5 ms·
Chaotic Waterwheel
- Tomte 5y agoIf you're interested in these things: Chaos by James Gleick.
- dylan604 5y ago"We also have made available four video clips of the wheel in action so that students may download them and use motion-tracking software to analyze the wheel’s motion. " I feel like proper use of motion-tracking software could be a class in and of itself outside whatever class this is
- pgtjk 5y agoI feel that adding a simple rack and pinion to the wheel would make the motion vastly more obvious.
- ummwhat 5y agoTheres an option far easier. Just put a rotary encoder on the wheels axle and read that data in directly. Even lazier, use any common DC motor as the axle and the voltage across the terminals will be proportional to velocity. Using video motion tracking is way Overkill here.
- ColinWright 5y agoBeing easy is not the point ... the purpose is to learn how to do things when there isn't an alternative.
- solarmist 5y agoI think this would be more interesting/impressive if they color-coded the buckets so you could see how often they make full circuits.
- smegsicle 5y agothe antidote to those 'satisfying machine' videos
- splittingTimes 5y agoIt's the anxiety inducing waterwheel
- gorgoiler 5y agoThe faucet isn’t exactly isolated as a chaotic component. As it is, it seems to sputter and flow in a highly chaotic way already, never mind what is under it. I am surprised the input flow isn’t first shown to be of a highly consistent flow rate with efforts to ensure a predictable laminar flow. All you’d need is to have the faucet fill a bathtub (a capacitor) which then drained onto the wheel through a flow laminator. You could make one of those using a hose pipe whose far end is stuffed with a tight bundle of plastic drinking straws. If you kick a football painted bright pink at random, I wouldn’t start talking about chaotic pink footballs. Perhaps they couldn’t find any straws?
- lovemenot 5y ago>> Perhaps they couldn’t find any straws? guffaw! guffaw! The physical demo might have been more true to the concept, perhaps. I noticed the same issue as you did. I just came to say that the mild shaming you applied in your comment is unkind and unnecessary. A good point need not be made with ridicule.
- gorgoiler 5y agoThanks for saying this. It made me think twice, even though I didn’t adjust my original post. I wasn’t being anywhere near as unkind as I think you think I was being, but still: language is everything. The guffaw! guffaw! part didn’t land objectively though. You might be doing the same thing of which you accused me. Just saying.
- lovemenot 5y agoYou are welcome. My wording of retort may have been a little too strong. >> I wasn’t being anywhere near as unkind as I think you think I was being, That's not for you to say. I only said I thought the comment was mildly unkind. Neither of us knows how it might have been taken by the actual object persons though. Nor the lurkers. My worry is the cooling effect that a large amount of indirect and minor snark could have on sensitive people. Individually ever-so-slightly, yet en masse broadly deterring them from a culture which seems permeated in it. Such as (to my mind) science.
- wruza 5y agoWould be interesting to see an idealistic 2d (t, angle) or (t, rpm) phase space graph. Which patterns could it have? Is it bounded, boring, hierarchical?
- ummwhat 5y agoThe thing you want is the lorentz attractor and it's such an icon of chaos theory you've likely seen it already.
- MauranKilom 5y agoThe ratio between faucet output to bucket hole diameter and wheel friction is almost certainly a major determinant in how chaotic the overall behavior is. If the buckets drain quickly and the faucet fills them slowly enough (and there is nonzero friction on the wheel axle), you should reach a steady state. Did they document these values anywhere? I couldn't find them immediately.