3 ms·
"Trust, but verify" is a semantically null expression that appears to have filtered out of the Soviet Union during arms reduction negotiations, and eagerly take
by ncmncm 5y ago
"Trust, but verify" is a semantically null expression that appears to have filtered out of the Soviet Union during arms reduction negotiations, and eagerly taken up by Reagan administration appointees.
You can only ever trust or verify. "Trust, but verify" is functionally identical to "verify", thus, equivalently, "distrust, therefore verify", with maybe a generous helping of cynicism, doublethink, and official mollification.
- jcelerier 5y ago> "Trust, but verify" is functionally identical to "verify" is there some kind of equivalent of aphantasia but for the feeling of trusting something ?
- sk0g 5y agoIt's like the rule I forget the name of - if a sentence has a but in it, everything before the but is filler :)
- naruhodo 5y agoNot just filler. Everything before the "but" is negated. I'm not racist, but <some racist shit>.
- strken 5y agoThis is trivially stupid. "I like the Corvette, but I'd get it in red" does not mean you hate Corvettes. "I like steak, but only medium or below" does not mean you hate steak.
- ncmncm 5y agoDo you understand what the word "filler" means?
- ncmncm 5y agoSorry, I misread.
- naruhodo 5y ago> I like the Corvette, but You don't like the Corvette. Not that Corvette. However, you like Corvettes in general. Or you only like red Corvettes. > I like steak, but Turn the comma into a period: I like steak. It's unconditional; steak is a big yes for you. Except it's not. You have conditions. So sometimes you like steak and sometimes the opposite. You don't like steak. I think the interpretation of but is not as trivially stupid as you say.
- Terr_ 5y agoThat may be a confusion of different grades of trust. For example, the difference between trusting someone's intent versus trusting their capability or trusting an outcome in an imperfect universe. Alternately, the degree to which one cooperates in advance of getting verification. A "measure" of trust, if you will. Either way, if you insist on an excessively narrow definition of trust as being "never verifying", then yes, they're mutually exclusive... but only because it's circular logic.
- Spivak 5y agoI’ve always taken it to mean “don’t block people you already trust waiting on the verification to come through but do check it eventually.” Bar tabs are a good example of this behavior. Just get your regular a drink and assume their card will go through. In the past checks worked like this too. 1. Let the person start doing what they set out to do. 2. Check if they actually have permission. 3a. If yes, stop. 3b. If no, block their access.
- 62951413 5y ago* I could be a verbatim translation and so lose subtle semantics; "don't expect what you don't inspect" would be idiomatic * Any Soviet saying would come from a culture used to double-speak to survive government oppression and censorship. Which is probably still new to many Americans who remember good old days.
- blooalien 5y ago> "Which is probably still new to many Americans who remember good old days." It's been straight up surreal watching the world turn into the George Orwell "1984" world we were all warned about as children, and seeing the USA (Land of "Freedom") gleefully join in the dystopian "fun".
- Seattle3503 5y ago> ncmncm 1 hour ago | parent | context | flag | on: Don't trust comments "Trust, but verify" is a semantically null expression that appears to have filtered out of the Soviet Union during arms reduction negotiations, and eagerly taken up by Reagan administration appointees. In a modern context it means, look for errors but not deception. It's how I approach code review.
- rodgerd 5y agoI trust the developers I work with to try and build code to spec. I verify their code with testing because humans are fallable.
- gxt 5y agoWould you bother to check something you distrust? I wouldn't, it would be a waste of time.
- ncmncm 5y agoYou don't count your change? I mean, when you get any. That is increasingly rare.
- strken 5y agoIn this vein, "distrust" means you believe they may have shortchanged you, while "trust but verify" means you're also open to the possibility they gave you a $10 instead of a $5.
- gxt 5y agoA prerequisite to trust-but-verify is having the luxury of trust. What you describe is a scenario where you may not afford any. In that case it's verify-or-bust :)
- kingcharles 5y ago"This cat food is new and improved!" "How can it be both NEW and IMPROVED?"