?
- roenxi 5y agoI have no idea what ending the pandemic means. It is a stupid wooly phrase with multiple meanings, often conflicting. That is why I'm unhappy about the policies used to achieve it - whatever it is. > Which ones? Well, looking at a relevant wiki article [0] I'd say the policies I know best (Australia) are bumping up against the articles dealing with freedom of movement, big chunks of articles 18-21 (underlining peaceful association a few time), I'd argue 22-27 - I forget where 'right to earn a living' is but I'm pretty confident it is in thge UDHR somewhere and that is probably in 22-27. At some point (and 2 years is past that point) these philosophical issues like human rights start to matter. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human_Rights#Structure_and_content https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Declaration_of_Human...
- ceejayoz 5y agoAs with every document of this nature, some of the rights outlined may conflict with each other. You wind up having to reconcile those conflicts. For example, Article 29: > Everyone has duties to the community in which alone the free and full development of his personality is possible. > In the exercise of his rights and freedoms, everyone shall be subject only to such limitations as are determined by law solely for the purpose of securing due recognition and respect for the rights and freedoms of others and of meeting the just requirements of morality, public order and the general welfare in a democratic society. It's pretty easy to see vaccination and other public health measures as one of these scenarios. “Articles 28–30 establish… the areas in which the rights of the individual cannot be applied, the duty of the individual to society…”
- bigDinosaur 5y agoDoes that justify how countries like Cuba dealt with HIV? The problem is that public health can reach fairly extreme levels unless it is checked by a strong conception of individual rights. Otherwise you literally get situations like what happened with HIV in Cuba (for those who don't know, HIV positive people were rounded up and sent to institutions as a public health measure to prevent HIV spread). That's why I find it incredibly concerning that people seem to just be happy to suspend individual rights so rapidly. The state of Victoria in Australia recently passed legislation that lets it ignore certain human rights - such as the right to employment - in the face of the pandemic.
- aqme28 5y ago> people who don't get vaccinated are actively harming everyone else. Aren’t they? Hospitals are overflowing and elective procedures cancelled due entirely to people refusing to get vaccinated.
- thrown939181 5y ago
- headsoup 5y agoNo they're not. A) there's more vaccinated in hospital per capita of late. Why aren't we demanding lockdowns again instead of just blaming the "unvaxxed" still B) the unvaxxed still aren't allowed into many places, yet the virus spreads readily C) Why, rather than just "argh unvaxxed lepers!" are we not guiding better health and wellbeing instead? D) a covid case is counted when people are in hospital for any other reason and catch it E) you are counted as unvaxxed during the two week window after getting vaccinated, which is exactly when your immune system is weaker and succeptible to catching a bad case of covid. Interesting how hard it is to find this data, you'd think it would be strongly monitored
- lkbm 5y ago> A) there's more vaccinated in hospital per capita of late. Why aren't we demanding lockdowns again instead of just blaming the "unvaxxed" still Do you have a source for this. This directly conflicts the data I've been seeing. e.g.: https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page#daily https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/covid/covid-19-data.page#daily — weekly hospitalizations peaking at 92/100k for vaccinated vs. 772/100k for unvaccinated.
- _0ffh 5y agoThere was data from Denmark, Germany, and a third place a couple of weeks ago where the share of Omikron infections in the vaccinated was 10-15% points greater than the share in the total population (like 70% vacc/total vs 80% vacc/infected). I've checked one of the original sources (country's public health agency) and it confirmed the claim. To be fair, that could be because there are more restrictions for the unvax'd versus the vax'd.