3 ms·
Indeed, that is not at all what a straw man argument is, go look it up. Medicare is not at all comparable to the coverage you get with private health insurance
by colechristensen 5y ago
Indeed, that is not at all what a straw man argument is, go look it up.
Medicare is not at all comparable to the coverage you get with private health insurance.
Single payer healthcare systems have zero or very very low costs to the patient, nothing at all like the deductibles, coinsurance, and out of pocket maximums you find in private health insurance.
You don't really know what you're talking about on several points and it doesn't seem to be worth correcting each one of your misconceptions.
- mindslight 5y agoI said "straw men", not "straw man arguments". Each of my following sentences was a quick refutation of the fallacies you based your argument on. It's almost like they were talking points with no bearing in reality - for example, Medicare is decidedly distinct from the VA. It's difficult to have a discussion with someone who is drawing assertions from an alternate reality. It's also funny you said I don't know anything about Medicare given that I handled my father's healthcare for several years. There were definitely deductibles, "coinsurance" (aka percentage-based deductibles), and out of pocket maximums for Parts A, B, and D. I straight up said I'd prefer market based solutions, to actually address the administrative cancer that is responsible for ballooning healthcare costs - in what other industry are vendors allowed to keep prices secret and then send arbitrary bills afterwards based on how they feel? But I have seen no credible attempts for reform by the other Party, instead deferring to the absolutely insane status quo. And no, a few executive orders to publish fictitious chargemasters don't count - I'm talking real reform like requiring providers to set a single price schedule regardless of who is paying. Until there is a credible alternative plan for industry reform, then unfortunately M4A is the only plan addressing the insanity of the current system.