4 ms·
This doesn't make sense. This is actually addressed in the piece. If inductive reasoning is irrelevant for mathematics, why do then mathematicians have excellen
by cubefox 5y ago
This doesn't make sense. This is actually addressed in the piece. If inductive reasoning is irrelevant for mathematics, why do then mathematicians have excellent intuitions about what is true even before they manage to prove it? The quote from the essay:
"[D]espite the fact that error-correction is really hard, publishing actually false results was quite rare because “people’s intuition about what’s true is mysteriously really good.” Because we mostly only try to prove true things, our conclusions are right even when our proofs are wrong."
Deduction can't explain this surprising reliability of mathematical intuition, only induction can. The question the author tries to answer is why the intuitions of mathematicians seem to be more reliable than those of social scientists.
- scoofy 5y agoI mean, again, this is a very messy thing to talk about explicitly because it's playing fast and loose with language. I think the fact that our brains are computing/pattern-recognition machines is the obvious reason computing (deducing) is 'easier'. However, human minds are not actually mysteriously really good at math. Our brains are very clearly broken at some types of mathematical problems. It's just something acedemics tell themselves. When it comes to gambling, large numbers, power laws, etc. The number of times I've had to explain to my friends and family how exponential growth "will appear" with the spread of covid is testament to the fact that our brains don't actually have that math built in, probably because it wasn't particularly important for evolutionary survival and reproduction. The entire field of behavior economics studies this delta specifically. I'd say the deductiveness of a problem, itself, is what makes people have the intuitions. It's vastly easier to use deduction that it is to do induction... because induction is by ultimately unknowable and effectively solipsistic.
- walleeee 5y agoHumans in general may be prone to all sorts of erroneous mathematical reasoning but the speed and consistency with which mathematical concepts reproduce in the minds of mathematicians can justifiably be called mysterious imo, at least until we better understand human language faculties