4 ms·
But there's a difference between "can't get the results a second time" and "didn't even get the results the first time". There isn't even so much a notion of "
by stavros 5y ago
But there's a difference between "can't get the results a second time" and "didn't even get the results the first time".
There isn't even so much a notion of "results", just "logically, Y follows from X". If that's wrong, you don't need to run the experiment again (there is no experiment to run), the logic is just flawed.
- topaz0 5y agoRight -- you need to run the argument again.
- bo1024 5y agoI don’t think it’s quite that simple. A math paper generally says 3 kinds of things: X is true, this is the high level idea of how we can prove X is true, and this is the detailed proof that X is true. As the post mentions, usually when there’s a mistake, X is still true.
- ConceptJunkie 5y agoWell, when there's a mistake found in a proof, the mistake needs to be rectified before the proof can be accepted. There have certainly been proofs that X is true, where X has turned out not to be true based on the fact that there's a mistake in the logic. While it's possible a mistake won't be found, it's a much different problem than running empirical experiments and getting different results.