4 ms·
as a member of the target demographic, all you have to do is provide a version of Modular Grid that doesn't randomly reposition modules for no reason, or which
by tessierashpool 5y ago
as a member of the target demographic, all you have to do is provide a version of Modular Grid that doesn't randomly reposition modules for no reason, or which can display a picture of a cat without moving my entire rack, and I'm in.
but you have to give us this for free. we have to see it and use it right away when we get to the page. I'm not making an account or providing my email address if I don't have to. you have to show me something worth my time to get something from me. other people may not feel that way, but that's where I'm coming from.
anyway — the signal flow feature looks nice, and if you were using pictures of the modules instead of colored circles, I'd be pretty into it. if you made those signal graphs easy to share via Twitter and Reddit, and easy to export to Instagram, I would definitely use them, and I think a lot of other people would too.
I built some pretty complex patches recently and abandoned a whole mini side project documenting them for YouTube because I didn't have a practical way to do the signal graph thing. your signal graph would be perfect for that, but it's got to look better.
I'm sorry to say that in this space the bar for interaction design is low. I love Modular Grid but everybody knows this is true. but Modular Grid shows you pictures of modules. that's where the bar is for the visual design. you have to at least show pictures of modules. people who are thinking about buying stuff like looking at pictures of the stuff that they're thinking about buying.
likewise, when it comes to the YouTube use case, most views on Eurorack videos come from people who are thinking about buying the modules in the videos. if I'm doing a YouTube video showing the signal flow with pictures of modules, I'm getting views, likes, comments, and subscribes — and the comments are saying "what is that app? how do I get it? where do I sign up?" but if it's just these colored circles, the response won't be as strong.
just my opinion.
after reading my own comment I decided to add: building stuff is hard and I respect the work you're putting into this. we in Eurorack definitely need better tools and what you've built looks really awesome.
- polyterative 5y agoThank you for your detailed response. Honestly I have never even thought about the email 'problem' because so far I have prioritized bigger problems but I understand your point perfectly, having a way to play with it without an account or mail data would be useful. It's not super hard given the current implementation too. As of right now, I have no clue where to get the images. Several have advised me to steal data from modular, but I'm a bit reluctant to do so. Honestly, the whole rack management was something I built after a couple of weeks of frustration with modulargrid's lacking abitity to sort modules. Also lately I couldn't dedicate as much time as I would have liked, and my motivation was waning. As a result, I decided to launch it in a usable state, despite the fact that it lacked some features that I wanted to add. That being said, the points you have raised are 100% valid, and I will certainly take into account what you have said in the future. Thanks!