7 ms·
Row erupts over wreck in US waters identified as Captain Cook’s Endeavour
- srmarm 5y agoInteresting, although the linked article suggests that claim is disputed.
- scoot 5y agoIt's also what the actual headline alludes to, and the subheading makes clear. OP has editorialized the post title to be more clickbaity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adamjb 5y agoOP posted it with the original headline https://web.archive.org/web/20220203013548/https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2022/feb/03/captain-cook-ship-endeavour-identified-confirmed-shipwreck-us-rhode-island https://web.archive.org/web/20220203013548/https://www.thegu... They submitted at 2022-02-03T03:09:31 [0] but this post got re-upped by the mods, as they sometimes do for submissions they feel deserve a second chance [1] [0] as you can confirm by mousing over where it currently, erroneously, says "3 hours" [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11662380 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11662380
- scoot 5y agoCorrect about the re-up (good catch!), but not about the headline, which at the time that it was originally posted here was "Ship fight: row erupts over wreck in US waters identified as Captain Cook’s Endeavour"[1]. (Note the use of the word "identified" in OP's title, not "confirmed" as in the original version of the article that you linked to.) https://web.archive.org/web/20220203024757/https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2022/feb/03/captain-cook-ship-endeavour-identified-confirmed-shipwreck-us-rhode-island https://web.archive.org/web/20220203024757/https://www.thegu...
- dfawcus 5y agoThat piece is interesting in that they suggest how one may probably identify it as being the Endeavour. That was by establishing the timbers are English Oak, as they indicate the other wrecks were built from American or Indian timbers. So if they have done that, then combined with the detail in the recent article about matching to the plans, it may well be reasonable to assign a high probability of it being the Endeavour. So maybe not 'proof', but a reasonable high probability assumption. Unless they find specific unique details from that ship in the wreck, what else could count as 'definite' proof?
- scoot 5y agoApologies, I edit the parent comment to remove mention of the other article with the intention of posting it as a separate comment, around the same time you posted this reply. For context here's what @dfawcus was replying to since I can no longer edit back in: > Here's a related article from 2018 with a bit more historical context: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/sep/19/wreck-of-captain-cooks-hms-endeavour-discovered-off-coast-of-america https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/sep/19/wreck...
- Prcmaker 5y agoThe claim has been deemed premature by the primary research organisation involved in this project. I'd call that a pretty big red flag.
- ummwhat 5y agoBut, rather importantly, was there a Union Jack in the corner of that big red flag?
- chanandler_bong 5y agoOh, very good...
- willyt 5y ago<pedantic nasal voice> Actually as a Royal Navy ship, she would fly a white ensign, not a red ensign. </> (Sorry, couldn't resist)
- soneil 5y agothe Endeavour was sold to private ownership 2 years before she was scuttled. So I do think a red ensign would be appropriate.
- codeduck 5y agoEndeavour flew a red ensign during her service in the Royal Navy, as far as I can determine. The White ensign only became the ensign of the entire Royal Navy in 1864, prior to that it was flown by ships of the White squadron of the Royal Navy. The Red ensign was flown by ships of the Red squadron, as well as by private vessels belonging to British subjects. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_ensign#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_ensign#History
- mellosouls 5y agoActual title: Row erupts over wreck in US waters identified as Captain Cook’s Endeavour
- Anon4Now 5y agoPut Morse on the case. As long as there are clues that a classic education will unravel, he'll have this solved in no time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crhutchins 5y agoThis is a nice hypothesis based on what happened
- jnsie 5y ago> but Rimap’s conclusions will be driven by proper scientific process and not Australian emotions or politics Whether they turn out to be right or wrong, this was classless
- waffle_maniac 5y agoWhat's the difference between unprofessional and classless? It does seem Rimap is in the right here. They have a right to rebuke someone not engaging in good faith.
- jnsie 5y agoIt's one thing to rebuke. It's entirely another to purposefully belittle motivations. It's worse still to do so based on nationality, which is absolutely what was done here. It was crass IMHO
- waffle_maniac 5y agoIt wasn't based on nationality though. That's untrue.
- jnsie 5y ago"Australian emotions or politics" Why Australian emotions or politics. Why not just emotions or politics? It was absolutely based on nationality.
- kingcharles 5y agoRelated: Shackleton's Endurance: The impossible search for the greatest shipwreck https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-60239105 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-60239105
- thereddaikon 5y agoI'm guessing OP has a strong bias on this since the article does not match the title and actually talks about how there is controversy over the claim.
- thingalope 5y agoActually, the Guardian headline says “identified” too, because both of them understand that identification is not necessarily factual. Their headline is saying a fight/row broke out over someone identifying it as such. That can be true without it actually being that ship. Like identifying an unknown particle as something and ultimately being wrong. It doesn’t mean saying someone identified it as such is a certainty of identity. No reason to go after OP here at all. You’re misunderstanding the nuance of the verb “identify” here. There’s an implied “someone has” behind the “identified” in this usage.
- thereddaikon 5y agoIt's misleading through omission. If someone says something has been identified you assume its correct unless they give further information that it might not be. That's an important distinction between the two titles. And I'm not "going after OP", just stating that they have a bias.
- thingalope2 5y agoNo, you don’t, because this is a common journalistic shorthand in English. The article is not reporting truth. It’s reporting that someone claims to have identified it. That distills to a shorthand verb “identified” in journalism a lot, which is not saying “the abstract truth of our existence has established this as so,” it’s saying “such and such group has claimed this is that”. If you think OP is misleading you through omission, again, this is a nuance of journalism that you’re overlooking (and possibly fair for you to overlook because it might be an English-specific thing, I’m unsure). The correct way to read OP’s headline is “someone claims X can be identified as Y”. Again, and please understand this point this time, identified is almost always implicitly prefixed by “someone claims to have”. Once you truly understand that point you’ll realize it’s impossible for you to be misled here. “Body identified as so-and-so” even occasionally changes as more information becomes available. It’s rare, but it does. The verb “to identify” is strongly distinct from “to be” and is centered on the idea that someone is reporting their conclusion which is often opinion. If you think you’re being misled, you’re reading it as “to be,” which is a dangerous idea to carry through the world of news in many ways.
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoThe routes of his 3 journeys never cease to amaze me: https://www.maas.museum/observations/2012/04/17/cooks-three-voyages-of-exploration/ https://www.maas.museum/observations/2012/04/17/cooks-three-... Longitude was from astronomical observations and quite inaccurate, they had little knowledge about the prevailing currents and winds and they we’re doing huge passages away from land. Often having no or little proof that they’d find land they were aiming for.
- jbkiv 5y agoI was indirectly involved in such a discovery in the 80s. A Spanish Galleon had been found in the Atlantic, off the SouthEast coast of the US, by a private, commercial, diving expedition. Gold was found (it may have been the main reason for that expedition). Congratulations were in order. But the question was: who owns that gold? Without getting into a lot of details, if you find a ship floating away or something at the bottom of the ocean, it is yours to keep. Sometimes the owners and passengers are rescued from small sailboats as the sinking is imminent and the craft is sunk as she would present a hazard to navigation. Or that boat is left floating away. I recall such a case in 1994 a sailboat had been abandoned off the coast of North Carolina, the crew had been rescued with a Coast Guard helicopter. That sailboat was found a year later off Cape Hatteras. Bottom line the boat was rescued, her owners were found, and the insurance company had to negotiate a return (they paid the owners for a total loss). That part is important, so let’s go back to that galleon full of gold coins (unlike bitcoins they had appreciated in value over three hundred years). That load was insured by the oldest insurance company at the time, the Insurance Company of North America (INA). INA became CIGNA, then ACE and is now Chubb. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insurance_Company_of_North_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insurance_Company_of_North_Ame... Yes you can mock insurance companies for their archaic systems, flat files and old windows machines. But paper files were kept. They had paid for that loss. Recovering that gold was just a matter of filing legal documents. Negotiations ensued with the underwater gold diggers. A deal was reached.
- mitchdoogle 5y agoWhat's the point of mentioning Bitcoin? Why do people have such an irrational hatred of cryptocurrency? You're not even correct. Bitcoin value has skyrocketed compared to gold, even if you go back 200 years.
- stronglikedan 5y agopeople like to punctuate stories with topical humor sometimes. it's a joke, not a personal attack
- 5y ago