"You’re considering secondary effects, which would have also happened with the money loaned to the banks." Quote, you. The effects of such a thing simply aren'

"You’re considering secondary effects, which would have also happened with the money loaned to the banks." Quote, you. The effects of such a thing simply aren't the same. Poor people aren't helped when you give folks money at the top - which is, after all, what the taxation policy does. It isn't uncommon to include things that aren't strictly taxation in this.